Why Is Aamir Khan Such a Pretentious Prick

Once upon a time in India, Lagaan released.

The film was a smash hit, was sent as our choice for the Oscars (but couldn’t win, as the jury grew old and died during the interval) and Aamir Khan suddenly became the thinking man’s conscience. The guy who would never attend film awards because he didn’t believe in them, suddenly seemed to be jumping up and down the red carpet, promoting his film. But of course, he was doing it for the nation.

When Lagaan lost out to No Man’s Land, Aamir Khan told the press that the other film deserved to win. When I saw it, said Khan, I knew that it was better than ours. From that moment on, Aamir Khan has somehow projected and marketed himself as the voice of the nation/youth/continent/solar system.

And it’s fucking annoying.

*

Alright, so he chooses to do one movie at a time, reads his scripts, and does extensive preparation for it. But all that is fucking expected from an actor in the first place. Just because ours is a hare-brained industry, doesn’t make someone a goddamn Socrates.

A few months before the release of Rang De Basanti, Aamir Khan sat with the Narmada Bachao Andolan protesters to speak up for their rights. Since then, there has been no word of his involvement with the issue whatsoever.

He then made a film on Mangal Pandey, and has been on a Bhagat Singh trip since, telling the nation what’s right, and what’s offensive. In Taare Zameen Par, he showed us how we are all a cruel, insensitive nation that doesn’t know how to deal with special children. In 3 Idiots, he showed us what is wrong with our education system. In PK, he showed us the problems with religion and godmen.

And tactful and insightful that our media is, we made him the voice of the nation. Aamir Khan tells the nation not to litter. Aamir Khan tells the nation to be nice to foreigners. Aamir Khan tells the nation to be nice to foreigners.

Aamir Khan is a thinking man. How? Because all his films have long shots of him staring into the distance, thinking about the welfare of the cosmos. Aamir Khan is a perfectionist. Why? Because he undergoes a physical transformation for every role (which, as any theatre actor will tell you, is the fucking basic thing to do. Also, he gets paid crores for every film). Aamir Khan is a socially aware star. How? Because he blogs about issues.

However, as we all know, even Vishwamitra’s penance was disturbed. So Aamir Khan, the ever-aware thinking man’s Gautam Buddha slipped out of character and blogged about Shah Rukh Khan licking his toes while he sat on his table.

And of course, there is Satyameva Jayate. Now, I personally have no problems with the show. A star like Aamir Khan talking about issues that we Indians never bother to speak about, is commendable. Kudos.

I also have no problem with him projecting himself as this new-age Carl Shehnanigan who tells the nation how to live – much of an actor’s image comes from this. It is no different from Salman Khan being the large-hearted bhai, Ranveer Singh being a horny guy, and Honey Singh the nation’s Mahalingam. I have no problems with that.

satyameva jayate
Look at my tears…so pure, so pristine. Just like my soul. Which is pure white. Just like the clouds there. I am the sun. Sun and clouds. Deep.

My only problem is with Aamir Khan’s opinions on other artists. You see, Mr. Perfectionist doesn’t give a fuck about other artists. His work is sublime and pure and unadulterated and heavenly. The rest can go fuck themselves.

amir-stya1
Can you see the concern in my eyes? No? Well, that’s none of my concern. I am sensitive. I hope you can sense my sensitivity.

Take for example the controversy regarding 3 Idiots.

Now, even though Chetan Bhagat is the Rakhi Sawant of Indian literature, he wrote the book and sold millions, and no one can take that away from him. If you’ve read 5 Point Someone, and watched 3 Idiots, and you possess the IQ of a garden lizard, you’ll know that the film is more or less an adaptation of the book. However, since it is Bollywood (and fuck writers!), Bhagat wasn’t given opening credits. He raked up the issue and Vidhu Vinod Chopra asked a journalist to ‘Shut Up’. Which is at least an honest response.

Mr. Khan, however, using his special 8th Sense, somehow had it all figured out. He told Bhagat off in public, calling him a cheapskate who will do anything for publicity. Which is fine, till someone asked him if he’s read the book. To which his response was – ‘Ahem, no.’

How the fuck do you know that it isn’t an adaptation, if you haven’t even read the goddamn book? But Aamir Khan, yo. Intellectual actor.

When he released Delhi Belly, he appeared on Aap Ki Adalat (that classy, artful show with a completely non-creepy looking host), and justified the language in the film. His logic was, the youth of the nation today talk in that manner. If you can not stand such language, please don’t watch the film. All good.

Now, the AIB controversy. Since our media has no fucking work, they went and asked Aamir Khan, the brahmaguru of wisdom, what he thought. Aamir Khan first looked at the sky, blinked seven times, sipped some water, and then gave out his thoughts. That the show was offensive, hurt people’s sentiments, blah blah blah.

But then, here’s the key – HE HASN’T WATCHED THE FUCKING SHOW.

If you haven’t watched the show, and someone randomly told you there were jokes on body shape, sexuality, and religion without providing any context, it’s the partial truth. You’re like the blind man of Hindustan who held the elephant’s ass and thought that’s what an elephant looks like.

But no. Aamir Khan ko kaun samjhaye? He is the voice of the cosmos.

The universe works in perfect motion because he approves of it. Every time Aamir Khan sheds a tear, a kid in Africa gets cured of AIDS.

It’s bloody annoying.

*

Dear Aamir Khan, This isn’t the 60s. Where you could do a few patriotic movies and become a national hero. The audience you deal with is thirty years younger to you, a completely different generation.

They understand subtleties, read between the lines, and can tell an actor from a chutiya. Just because you did regressive shit for 20 years, and suddenly conscience struck you like lightning, doesn’t mean the rest of the nation is a bunch of chimpanzees.

Also, like Russel Peters said, you are an actor. You appear on the set, mouth lines written by others, get numerous takes to perfect your craft, and get paid a bomb for it. Which is all fine.

But just like you’re an artist, there are others too. Who are attempting to make an honest living by pursuing what they think is art. If you really are an artist, at least have the fucking decency to look up their work before commenting.

Like I said, you’re not fooling anybody. This is a generation that sees through bullshit. And right now, for all your decades of carefully constructed PR, you come across as an aging douchebag.

I hope you aren’t offended by this blog. But if you are, I hope you at least read it before getting offended.

 

735 thoughts on “Why Is Aamir Khan Such a Pretentious Prick

  1. I usually agree with your views but not this time. He is a bollywood actor. Pretentious is another name of Bollywood. How can you crucify him for that. Let him be that but at least he is doing some decent work and providing some meaningful entertainment. Never felt my money is being wasted after seeing his movie (leave dhoom3). The 3 idiots Chetan Bhagat Saga was just plain stupid. They should have give him credit. Don’t agree with the AIB comment. He did mention clearly that his comments are based on few clipping he has seen and conversation with Arjun Kapoor and Karan Johar. He did have have the knowledge of what is AIB Roast all about. That’s his view of it. What he said sound correct for someone who will feel offended by the roast. Someone can be offended by just watching part of it and can have a view. That’s what the case.

    Like

    1. even AIB roast very clearly warned in the programme before they started that it’s going to be nasty so we warn you if you can’t handle it then leave.. as well as the youtube video clearly mentions right at the beginning 18+, adult content.. so Aamir gets by with saying that i had clearly warned people i’m making an adult movie and AIB doesn’t in spite of warning people..hypocrisy and convenience hits a new high with this whole thing.

      Like

    2. Really? Using the same logic, Bhaag DK Bose played on all televisions throughout the country. Even today, little kids dance to the song on reality shows. Surely that must offend you as well?

      Like

    3. You’re not getting him. Basically amir khan always tries to portrait himself as only meaningful actor in bollywood and the way he promotes his movies is like by doing things on some social issues which will project himself as youth icon ( but he does this only at the time of promotions) and secondly, sometimes he comments on that issues as well which he doesn’t have any idea about.
      So, like we all know, he commented on AIB that it was a violence show and he doesn’t like vulgar jokes then what about Delhi belly? Wasn’t that movie promoting violence? The film was full of vulgarity.
      He was just taking moral high ground by giving that statement but he didn’t realise that he was contradicting himself .

      Like

  2. This article is so unfair. Just because an individual has done “regressive shit” for twenty years, does it automatically disqualify him from voicing an opinion, right or wrong? Doesn’t one have the right to evolve? Why hold him hostage to his or her past beliefs or actions? The guy has an opinion and he voices it. Let us leave it at that, why haul him over the coals? Everybody is opinionated, you and I included. Just like the article’s opinion of the 60s generation – a bunch of morons devoid of brains and subtleties. But then that is the writer’s opinion – one can debate that but that doesn’t give somebody the right to demean the writer or call him names. So let him be.

    Like

    1. Sangram: No body is talking about giving opinion is wrong. Read the article again. His opinions without reading 5 point someone and watching AIB Roast is what is wrong. He gave totally opposite opinion when it came to Delhi Belly. Do you think a person who has such a huge following has the liberty to be a hypocrite when it comes to other’s work? That is a concern. And celebs like Aamir should be more respectful to other artists and responsible to what they utter in public. You are being judged for what you do or say.

      Like

      1. Peeyush: I have based my comments on the article as a whole. I have read the article and I am sure you have done it too. The article not only judges for what he is now but also for what he was, which I felt was not fair. As far as AIB is concerned he did mention that his knowledge of AIB was from the conversation that he had with Arjun Kapoor and Karan Johar who had participated in it. Moreover he said he did see some clippings but could not watch the whole show. And he did not like it. So his comments are based on what he saw and heard from the people who participated in AIB and from the clippings. And nowhere was he being disrespectful to any artist. He simply mentioned that he as an artist wouldn’t do it. For Delhi Belly that he made it known to the general public that the movie would contain language that some might find offensive. The movie therefore is rated “A”. Legally he did whatever was possible to restrict the viewing age of the audience. Yes when you talk of 5 point someone, the credit should have gone to Chetan Bhagat. Aamir was wrong there.

        Like

        1. 1. AIB Roast had a disclaimer, both in written and verbal (several times by Karan Johar)
          2. Released only on YouTube, where ‘Adults’ could see it with their will, unlike releasing it in theatres
          3. Bhag DK Bose, was it restricted for any audience on TV or the internet? I don’t recall
          He has all the rights to go verbose about his point out view, but they shouldn’t contradict according to one’s convenience. He clearly said ‘Sex Comedy’ is what the generation likes, during the release of Delhi Belly and asked people to watch American Sitcoms to get an idea.
          PS: I do like Satyamev Jayate

          Like

          1. Mudit: AIB had a disclaimer. Well good for them. When I said that Delhi Belly had an A certification it didn’t mean that AIB didn’t have one. All that I wanted to say was that Aamir did everything possible to ensure that the movie was watched by adults only. As for the song “Bhag DK Bose”, it was approved by the Censor Board and therefore could be played anywhere. Why should the onus be on Aamir? And he saying things like “sex comedy” being liked by this generation, I am not aware of any such comment made by Aamir. My only issue with this article was that it raves and rants against an individual who is supposed to be intolerant and an hypocrite. The article many a time, smacks of the same – unforgiving and strident.

            Like

  3. Freaking awesome !!! This is exactly how I feel/have felt over the years and I have never been able to explain why to my friends who worship him !!! Very articulate and, like I said, freaking awesome !!!

    Like

  4. The new douche bag of B-World, aspiring to replace Manoj Kumar and take the mantle of Sanksari Babu Alok Nath. That hurt harder than the roast, Ouch!!!! Loove this to death
    Every time Aamir Khan sheds a tear, a kid in Africa gets cured of AIDS.

    Like

  5. I am so glad that someone has had the rationality to voice opinion about an actor who is claimed to be a perfectionist, and inspire of doing his homework cries each and every fucking time on the cameras when he hears the stories of the victims (for the nth time) on his show.
    Moral policing is not what people are looking forward from him! (With such hypocrisy)
    Probably the reason, why he as an individual could never connect with the people. Only his well crafted characters did.
    In the meanwhile, someone please send him the DVDs of Mela and Baazi.

    Like

  6. Awesome stuff Hriday. you were at your ranting best with this one! I think you write best when you are angry. Think about it. The entire AIB knokout debate can be replied to with Voltaire’s (about whom i know nothing else) famous line ” i may not agree with what you are saying, but i will defend to my death your right to say it” . Aamir Khan starred in Dhoom 3, and lost all rights to any claims about being an artist.

    Like

  7. He is the only actor who at least had the guts to bring us Indians’ insecurities,superstition and stupidity to the public. Who doesn’t always focus on bullshit fairy-tale-happily-ever-after movies like SRK or salman. And when you say he doesn’t follow up on the movements he attended after the movies, what do you want him to do ? give up his career?
    What have you done? How many minds have you changed? Have you taken an actual stand on anything? or u just hide behind screen and post “fucking” things?
    Don’t sit and blame. May be he didn’t continue but he started it at least. If he started it, we should finish it. Nation is not his responsibility. He used his status to bring the problems to front and we as a nation have to work on it. but not until people think like you do. Open up your mind and see it from other perspectives too.

    Like

    1. “Who doesn’t always focus on bullshit fairy-tale-happily-ever-after movies like SRK or salman”
      Ghajini was bullshit, Dhoom 3 was the shit of the anaerobic bacteria that thrive on bullshit, and Mela was so shitty that if you poured bullshit across the realm of the movie, it would clean it up.
      Aamir khan is not the conscience of the industry, he is not “Art” cinema, he’s just an A-list actor who acted in some films with good scripts.

      Like

    2. I never get the ‘What have you done?” logic. So only people who have done something in the field get to speak about it, right? So the Prime Minister does something, and then talks about it, analyses it, and praises/criticises himself. Cricketers play the matches and then come home and write articles for the newspapers themselves?

      Grow up, man. He works in the public domain, and I have the right to voice my opinion.

      And I usually don’t dignify immature ‘What have YOU done’ comments, but I must say, this is what I do – I WRITE. I have been spending nearly a decade voicing my opinions. I stand up for what I think is right, and criticise what I think is wrong. Have been doing it for eight years now, and every once in a while, I have to tolerate idiots like you who drop in, read ONE article, and dish out the oldest cliche in Indian society – ‘Woh sab toh theek hai, lekin what have YOU done?’.

      Grow up.

      Liked by 1 person

    3. WRITERS do a LOT. Just like Aamir Khan, they too just might end up raising issues of social relevance in voicing their opinion. But the difference lies in the nature of the opinion which rather than pretentiousness is characterized by brutal honesty and passion. So ya they initiate awareness, they make people think and rethink, question and analyse. Just imagine, if just like you everyone starts “doing something” and no one “does nothing”, we will (ironically) end up living in Zombieland with dead men walking all around.
      PS: Yes writers too can be pretentious but this piece of writing doesn’t seem so to me. I also realize writing is only one of the means of initiating awareness. However all I am trying to do here is build a case for writers.

      Like

  8. Hi ,

    I actually never read blogs, but i read this one, you have written all your views without knowing someone personally its like the same way as your elephant example.

    second thing every person has there own views on everything going around in this world doesn’t mean he is correct and you are wrong, and its not wrong to express there thoughts, its the same way you have expressed :-). I guess because you dont like him;-)

    Third thing this guy “Aamir Khan”, i ain’t his diehard fan either, but i think he is standing up and bringing awareness about so many issues and wrath’s we are facing these days. When our so called politicians are mummmmmm about it, they are appointed to clean up the society i guess. Its like that quote “when some one starts doing good work, there are 100 others who want to pull them down”.

    Its just like you wanted to write something so you thought will take someone and write about him with some facts. I would like to put this question to you ” Aamir khan did atleast something to bring awareness or worked towards the betterment of the society,outside his entertainment world, what you did??? !

    oh you wrote this shit, to pull down someone, chalo anyways you to have right to express your feelings and frustration. To clarify one thing i dint say you are wrong at all. you just expressed your thoughts, kuddos!!!

    Like

    1. I understand what you’re saying. I would request you to please google Heartranjan Satyamev Jayate. I had written about the show, and praised it quite a lot. But juxtaposing every argument with ‘At least he did SMJ’ is a flawed argument.

      But anyway, thank you for your comments. Have a wonderful day! Thanks for taking the time out to leave a comment. 🙂

      Like

      1. Perhaps you should have think more before writing all this. You could have think “Why did a person, who raises many social issues (unlike others) said something like this?”. Just think, how much difficult it is to do social service. And just after one Apparent mistake, your anger came out.
        Isn’t it similar to the phrase “You do 100 good things; it matters to no one. You do one mistake, people criticizes you.”; even if that mistake is not a mistake, just apparent. I googled “Heartranjan Satyamev Jayate” and found your blog where you have mentioned that he spent 7 crores in the promotion of “Satyamev Jayate”. Now, why would a person like that do that?
        You praised him in that post and now you are writing bad things about him. Doesn’t that make YOU a hypocrite?

        He just put his viewpoint that he didn’t like it. Its his freedom of speech, that’s it. Why are you criticizing him?
        He may not be the voice of India (or whatever) but he is a far better soul than you are. And that makes you having no right to criticize him unless you are at his level. If you think that someone wiser than you have done a mistake, think again and again about that.

        Watch this

        Comparing it with Delly Belly. I am a person who is comfortable in speaking abusive words but maintaining the respect for others simultaneously. I have watched Delly Belly full movie, but I closed that AIB video in the middle. It’s not that I can’t hear that. It’s not even the fact that “Delly Belly have used that language, why can’t AIB?”. It’s just that I felt that they are doing it for coolness sake. Even you must know that speaking abusive words doesn’t make you a dude, but I didn’t get this feeling by watching the AIB video.

        Also, Delly Belly was released in theatres and people had complete choice not to go there. But AIB was on youtube and people are tempted to see that. Now, you might say people should control that. They can’t, what to do? I know it’s their mistake but what to do? That’s where the responsibility of society comes. If you care about them, you should take decisions according to them and make them adapt to the right thing gradually. If you don’t care about them and will just do whatever you want, you will lose respect at least from me.

        Delly Belly is like: they are doing non-sense at home with a board outside “come only if you can face that language”. People can control going there.
        AIB: Non-sense in the public with the same board. Now people get attracted to it.

        What’s right and what’s wrong is not very clear (at least in terms of law). But just think this. Can you imagine that AIB guy do something like what Aamir Khan did in Satyamev Jayate? I am not sure, but I think no. He won’t have that level of responsibility.

        You have to maintain a balance between freedom of speech and responsibilities towards society. For example, you may not want to shout abusive words in public just for the sake of it because that is not good for people.
        Again, I am not blaming you for writing this. There is a thick line between what and what not should be done. But I don’t want you to realize that you should not have posted this, after turning so many people against him.

        Please let me know if I’m wrong somewhere.

        Like

  9. Well said mate! Completely agree with Mr. Khan being a hypocrite. I always wonder, why he had to go about having a surrogate child and not adopted a needy girl child for all his dramebaazi.
    AIB is good and it needs to be there. Maybe Aamir needs to be the next Roast

    Like

  10. Do you mean that you father was an idiot by saying this generation is smarter, not like 60’s. Chetan Bhagat himself signed the contract that his name will come at end credits in 3 idiots, but I think you didn’t even read about that controversy and saying what you heard in media. DK Bose and AIB is very different. DK Bose didn’t get personal at any one. Aamir said that if you are insulting any one that is bad. What they said about Farida Jalal, is unacceptable. When Salman Khan told called them in midnight they edited the video before uploading it, that mean they have used many people name just to make a vulgar joke without even taking prior permission. Just because Salman is powerful and Farida Jalal is not doesn’t mean they can take anyone for granted. If you call this an art, I doubt your understanding of art. And Peter Russel, he makes money just by vulgar comments on people and countries. He can’t even stand up for a minute without making obscene and vulgar comments. Everyone can have their own opinion and they can express that freely. Ain’t it ?

    Like

    1. Relax, man. I meant that the present generation is more media savvy, they are more connected to each other, to issues. It is more difficult to penetrate their consciousness, as compared to the earlier generations. There are actually Communication theories on this subject. Google the Magic Needle theory, which deals with the dissemination of information, how it has changed over the years, and its impact.

      Sorry for sound so boring! 🙂

      Thanks for the comment. I hope you read some of my other stuff too. Have a nice day.

      Like

  11. Mr Aamir is not an artist, he doesn’t even act properly. If Salman ‘Bhai’ scores a F in acting then media tagged mr perfectionist gets away getting a D in acting. He has a good eye for good scripts though unlike other two Khans.
    He is the baba ramdev of bollywood, self proclaimed self-righteous hero.

    Like

  12. I think mr. whomsoever wrote this. Its because of people like you …that good people’s work is undervalued and their confidence broken down. Please take your raving and ranting somewhere else…and if I was to rate your blog. I would give it -50 for poor writing, raving and ranting….no real content and general angst. So unless you can create something like that I suggest that you stop pointing fingers. Look at your own life and take stock of that .

    Thanks

    Like

      1. Just one question: Have you done anything for society or you’d rather just spend time belittling efforts of others? Instead of writing the blog and responding to comments, its perhaps too much to expect good social deed from you. Just remember one thing, given a choice, universe (and all your readers) will definitely choose Amir over you.

        Like

    1. Thank you for saying what I felt. I have read poison pieces but this is the worst — and Aamir does NOT deserve such vituperation from one of the many bloggers that clog cyberspace. I have been a fan of Aamir since late nineties, specifically Sarfarosh. He was the reason I returned to Hindi films after many years. And though some of his film choices since then have been less than satisfactory, I am still happy with the fact that he is a part of Hindi cinema while I am alive. I feel about him like I did about Sanjeev Kumar ( who died too young).

      And this blogger Heartranjan or whatever writes about Aamir having done regressive cinema for 20 years and then waking up. EXCUSE ME? Mr. Blogger, you don’t know your Hindi cinema or you wouldn’t be writing like this. To recapitulate a bit–1988– QSQT 1st official film though there was a Holi in 1984 & a noir-ish Raakh made earlier, released later ( 1989). Then 1990 to mid-nineties, mostly forgettable cinema (like the regressive hit Dil from 1990) save for a cute DHKMN ( starring the brat Pooja who is now busy attacking Aamir, just like her crazy dad — and poor Aamir didn’t even mention Alia the Bhat girl present at the Roast). And a sweet and funny JJWS ( ’92). Then a string of turkeys some half-dozen.

      But from mid-nineties to present day Aamir has done fairly decent sometimes very good cinema.. AHAT, HHRPK ( a lovely children’s film),, Ghulam , 1947Earth, Rangeela, the terrific Sarfarosh in 1999, Lagaan in 2001. Yes, there was the terrible Mela in 2000 and a loud Ishq a couple of years before that.But from 2005, Aamir has done plenty of good work, right up to the present. Dhoom 3 was a potboiler that was entertaining enough to many of us. So mid nineties to present day–Aamir has been doing pretty decent cinema for twenty of his nearly twenty seven years as an adult actor ( not to forget film maker)

      Sorry to take up your precious space recounting Aamir’s filmography in short– but you chose to write ill-informed BS, you will get it back from furious fans. And Aamir did not read the original of 3 idiots because he needed to read only the script, altered from the original story ( for which Bhagat was paid the agreed sum). Bhagat had no probs till he attended 3 i premiere– till somebody wised him up to the fact that he had sold himself cheaply with credit somewhere way below. Why blame Aamir. And why pick on Aamir for that dog story? SRK has done plenty of trolling of Aamir right through nineties and Aamir simply gave it back through his blog– but expectedly simple simon idiot Aamir didn’t have the Dilli chaalaaki of SRK to do a proper job of his prank.

      And this AIB thing–does this trashy show warrant so much defense at the expense of Aamir? And who cares for loudmouth Russel Peters except for South Bombay snobs and the like? Aamir did say (in his 6 minute video at the Youth meet on 10th feb), that he had seen only two clips and heard plenty about the show from good friend Karan. He felt he had seen enough, was appalled, said so when asked at the function. SO? Does Aamir deserve to be roasted by the social media through two bloody weeks?

      NO!

      Aamir’s Satyamev Jayate is something I have watched right from 2012 to 3rd season. I have been in touch with director Satyajit Bhatkal through fb, given suggestions, some of which were even accepted. Clearly this show is more important to many of us. Scoff if you wish who cares for generalizing smartass bloggers. Your little post will get its footfalls and clicks– but it will soon be part of google history. Aamir the sincere idiot will survive you cynics.

      Like

  13. Well, this is case with every other actor … Be it Deepika padukone having issues with her cleavage being covered in a video one year after it was posted… Which happened just before release of her film or shehnaz treasurywala’s open letter to all powerful men of india before release of her film…

    Amir is just another actor… It is upto people to know when, whom and what to follow …!

    Like

  14. My my! How unforgiving we are when we accuse another of being unforgiving!

    So the ‘older’ generation was a bunch of chimps was it… one that hadn’t the sense to read between the lines or see the subtext without being pounded on the head with a mallet?

    Do you know how you sound?

    Incidentally, is ‘fucking’ your favorite adjective? May I dare- coming from the 60’s moronic generation that I do- to recommend the use of a thesaurus? The same adjective (and one so gross to boot) used multiple times in a post seems mighty unimaginative to me.

    But then, I am a chimp as you’ve so kindly pointed out. Funny, I never noticed it!

    Very instructive piece of writing. I must commend you for it. All except the repeated adjective… which indeed if it was.

    I usually don’t comment on rants of this nature… but I just had to make an exception for you.

    Like

    1. Hi.

      I must say you completely misunderstood me. I meant that people are not chimpanzees. That this generation is more connected to people, to issues, more aware. In the earlier generations, information was one-way, more restricted, and the people who controlled the flows of information were very few. The fact that you are reading and commenting on an article without even knowing me is testimony to that fact.

      I am sorry if it seemed like I was offensive to the older generation. And about the ‘f’ word, well, yeah, I tend to go overboard with it.

      Thanks for the comment, nonetheless. And have a nice day! 🙂

      Like

  15. I dont mean to be rude at all….but Mr. Amir Khan is a great actor..and I really dont think he deserves the criticism metted out to him for his work. So please tone it down…and appreciate his work as his honest expression and thats all…

    Like

    1. Hi,

      I really liked Satyamev Jayate, and watched all the three seasons. I also reviewed it positively on this very blog.

      But doing one good TV show doesn’t absolve one of everything else, nor does it make someone holier-than-thou.

      That was my point. Thanks for the comment! 🙂

      Like

  16. I completely agree with you on the AIB roast point and throughout the article you have been saying he didnt watch it, which is again stupid on his part. Now have you fucking watched his comments?? He says he finds it offensive but THERE SHOULD BE NO BAN FORGET ABOUT THE HOOLIGANS PUSHING FOR IT.

    So after reading all that in your article, I wanna ask you “Are you a SRK fan in hindsight?”
    Coz questioning and ridiculing his whole career on just expressing his opinion on the AIB roast(I dont agree with his opinion) makes you sound even more stupid.

    I understand you are an English speaking-Russel Peters ,Seth Rogen worshipping young man like me, who likes to discredits our film industry even though we dont know Jack shit about it.
    But understand this ” If he has done regressive shit for 20 years as u call it, I dont know what SRK, Salman or Akshay Kumar have done honestly. Amitabh Bachhan also did “Lal Baadshah”, so he did Regressive shit too. So there is no good actor this country ever produced. Oh wait, I forgot, you are Tarantino Loving- Game of thrones fan, so u would consider Nawazuddin siddiqui and Irfan khan as good and REAL actors only. But wait they Did GUNDAY and KICK, so again no good actors.

    Well if our film industry is that shitty and you are so “I know all”, please stop writing about Uday Chopra and Aamir Khan and using this Shitty industry as the source of your posts, coz this makes you a Pretentious and Hypocrite prick.Write about Breaking Bad and Homeland , if you understand all regressive shit and theatre, for anyone will care Fuckall if you write about them.

    The point is – He had an opinion and like you , I disagree. But like you said if you possess the IQ of a garden lizard, you would see that he is currently still the Best Actor , Mainstream around and unlike SRK he uses his position to do an Ad for the Tourism Ministry , and a show which affects at least a few people, rather than taking his pants off and cracking silly jokes in an award show. He earns crores yes, but you would be surprised to know that He earns much less than many and none of them do better film. Why?? Coz he likes to at least half descent movies and some social work. Not that he cant earn money, well he proves who is who every December..

    So I conclude you dont have a problem with his opinion (which would have been fine), you are just a plane HATER, as you mentioned Lagaan , TZP and Satyamev Jayte for reasons I wont understand, unless they are cheap shots. Or maybe you are just a prick and he shows you the mirror, every time.

    I expected a lot when you wrote the Uday chopra piece. You are the only one Blogger I followed, and here you are still Immature. Grow up mate.

    Like

    1. Come on, man. I am tired of this SRK vs Aamir crap.

      Yes, Aamir Khan is a better actor. I love how he takes the time out to produce smaller budget movies (Peepli Live, Jaane Tu Ya Jaane Na, Delhi Belly). I think he is probably the most sensible among the lot, but the world isn’t black and white, is it?

      And contrary to your belief, I don’t write about Bollywood too much, and certainly not to ‘hog’ cheap hits. I have nothing against SMJ, and think it’s a pretty neat show. I still don’t get how I was immature by writing this, but anyway, here’s the crux of what I wanted to say.

      I have no problem with AK being the sensitive, concerned citizen. Just that he’s going about it in a rather insufferable, pretentious, holier-than-thou manner.

      That it all seems very hollow, very well-thoughtout.

      Like

      1. @Heartranjan: I admire you for not denying that you are an Aamir Hater. But pardon me I wont give you an Oscar for calling Milk is white,when you say in ur defense that you Praised Satyamev Jaite and praising him as an actor , coz thats a fact. Now coming to your post, I dont have a wrath against you being so judgmental and that too wrong. I think its a basic Indian problem that we cant be happy and make everyone happy. We see Happy new Year , Humshakals and Chennai Express in the name of entertainment and everyone is like” Why the fuck they cant be realistic?” And when someone takes ur nerve on social issues, he is the “I know all”. Dafuq you want man??

        A person doing social movies and program mes doesnt mean “HE IS PREACHING”. He said he found it offensive and blah blah (which I dont agree with), but its his OPINION. He didnt say ban them , he said he opposes the ban. Why cant he voice his opinion on an issue even if his wrong?? I mean you are voicing yours here , and that too in an Extraordinarily fucking stupid way.

        Even if you want him Hollow and not incorporating his principles, it is not a law that he comment on the AIB roast.

        Now why I called you Immature?? Well, I blog myself , and I think you pretty well know that when a blog has a central Idea and a topic, there are arguments assertions and reasoning. There is very less room for redundant data. When I saw ur post, I thought it was about his Hypocritic opinion about the AIB thing. But when you are questioning his career that he has done REGRESSIVE SHIT for 20 years and He has no right to teach that all parents are idiots in TZP and alll, man you sound like a Fucktard, to be honest.
        The character he plays in TZP Preaches the right and wrong, not HIM. Like Heath Ledger as Joker was awesome, not the Heath Ledger the person. He was a Druggie.

        And you have a fucking problem with him doing the Tourism Industry ad for only you know reasons and then you claim he earns crores. So basically you dont want him to the Tourism ad and do some Shitty game show , so that later you can crucify himself , as a money whore. Wow man, your conscience is up your ass, I must say.

        Thats why your article is crap and I am disappointed. As I said and proved how alll this data and you Nullifying his carrer is irrelevant to the AIB post and even Aamir vocing his opinion is mutually exclusive of all his good work.

        So again man grow up or write in proper context. And in addition to ths small movies like Peepli and all I am Proud of the movies like RDB, TZP, Dil chahta hai and Lagaan (another insignificant input in this shitty post).

        Well haters hate and Potatoes Potate mate, but atleast bash him on something Bashable rather than writing a post out of compulsion or making a fool out of urself. Like the SRK fans do to console themselves as they know who is better.

        Like

  17. I find your blog astonishing .. wat actually you are trying to defend and whom u r calling a Hypocrite voice of nation … wat aamir said was absolutely correct .. media has social responsibilities .. now days kids watch more of you tube and less of tv ..Russel peter must be doing very good with all jokes he have but it doest mean u do anything and categorize it as art… if it is then it is bullshitt … wat u tell to small or young kids who abuse in front of you .. i guess u tell them abusing is wrong its not social these are not signs of a civilized literate man… or you tell them oooh great u r becoming the future russel peters.I guess we Indians are hypocrite trying to copy the western glamour so much that even the negative parts also feels right. Aamir is doing way more social awareness than AIB ,sacrificed way more than AIB can ever .. wat actually u r trying to give to the nation …. u r sounding as if u’ve relieved this world out of its miseries and tensions .. at least aamir can shed his tears stood up for issues … Wat are you standing for?? you can only make fun out of it…and can criticize people like aamir for these cheap jokes … have u ever wrote a blog appreciating his social work.. no.. why ?? .. because u think he is a hypocrite actor and trying to be the voice of nation… He is not blind he is aware… u will not go on the wrong path if u r aware of it ….. I dont have any problem with anything in the roast but from my point it should not be released on youtube socially.You can write a blog on me now because i have my own opinion like aamir like you.

    Like

    1. Thank you for your wise words. You said what I wanted to say…but I’ve already said a lot. This stupid AIB Roast-Aamir thing has gone on too long, and this blogpost seems the culmination. All Aamir-haters for whatever reason and supposed liberals ( and funny thing is I consider myself a liberal secular Indian ) are awash with cheering pointing the way to this blog. But glad to see some sensible comments. Now to get out of this sick space, to a saner real world.

      Like

  18. Yet another ‘nobody’ trying to piggy back on a celebrity to get more followers for a biased, ill-informed blog. While I am no Aamir fan, this blog makes no sense, but then again only if you call a mainstream actor ” a pretentious prick” will people read this rubbish! Cheers.

    Like

  19. This was bound to happen.
    Its all because of the AIB. Brilliant as they are, they have unknowingly started a completely unwanted revolution of wannabe comics and satirists who have no idea what they are trying to say. String together a few “fuck’s”, use some second hand similes that people with the average IQ level of a fruitbat can understand (see, if I can do it, anyone can do it) …….aaaaaAAND……
    pick on a celebrity (how original eh?). The bigger the better, the more outrageous the better.
    AIB could manage just those two clowns on stage, so Mr. Big-Bad-I’m-So-Intelligent-and-Outraged blogger wants to go one step ahead. So he picks on Mr. Perfectionist.
    If ever there was a match made in heaven, it was this:
    Mr. PerfectShit on Mr. Perfectionist
    Good going dickhead. You must have enoough ‘hits’ now to quench your Hypocrisy needs for the day?

    Like

    1. Are you done?

      Done ranting? Feel good?

      Ok, here’s the deal. I have been blogging since 2008, long before AIB even began. I write about subjects ranging from politics, to sports, to spirituality, films.

      You, my friend, are a lazy bugger who likes to rest on lazy connections. If you used your brain, and fingers, and scrolled down the page, you’d get a better idea.

      But wait! I am sure you are in Africa, inventing the cure for Ebola. Sorry to disturb you. You don’t have to read this, you know. And you don’t have to comment either.

      Have a lovely day! Sorry about how bitter the blog made you feel. I hope my apology is able to repair some of the damage.

      Like

      1. Dude, I’m going to keep this short-ish, seeing that you have so many asses to lick through your comments to the comments.
        Y’know what this is right? This is a stale-mate (no puns intended) – you with your right to expression, this being your blog and all that and we the commenters having the right to express our disgust at your disgust. So, there ain’t nobody winning this game.
        Having said that, I know you’ve been “blogging since 2008” on a range of serious issues etc. etc.Good For You! (pat on the head)
        I have read your earlier posts (some are surprisingly tolerable) but the comment here was purely on this post and the tone of the narrative.
        Well anyway, ‘lazy bugger’ that I am what with all these ‘lazy connections’ (make up your mind, who’s lazy me or my connections?) I better get to doing some productive work eh?
        fyi, the cure for Ebola has already been tested and found to be doing pretty well in field trials. It wasn’t invented in Africa, and not by me (just clarifying).
        Since that is done, I guess I’ll have to do something about this swine flu.
        You still there?
        Just go already. Dont mind me. I’m working.

        Like

  20. Came here via an FB share. Here’s why I think this post smacks of prejudice. And why I think AK shooting himself in the foot with the AIB criticism has allowed haters to air it while sounding believable. Let’s address your key points.

    — Lagaan: “The guy who would never attend film awards because he didn’t believe in them, suddenly seemed to be jumping up and down the red carpet, promoting his film”.

    AK was asked why he wouldn’t attend Indian award ceremonies but did attend Oscars. If I remember correctly, he said he wasn’t against award ceremonies per se (which would be kind of stupid) but thought the Indian ones lacked credibility. Given the all-too-common talk about how awards in the 90s were bought by the YRF-SRK camp, his position wasn’t as outrageous, was it?

    — RDB: “A few months before the release of Rang De Basanti, Aamir Khan sat with the Narmada Bachao Andolan protesters to speak up for their rights. Since then, there has been no word of his involvement with the issue whatsoever.”

    The act of speaking up for the rights of NBA was a streak of activism. Something that has shown up consistently since (in an infotainment sort of way through some of his films’ messages or outright through shows such as Satyamev Jayete). The same thing you’ve apparently hated him for all through.

    — Mangal Pandey/TZP: “He then made a film on Mangal Pandey, and has been on a Bhagat Singh trip since, telling the nation what’s right, and what’s offensive. In Taare Zameen Par, he showed us how we are all a cruel, insensitive nation that doesn’t know how to deal with special children.”

    Ignoring that fact that Mangal Pandey came _before_ RDB, I don’t see what’s wrong in showing us how we deal with special children.

    — “I also have no problem with him projecting himself as this new-age Carl Shehnanigan who tells the nation how to live… My only problem is with Aamir Khan’s opinions on other artists.”

    But then why were you earlier ranting about the way he approached his characters or how he did his films?

    — “Take for example the controversy regarding 3 Idiots… If you possess the IQ of a garden lizard, you’ll know that the film is more or less an adaptation of the book… since it is Bollywood, Bhagat wasn’t given opening credits”.

    Hopelessly mixed-up logic. In that, the primary dispute involved contracts that VVP uploaded on his website that clearly showed whether and how credit was to be given. Had the issue gone to court, even the judge would have taken more to decide who was in the wrong. For you, it was easy: “Since it is Bollywood, Bhagat wasn’t given opening credits.” Not to mention CB eventually apologized to AK over the issue.

    — Finally, on AIB. his comments prima facie were hypocritical (though contrary to your assertion, he did say he watched parts of it). But here’s food for thought. While AK didn’t elaborate why exactly he found it “violent”, except to say gaalis wouldn’t cut it with him, for all you know, he could have been referring to the part where they made fun of followers of religion (Christianity, mainly). And which actually is a debatable issue, freedom fanatics notwithstanding. Even assuming he was referring only to gaalis, and thus was indulging in double-speak, it nowhere lends credibility to your intense hatred of his thinking-man avatar (as is obvious in your numerous sarcastic “voice-of-the-cosmos” kinda adjectives).

    Like

    1. This blogger is completely unaware of facts. Aamir sat on Narmada protest AFTER RDB was released on Jan 26 2006. RDB had run its course almost by the time this controversy happened in March 2006. So The next film , May release Fanaa was affected. Aamir’s act was a mix of impulse and some earlier prodding from his cousin Mansoor who had been involved in Narmada Andolan. Long story. Aamir’s a well meaning guy, too simple for the smartass networked generation to comprehend. He will survive.

      Like

  21. Feel sorry for the person who has written this…… I knew from the moment I read the first line that its about the AIB thing…… So stop bullshitting n come to point…….I watched AIB roast n I liked it n I don’t see any problem with people abusing each other…. hell we do that everyday…. But I will not call any elder( father/ grandpa/uncle) abuses things if they don’t like it…. Its there view and I respect them…. If u say youth talk like this in there day to day life then react to anyone’s reaction also in same way…. Stop bashing someone just because he kept his views…..

    Like

  22. Whilst applauding your efforts in writing such a blog, will you please understand the viewpoint of his interview, i am sure you didn’t…just because you have free space on the Internet, and time in your hand you can not post any bull crap…well who are you to object somebody’s freedom of speech???on one hand we handle Arnab who talks only and never listens has all the freedom to talk non-sense everyday…so stop being a hypocrite and jealous on somebody’s success and following…you can write million blogs ridiculing all the famous people in this country, but still you will not have an iota of following Aamir has…so shun away from cheap tactics and get on with your blogging on politicians instead..in simple words i would call you an envious neanderthal.

    Like

      1. Hahaha, exactly!

        I have stopped responding to such comments, man. What can you say? For such buggers, I need to have the fan following that Aamir does, and only then will I be considered worthy on commenting on such a great man.

        It’s the Indian logic of ‘Par tune kya kiya?’. We will never get rid of it.

        Like

    1. Well, who are you to object this post? 🙂 what a judgemental, biased reply, there is only personal insults – typical fanboy.

      Like

  23. AIB was funny? Yes. It was at times but in overall vulgarity has taken over comedy. So if your kids listens to those words and starts using them infront of your parents . Is that ok for you? ok.. They have mentioned it as an adult show but how it can be taken care on youtube. Leave about kids. irrespective of age, Its not at all fair to make a sexual and filthy comment on a old women fairda zalal. Would you accept if your fellow frd uses foul langauge on old women. Is that called funny?

    no body objects when it funny and not offensenive. few people may get offended because of comments on few things but vulgairty should be condemnable anytime.

    Like

    1. well you said it Abhishek, vulgarity is not synonymous to humor, even Russel Peters dirty swine who migrated to Canada should understand just by putting up accent he can’t walk away clean with his vulgarity….shame on you Mr.Peters you had to run away from this country because your dad could not earn his living here…think of him atleast before you start the next show, stop ridiculing his accent and his proclivities.

      Like

        1. I really am….with Morons like you and those stupid people who are supporting you….but let me tell you please migrate to Pakistan and make those guys as moronish as you are, at least we will have free Kashmir

          Like

          1. What the fuck does this article have to do with pakistan and kashmir? like seriously.. Just reading your comments is going to make the rest of the world lose a bit of their sanity..

            Like

    2. So you thought the AIB show, which by the way, you can only view on the internet by choice, was vulgar. What did you think about Aamir’s song in Delhi Belly – Bhaag BoseDK, which was blaring on every radio station and had little kids singing it??

      Like

  24. What a stupid article and who is the writer of this article to judge someone else’s work ? Amir Khan is doing and saying, within his powers, what he feels is right for the country ! What have you done for the nation ?

    Like

    1. *Aamir
      You should stop commenting blind nonsense on the internet. That will be good for the country too.
      P.s Aamir Khan is ironically judging someone else’s work too. Get those gears in your noggin working buddy.

      Like

    2. “who is the writer of this article to judge someone else’s work”. Dude, you just contradicted yourself by posting this comment. Who are you to judge the author’s work?
      He never forced you to read it. And what’s with this “What have you done for the nation?” crap?
      Read the article again dude, that’s not even the main question here.

      Like

    1. What a fucking idiot!

      Kahaan se aate yaar, yeh chutiye?

      Why do I need to do something for the nation to comment on him? So only people who do stuff should comment? You know who else believed in that? Adolf Fucking Hitler.

      Don’t you get tired of making the same argument over and over again. Going by your logic, journalists should first spend 20 years in politics and then analyse news, sports journalists should win Olympic medals, and film critics should first direct films, and then be able to review them.

      Grow up a fucking brain!

      Like

      1. He is using his fame to create social change through a very innovative & informative programme “Satyamev Jayate”, Do you think, the issues raised in this TV series are wrong? Regarding AIB, he has presented his opinion, which may not align with your INTELLIGENT BRAIN, so who are you to call him pretentious ? The foul language used in your article, shows that you have a very intelligent brain but it would be better to keep the intelligence to yourself !

        Like

        1. SOCIAL CHANGE you say.. he is just sensationalising problems of the nation to fill his pockets. charges more than 3 crores per episode. and not even half of what happens on the sets is aired on the tv. I know this because i am a doctor and for the episode of malpractice by doctors, more than 5 friends of mine were present in the studio and they presented their views which would have totally changed the way the entire issue was percieved.. So basically everything is skewed to portray what HE(the almighty AAMIR KHAN) believes is right and what will make the issue more sensational.

          And if he really is so patriotic and wants to contribute to social change why charge such a bomb to create “awareness”. why not do it for free. or better why not donate it to the cause that is talking about.

          Coz when it comes to us doctors, he expects us to be gods and treat patients for free..

          two face bastard!

          Like

        2. What does a person’s language have anything to do with ones intelligence. i don’t get it. You think ‘intelligent’ people like stephen hawking, Einstein, “Aamir Khan” and others do not use foul language.. Bloody fucking idiotic statements.. Oh i guess my IQ just dropped 30 pts.

          Like

  25. I enjoyed reading this. hahahaha. I just spoke to Aamir (he me buddies) and he had this to say: “I am completely offended now that I read the entire story.” Please be nice to my pal 🙂

    Like

  26. Its easy to judge, write blogs,comment on people, have a problem in what they do
    what have you done
    and btw watever he does people do follow him
    reading your post wont make any effect

    your hours of writing was in complete vain
    so STFU

    Like

    1. “your hours of writing was in complete vain” – I don’t think he wrote it to diminish Amir’s popularity. It is just his view. If you have a counter argument, you are welcome to give it here.

      Like

  27. HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA… Apne toh Pura Balatkar kar diya iss ka….he is fooling people since Holi, he is the won who has Illegitimately born Son (Jaan) out side marriage, he destroyed the life of jasica hines (Mother of Jaan) he even kidnap his own brother because of Money, gave him wrong medicine, tried to prove him ill man, mental…. now he is trying to show his double stantards, even his own Father kicked out him from his own house and did court case against him and also Called him ”Nalayak Beta” , also he is the one who abused, targeted Legends like King of Bollywood SRK and Shehneshah of Bollywood BigB but still he behaves as he is such a good guy while he is the most insecure, Creditchor & shit person B’wood has ever seen…

    Like

  28. Not that I support Aamir or this article (although I like him as an actor but that has nothing to do with liking him as a person) … but anyone could clearly tell that the article is written out of frustration… and anything written out of frustration is biased and points out only the negatives (Also, you are welcome to abuse me too, just because I humbly beg to give my honest opinion on your article)

    Like

      1. Thanks heartranjan. I did not want to leave an impression that I meant you were a psycho. It was a deliberate reference to some of your replies to some other comments I saw. You too have a lovely day 🙂

        Like

    1. Frustration, misery, whatever you call it, have always been wells of creativity and new ideas for as back as humans have been drawing stuff inside caves. I don’t think hopping around lush green meadows you are ever going to write consciousness altering material.

      Peace.

      Like

  29. Haha! Interesting take on the scenario. Aamir Khan certainly seems like a douche and a hypocrite. Problem is, people need to understand that vulgarity is like alcohol in our country – there is always an age limit until which one should stay away from it. As long as this is not brought to children, I think comedians can get away with anything on stage. This also includes Delhi Belly.

    The article is definitely insightful, as I always thought Aamir Khan was off his rocker, in hindsight.

    Like

  30. I think this blog is totally biased and the blogger is trying to conceive some important points to divert public opinion. Some of the things you have said make little sense. What do you mean when you say that ‘this is not the 60’s generation’? Were people stupid during that time? Did you really watch his complete reply to AIB roast issue? You say here that he hasn’t watched the roast and he still commented upon it. In fact, in his interview, he says that he watched a brief clip or two from the show and he also heard Karan Johar making some jokes about it and from that he decided that he doesn’t want to watch the full show as he doesn’t like these kinds of shows. He said himself that a movie like Delhi Belly was produced by him which had a lot of abusive language used in it. He obtained an adult certificate for it so that people know this movie has some adult content in form of language or some scenes in it. After that, it was public’s decision to watch it or not.
    This guy has done some very important movies like Taare Zameen Par, Lagaan, 3 Idiots and PK which have helped us understand some important social issues better. Nobody can deny the impact Satyamev Jayate has had on common people. It has raised a lot of awareness in people regarding some very very important issues and there actually has been some marginal improvement regarding these problems and a good share of credit for this success goes to Satyamev Jayate. So what’s your problem with him? I don’t care what kind of movies he did when he was in his 20’s or 30’s, I don’t care if he attended some award functions, I don’t care if he gets an Oscar or some other award. The thing that matters to me is that he is using his fame (which in turn gives him a power to attract people) for a nicer India, a better society. He is using his celebrity status to bring to the attention of the people, the social and economical issues which have been a great hindering factor for the progress of our nation and society. After all, we don’t have many people like him who are ready to invest their time or money to do something nice for the nation. So what’s wrong in calling him the voice of our nation? What’s wrong if he is trying to be the image of our nation?
    I think we should appreciate the work he is doing and instead of blaming him, let’s try to spread all the good work he has started and let’s try to make India stronger and better!

    Like

    1. Dude. Please read my blog on Satyameva Jayate. It’s sad how you typed out such a long comment, but don’t make any sense at all.

      I never said it’s a bad show, or that he shouldn’t do it. Please stop taking everything at face-value. Learn to read between the lines.

      Like

      1. It’s not just about Satyamev Jayate. You have said it here that you respect the work he has done through Satyamev Jayate. Here I am talking about the impact he has on our younger generation. Why do you think that he shouldn’t be the face or voice of our nation for all the good work he has done or is doing? Look, I don’t have anything personal against you and don’t want to be rude and start a war here. I am sorry if my comments offended you. But honestly, to me it looks like you didn’t see his interview regarding the AIB issue properly. Your statements regarding the same are not 100% correct. I see that a lot of people follow you and it’s good that you are writing about such topics which are important to be discussed. Then again, if there are a lot of people following you, isn’t it your responsibility to get all the facts 100% correct and then write them down so that the people get a full picture rather than a biased one? These are just my personal views. I am ready to accept all the criticism on it. I hope you get my point.

        Like

  31. 1. There seems to be a wave of ignorant-self-made-prententious-ftw-culture happening around. One group does the roast,one guy opposes it, guys who seem not be offended by the roast seem to be offended by those who did get offended and raised their voice.. that is so fucking hypocritical too.
    2. The Roast was epic, it is not new and many waves it was a lame ripoff of the comedy genre and various shows in the U.S, But what they did was great… and it will open up a new scene here in india.

    3. There seems to be pointless debates on it everywhere, but that is OK. but what is not is AIB cant be banned and I will agree with AK on this.

    4. You write a blog and obviously your font is bolder than the ones in the comments below. But that’s how democracy works.

    Simply said, If you liked the roast,stop instigating hate of those who did in the name of rationality .. LET IT BE… That is even more ironical
    if you hated the roast, stop hating those who do ..LET IT BE.

    You can shout all you want… just not in my ears intentionally..

    Like

    1. Hey, in my defence, I didn’t shout in your ears. One of your friends must have shared it on your FB page. Please direct your anger there! 😀

      On a lighter note, you are free to disagree with me. That’s cool.

      Thanks for the comment! 🙂

      Like

      1. @heartranjan ..

        true that! you didn’t…

        you mistook my words. your blog is a reflection of your thoughts after aamir’s response.. .. although I disagree with you … having read your blog.. i am directly asking you to think about what I said… LET IT BE…

        Yeah.. chill out bro.. good to have different opinions..

        Like

  32. Mr. HeartRanjan.. your writing skills are good.. probably you can be a writer yourself someday like Chetan! But this also shows.. how much vella time you have to write on a person who “acts” hard…does a bit for the society.. be it any form.. you an call it advertising.. but atleast he does that am sure.. you don’t and have not ever. In one of the episodes of SMJ on garbage he said that we all should separate wet garbage from dry one. Logical.. right.. did you even attempt to do it once in your home or even knew about it before???? I did not! But have made a conscious effort to do it. So Mr. blog writer.. keep on writing that is your democratic right.. but at least write with some brains not just for the heck of writing one blog daily!

    Like

    1. Wow.

      Such a powerful, thought-provoking reply. You should get a Pulitzer just for that comment.

      How many other blogs have you read of mine by the way?

      Oh, wait. Aamir fan, are you? 🙂

      Like

    2. And sir, have you ever. Just because your idol does it or gives the appearance of doing it, does not put you in a better position than others. And really what do you know that the blogger did not separate their garbage? Don’t be so conceited.

      Like

  33. Well written man! It is so damn hilarious! And a reminder for everyone against the roast – “AIB had clearly explained what a roast is, AIB clearly said not to watch it if you can’t handle it! Its a ROAST got damn it!” And fuck the censor board certificates man! Do they even ask for an identity card and verify the age when you enter a movie theatre?! And for the nth time, its a fucking roast!

    Like

  34. what amir told in context of aib knockout was just how HE felt and also he STARTED the speech by telling he didnt watch the entire show,but a few clips. he didnt ask anyone to not see or protest against it or anything. He just said how he felt. Doesnt that come under freedom of speech?

    Also taking side of Russel Peters’ statement is pretty immature. If Amir shud keep his mouth shut being an actor, then Russel should not even be allowed to make such a statement

    Like

  35. Hahaha. You have literally written down an internal hate monologue I have had for Aamir for years. These privileged chuts have never had the balls to write, create or come up with original work ever in their lives. Always making other people do the hard work and then choosing stuff that befits their image/ propaganda. Even if they do create anything, profit and mass appeal are the two things that govern these people. So in that regard these people are never going to push the envelope. What AIB and TVF have done is start a fucking scene man. An Interesting one.

    Like

  36. You just got butthurt that other chutiyas (AIB) from the same breed as you got ‘roasted’ by Aamir Khan! I see where you are coming from!

    Like

  37. This article is so misguided, which is a pity, because there is a trace of humour in it.

    Aamir Khan clearly stated that his views were about his friends and people he knows personally and what they told him they did, not about the AIB team. There’s absolutely nothing wrong with either his OPINION or him making them known. Also, he criticized the acts, not the people themselves; unlike this article, which is blatantly ad hominem.

    The fact that he gets paid for what he does doesn’t take anything away from him; just like the fact the Sachin Tendulkar gets paid millions doesn’t take away from the fact that he’s brilliant.

    Like

  38. There’s something wrong with you bro. Why are you so hard on people?

    Aamir Khan is a different person now, a soft guy. Besides, anybody who watches clips and not the show will feel exactly the same what Aamir did. He had the decency enough to say it “clearly” first that he hasn’t watched it.

    Like

  39. Damn! This reminds me of all the comment bashing on any random youtube videos. Just an extended version.
    Although, I agree Aamir is quite pretentious but most of what he does (Movies, Satyameva Jayate) has some meaning to it unlike any other A-lister. So he gets my respect.

    Like

  40. I think the writer should hear what aamir khan has said about the roast properly.
    He clearly mentions that “he” doesn’t like that kind of humour so he didn’t watch it because its not his taste or whatever. He isn’t forcing anyone to listen to his opinions, the media asked him so he gave one. There is nothing wrong in that. Calling someone pretentious just because she/he thinks that way makes you pretentious.
    Moreover I think Russell Peters was also giving his opinion and that’s fair. But there was no need to get aggressive telling aamir “to mind his business”.
    Who made him the spokesperson and why should he not be minding his own business.

    Everyone has opinions and we should learn to respect each and every one of them no matter how fiercely it goes against one’s principles.

    Like

  41. I have no idea who you are, and don’t even care what you have done for the country. But writing something just for the sake of writing is a pity.

    You bring up his film Delhi Belly. Please tell me if the movie was insulting to anyone? Now compare that to AIB where they had a joke on jerking off to Farida Jalal, something about Anil Kapoor and what not. Now take a time capsule and go back to see if both the situations match up.

    You call Aamir Khan as pretentious, but to be honest you lot aren’t any different. In fact the whole country is (including me). All you have done here is picked up a few points from his interview, twisted it according to yourself and blurted it out here. No one raised a single question when AIB were putting their other videos on Youtube because they didn’t offend anyone (read insulting to anyone), but lo and behold, one well known guy raises a point against something and everyone is after him now.

    Please stick to watching Bhai ki movies. There is no point of view in that stuff, and I am sure you would prefer that to something/someone which has a point of view.

    Like

    1. “You lot.”
      Go ahead, put everyone else into a category to make yourself look better.
      What a righteous guy! with oh, what a righteous comment!

      Like

  42. I don’t see Amir not liking AIB roast as such a big issue. Nahi pasand toh nahi pasand.
    Dude, you are like. ” chutiya ” is a gaali ” maa-bhen stuff ” is also gaali, they are equivalent? Well probably. Language and expressions make a ton of difference how something is said.
    This was a lame post, I won’t call you a chutiya for rest of your life for one shit post. I’ll just move on and enjoy a better post from you.
    It looks like you are just jelly, are you a jelly ?

    Like

  43. Yes, you are right, he is a half-aged half-brained actor, with probably less insights or even ability to drive insights from happenings in this cosmos than the current younger junta. Yes, he should not be making comments without even knowing what is it that he is commenting on.
    But, I still wouldn’t criticize him as such. I still think he does more good than bad, and certainly more good than majority of this country’s all-style-bollywood-population.
    Even though we now have a much younger junta with a much higher literacy rate and ability to read between the lines etc. etc. than before, we can’t still ignore the fact that there is an even larger junta who are still the herd-following blind-sided fools. And what do you think would work with them? A column in a newspaper or a qualified journalist on TV telling them about these issues with the whole basis to their argument and the ability to comment, or Aamir Khan saying the exact same thing maybe without knowing all behind why is he saying this?
    The latter right? So then, what’s the harm? He is after all an influential person in our country, he commands the respect of the nation (be it justified or not), and when he speaks – people listen. So, as long as he is able to get the message across to people (even if as just a mouthpiece), I don’t think we should mind his lack of intellectual capabilities.
    I think the real problem would be when his half-brain makes him pipe the rats the wrong way 😛

    Like

  44. You sir are a genius !
    Please excuse my free unwarranted advice- Don’t reply to the dimwits who can’t understand context if it hit them in their face. You will end up wasting your precious energy on them when it can be put to better use on more top notch blogs …;)
    way to go…

    Like

    1. Just read what you typed and say it aloud “I am not an opinionated prick for calling everyone who has a different opinion than me dimwits, but aamir is one for simply stating his opinion and making it clear that this was his opinion alone”.

      Like

  45. “If you’ve read 5 Point Someone, and watched 3 Idiots, and you possess the IQ of a garden lizard, you’ll know that the film is more or less an adaptation of the book “. I BEG TO DEFER SIR. 3 IDIOTS IS A GANG RAPED VERSION OF 5 POINT SOMEONE WHERE THE ONLY SIMILARITY TO THE BOOK IS 3 FRIENDS APPARENTLY DOING ENGINEERING AND IT ENDS THERE. Calling Chetan Bhagat the Rakhi Sawant of Indian Literature is like calling Virender Sehwag the Shahid Afridi of Test Cricket. It sounds ludicrous actually. I’m pretty sure that our blogger isn’t an engineer. So where were we…? yeah Aamir Khan…

    Like

  46. if its the job of every fucking actor to study and select good scripts dont you fucking feel that youd have sane movies in the theatres?? other than in ending uop seein auto rickshaws in germany!
    You have a problem with somebody’s opinion you pin him on that period! that’s your bloody freedom of speech and you have every fucking right to do so!
    The fact that you sub plot his movies as a carpet space to spill abuses or build a character is your fucking ego doing the work.
    If he has a problem with AIB let it be what the fuck Lagaan and 3 idiots got to do with it mate..
    Honestly.. i loved your one liners 😀

    Like

  47. I feel that Team AIB, Karan-Arjun & Ranvir tried to do a Russel Peters during the roast, which not all of us would accept because of various reasons and it’s reasonable to not find it cool as well, the roast nevertheless was creative, humorous and should never have been removed of websites or criticized about the way it’s been.

    And about AK’s comments on AIB, I don’t find his lines most-appropriate or even believe him true to “I-have-not-watch-it” thingy. About his opinion on this kind of show, you also have the right to agree or disagree with him.

    Talking about this letter, the writer, rather :P, he/ she seems to have been nurturing some personal grudges against AK and for a longer period so. Through this letter, he/ she just smashes out all the good work Aamir did in all these previous years. I find this guy utterly wayward with the explanations and also as he/ she attempts to be witty with explicit, forced & unneeded efforts; yeah indeed the extra effort shows in your letter. 😛 I have to tell you Mr. Author that, we all have the right to get satirical, sarcastic, ironical to a certain degree but don’t need to ruin facts in order to do so.

    My pick for author’s utter Non-sensers are:

    1.” Did regressive shit for 20 years.”
    I think you are probably an SRK fan and thus been blinded by his (SRK’s) masterpieces; Shahrukh who would hardly have a no non-sense flick under his belt for more than a decade now (Chake De was last, Mind It!!!). OK, even if you are not a Shahrukh admirer , I would really urge you to please check out the movies Aamir’s done over the years (yeah, barring a few, name Dhoom-III). And please note that as unlike Aamir did, please watch them before commenting next time. Thanks in advance for this. 😛

    2. “Physical transformation for every role (which, as any theatre actor will tell you, is the fucking basic thing to do).”
    Yes, we know how good our actors are at physical transformation, let alone theatre ones, e.g. it would really have been taken a heavy toll on SRK (our poor answer to ever-transforming Christian Bell) while he mutates himself from a Gangadhar to Tom Cruise with just plugging/ unplugging a moustache in a YRF movie . I know I would be sounding an anti-SRK by now, but I don’t have a better example at hand w.r.t physical transformation in Bollywood. PERIOD!!!!!

    3. “Reads his scripts, and does extensive preparation for it. But all that is fucking expected from an actor in the first place.” Totally second this, but someone please ask other stars to at least comprehend scripts once they are done with reading ‘em. 🙂

    Like

  48. Absolute crap, this is precisely why being a trillion people nation we are not mighty enough while a small nation as Japan could stand together to be one of the worlds biggest economies even after the atomic Bombs, we have never learned to appreciate while we appreciate people who dont even know how to act but is a show off king.

    Count how many movies from other actors have had social messages like Rang-de-basanti,3-idiots and PK. How many actors have dared to do it, other than dancing in marriages, other functions & going for opening ceremonies and collecting money for it.

    You have hidden all the facts that had gone into each incident and have comfortably tried to project the instances according to only your views / opinions. Have you ever verified on what has happened the narmada bachao andolan, if not please do verify where it is now, what a key role Aamir has played in it.

    If you have enough time please do go through facts on all the movies you had listed, the fact is not what you guess, please do stop writing such blogs if you havent learnt the subject properly.

    Like

  49. A bit too much, don’t you think?
    1. I believe he’s said he doesn’t attend award shows of those awards whose credibility he doesn’t believe in
    2. I don’t believe he has ever gone on record saying he was a full-time activist for any cause. Which is why Satyamev Jayate was only a show and not a lifelong commitment
    For #1 and #2, there are published interviews you can look up
    3. TZP was the only film he directed. In all other films that you listed, HE doesn’t show or tell us about these “issues”. Gullible viewers associate the actor with being the speaker and the first and final word on a film or the issues it talks about
    4. As far as actors go, he’s exceptional in India’s context. And being exceptional here means getting paid by the crore
    5. For somebody that says the new, young Indian can see through BS, your blog contradicts it.A quick glance through the comments section here and it shows how carried away people get with swear words that it doesn’t matter how misguided the first 2/3rds of the post is.

    Your “only” problem with him was the only logical point you’ve made. I guess his PR strategy is to appear holier than thou by saying that he’s not read Chetan Bhagat (frankly, I wouldn’t admit in public either) or that he’s not seen AIB Knockout (I couldn’t watch it. They took it down :/). At least the second time he said that he’s been told about parts of the show. Come to think of it, I doubt he’d have had the time or inclination to watch the entire thing. The trailer tells enough. The guy is smart and surely keeps himself informed. Being PR savvy is part of his job.

    You write well and show a good sense of humour. Looking forward to more

    Like

  50. Dude, this is just fucking brilliant stuff. I love the sarcasm and irreverence. I read thru some of the pathetic ohh-you’ve-pissed-on-my-aamir-khan comments and its sadly funny how people righteously defend their objects of lust.

    Like

    1. You hit the bull’s eye! Awesome punches to drive home the point that just being an intelligent actor does not make you either an Einstein or a Jaiprakash Narayan. And, frankly, with due respect to the kind of cinema he makes and the “intelligent” actor that he is, he is nowhere even near to Naseeruddin Shah, Om Puri, Nawazuddin Siddiqui or any seasoned theatre actor. He does not even have the charm or the wit to hold an audience while speaking. He was my childhood/teenage crush and then I evolved, thankfully!

      Like

  51. At first I just thought you hated the guy but I get it – I see your point of view. The only qualm I have is that he didnt open his mouth about AIB until he was asked about it. Yes, he said he didnt see all of it but he also said that from the bits and pieces he did see he didnt think it was funny. He also made it clear that this was HIS opinion only.

    I loved the show. I also love Amir khan’s work – humans aren’t perfect and if he’s got flaws and/or opinions you dont agree with, thats okay. You dont have to. Calling him a pretentious prick is stretching it.

    Like

    1. I’d rather watch AIB & Bollywood abusing, than pay 500 bucks to watch Dhoom 3. His work is good, but as the author says, IT’S BECAUSE ALL THE OTHER BOLLYWOOD ‘ARTISTS’ ARE USELESS.

      Like

  52. Now that is a blog worth reading, you have used sarcasm to its best. Many people over do it but your ounces were very well placed. I have told many times that he is a big nautanki but to some people he isngod and it didn’t set well with them.

    Like

  53. You started off well. And your point that most of Aamir Khan’s comments are a part of his thought-out PR strategy to prop up his self-styled social activist image. However, I think you render your own article a disservice by resorting to excessive name-calling. i don’t think the use of “fucking” or other swear words added any extra impact to your punchline. Just my thought.

    I really like one of the points made in the comments section regarding the AIB joke on Farida Jalal. I must say I cringed as well when I heard it on the show. It goes against one of the justifications made for the show that they are ridiculing people on their faces. I wonder if they asked her permission. Now, that was uncalled for. For me, all that fun in the show, whatever force it provides to freedom-of-speech in India and whatever good it did otherwise, wasn’t worth that joke.

    Like

    1. Joke wasn’t on Farida Jalal.. It was on Ranveer Singh that he is such a pervert who can jerk off to a dadi figure.. If someone goes pervert on Pamela Anderson and caught jerking off in the middle of street, why the hell would she be humiliated. I hope it clarifies their stand to you. Also you need to keep in mind that as a comic they will always make jokes on public figure, caricature artists and mimicry artists have been earning their livelihood through this since stone age. So, no problem there.. #AIBRoastChangedIndianComicSceneForever..

      Like

  54. Why you guys are giving so much importance to what AK said?
    By reacting to him, you only are giving mileage to what he said. You think by voicing your opinion you’d change his ideology? Never.
    If you want to write something then write about the heart throb of the nation KRK.
    Here, 2rs for your effort…hehe

    Like

  55. super post! I was totally in shock when the AIB controversy happened. We are a nation which gets offended by anything and everything and then we go from one famous person to another to check their reactions, which in reality don’t matter at all. Getting offended is the in thing these days it seems. But, we never get offended when we should really do – when some politicos try to dictate the number of babies a woman should have – that was offending. But, we are a bunch of monkeys who don’t know what is good for us and what we should not bother about.
    Coming to AK, even if we don’t go as far as Delhi Belly, PK also sported a few words which can ‘offend’ people, if AIB could do it.

    Like

  56. We Indians are bunch of hypocrites. Just the other day I was hanging around with 2 of my pals who’re a couple. The couple were discussing some matter when the girls called the guy ‘Kameena’ to which the guy reacted with by calling her ‘Kameeni’. Now, the girl said how dare she call a girl Kameeni? This ain’t right and blah blah. The guy was adamant at first and was holding grounds but on seeing his chances of getting laid with her going he said sorry.

    Like

  57. For your sake, let’s assume and agree some of the things:
    1. The dog comment was made on purpose of a whole-hearted insult.
    2. He was being the biggest of all hypocrites about the whole AIB issue.
    3. Maybe somehow you got into the wires of his mind and analyzed and came to the harsh conclusion that all this time he was just being pretentious about all these Social Awareness things and it was just a show off.

    Now the positive: Instead of just sitting and blogging and criticizing (we indians are so fond of it), he is doing something on the field. His creation, Satyamev Jayate has been able to deface some of the biggest malpractices and has raised awareness about multiple issues in India. Atleast somebody is doing what is necessary and important.

    P.S: I am not an Aamir fan.

    Like

    1. sathyamev jayathe is over generalized.. that fellow charges around 3 crores for an episode. . if he is soo bothered abt the nation let him do something for free… i personallly don like that shitty show coz he really converts it into a stage.. let him go out there and work man….

      Like

      1. There is no authentic source behind that 3 crore figure. Even I have come across some sources which says why he takes that much and how he makes less money out of it. Besides, what’s wrong if he makes money out of it which is given by STAR. It is solving a genuine purpose. Does it make him any evil?

        Like

      2. he is the producer of that show, dude… why would he charge money when he is himself putting his money on it. If the show earns, he earns. If the show loses money, he loses. Is it so difficult to understand? Moreover, for two years, he stopped appearing in any advertisements, when he could have earned hundreds of crores from them.

        Like

  58. Well i think you have a great PR manager who knows how to promote AIB through all the negative publicity on a daily basis. I have no issues with AIB, in fact your show was brilliant but the way you are posting stuffs on blogs are mostly a PR stunt and is a poor way to defend yourself, it just looks desperate.
    First by posting all sorts of post proving how AIB is being wrongly targeted by the politicians by blocking the video on youtube and through various FIRs registered and now by targeting Aamir Khan when he said something against your show.

    Like

  59. is the extensive use of ‘fuck’ in your blog an effect of AIB roast? lol

    BTW I found the AIB roast episode extremely vulgar and crass…I can’t just get the logic behind humiliating people just because it’s a “roast” and everything goes…(can someone simply come and say somebody’s mother is a whore and his father is a pimp and when he gets angry just say “hey dude…it was just a roast”) but apparently it’s a form of comedy and there are people who enjoys the same…so one is free to comment about their work, but it is pure bullshit to involve heavy words like ‘culture’, ‘responsibility’, etc to a bloody comedy show…they are comedians…not politicians or public figures who are supposed to be the shining beacons of our upcoming generation…!

    Also I agree with most of the things u said about Aamir…he has this tendency to be a ‘thinking man’s voice” at every given opportunity…i feel he is actually under pressure from himself (if he doesn’t get involved in a social issue in a week probably his TRP ratings get affected…is the show still on…??? I stopped watching long time ago) I have immense regard and respect for him as an actor par excellence (I hate the way u have downgraded his gigantic efforts to get in to a character as being ‘basic’…if it were so easy how come other superstars are not even close…!) but he needs to stop his sermons big time…or as you said, go through the entire work before commenting on it…!

    Like

  60. I love aamir, because there arent much real actors to like in the mainstream bollywood. Completely agree with the point that what aamir does is something that EVERY damn person who calls themselves as an actor is supposed to do! Loved your prespective here and had an amazing time skimming through ‘what have you done for the nation’ comments below.. xD All in all 5 on 5 for this one 😀

    Like

  61. Started reading this post so that I can defend Aamir but I am speechless. I cannot defend him.

    I personally do not like Aamir not attending award shows either. Salman also did not get awards until Kuch Kuch Hota, he complained about the same but never disrespected the award ceremony.

    Yes sometime you may not win awards because they are dependent on the jury members opinion and also public review but that does not mean who won did not deserve at all. If five actors has been nominated that means all of them have as much possibility of winning.

    Aamir always says this is my opinion. Well that is just being politically correct. If you comment about something have the courage to defend the same.

    You are absolutely correct on the OSCARS issue. If you do not like or believe in award ceremonies why OSCARS. OSCAR follows the same format like Filmfare or IIFA and OSCAR has also not been fair to movies and actors as well.

    “Slumdog millionaire” won because of its popularity where the actual winner should have been “The curious case of Benjamin Button”. So OSCAR is unfair as well so why attend OSCAR. Doing it for the country is just a lame excuse. Lagaan bringing OSCAR for India would have changed nothing for India or Indian Cinema.

    Aamir goes about doing good deeds thru Satya… and other media but Salman has been doing social cause for ages. He not only does general social work but also he helps his co-stars in building their career. Sonakshi, Arjun, Ranveer and so many others have grown in the industry because of Salman. Salman has never even talked about it in media.

    Mr.Perfect is very good but a Movie is not a one man show. Your perfection should not be the cause of your co-star’s discomfort. Co-actors of Aamir has openly shown discomfort because of Aamir’s perfection issues.

    Aamir tiil date has not launched a single new actor except his brother and nephew.

    So the bottom line is Aamir is not that perfect as the world things him to be.

    Like

  62. I think there is a lot of exaggeration in this article. People also often want to demean Aamir Khan so much that they could start romanticizing really bad taste like AIB Roast. And these ‘people’ also bashed Deepika Padukone for doing the contrary – enjoying and laughing her head off at AIB Roast. No one is perfect, not even actors. I compare the impact AIB Roast has had on the society and that Aamir Khan has had, and Aamir Khan wins hands down. And also, if the blogger ‘actually’ watched the video of Aamir Khan talking about it : He gave his opinion only after he was asked about the show and precised that it was ‘only his opinion’ and also, he maintained his disregard for verbal violence, which I don’t see Aamir Khan endorsing anywhere. And btw, Lagaan was a pretty kickass film. The author should stop calling names and give better evidence, or better still, get a life or he could easily become the Rakhi Sawant of blogging. Try seeing through the mist, people.

    Like

    1. You can call AIB’s show a massive pile of excrement while at the same time calling out Aamir for criticizing it without having watched it. There’s no contradiction here.

      Like

  63. Well written blog. I am a fan of Amir Khan, I watched AIB and I found it funny (not offensive). I don’t think’s Amir’s remarks regarding AIB Roast hold any significance, simply because what he said is good in general. But at AIB roast all were aware of what was going to happen and they willfully signed up for it. And to be honest our ragging sessions in first year of engineering were way worse than this roast!! So AIB is not as big a deal as people are making it.

    Like

  64. This is not sarcasm, this article falls in the category of Negative Criticism. Aamir may not be able to meet the ideal state, but he is delivering far far better than what any other Indian actor could achieve ….. both onscreen and offscreen.

    Kindly refrain from writing such articles until you yourself match up and size up to such a level.

    Like

  65. Suddenly everyone is trying to be over the board humorous and sarcastic and expect the society to adapt to it too. Both AIB team and Amir Khan know how the media works. But the biggest idiots are these media who try to bank on out of context quotes and make news.

    Like

  66. Pretentious Prick!!?? Says a guy who wrote an essay on Aamir Khan’s Point of View? Its his fucking point of view dude. Freedom of speech? Know what that means? Aamir through his shows and movies has had a positive influence on people. Even if he is playing an ‘ideal man’ character, even if it is PR controlled, even if he’s a hypocrite… what’s wrong with it? Is that not better than murdering, drunk and abusive actors as role models?

    All you needed were a few clicks and kudos you got them. However if you think Aamir ‘Bhai’ is gonna pick up the phone and call you over for dinner for this moronic rant, then I suggest you do not hold your breath.

    Like

    1. Freedom of speech? Know what that means?

      You clearly don’t, since the author has every fucking right to call out what he thinks of Aamir’s behaviour. As do you and everyone else to express your view or critique the author. Freedom of speech includes the freedom to criticize.
      Also it’s so precious to use the ‘you’re only doing this for attention’ argument. Nobody forced you to read and comment on this post either did they?

      Like

  67. Did he came out of his own and commented on AIB or was he specifically asked about it?
    Did he mention that he’s seen it in bits and pieces and would comment based only on that?
    Did he expressed his support for Freedom of Speech?
    Did he specifically mentioned that he’s against bans?

    You are really a cunt to belittle his works. You may not like it but I hope it’s only chutias like you who will deny his achievement. Who is Russell Peters and what is his claim to fame to comment on what an artist is supposed to do? He’s a stand up comedian but his fan following is no where close even to Fardeen Khan, leave alone Aamir Khan.

    Yes, he produced Delhi Belly and it was adult rated. But it is nothing compared to what AIB presented. Just abuses doesn’t make up entertainment else KRK would have been ruling the box office and not SRK. What AIB was, nothing but shit load of abuses in the garb of entertainment. One or two milder abuses is alright but what was presented in AIB was only Ma-Behan ki gaali, in fact more than that. The event was only made for pushing AIB into limelight out of youtube, nothing else.

    Like

    1. But Delhi belly was out in the open – it was getting pushed to us – the songs, videos through tv and radio – even during family prime time. This was a roast video that to on a pull platform – if you want to watch then watch it. You made an effort to wath it – fired up ur pc/mac/mobile, went to the browser, typed youtube.com, searched for the video and then finally saw it after knowing/ reading the disclaimers etc etc and knowing it is aroast video.

      it is like logging on to some porn site, watching a porn movie, enjoying it and next morning complaining how vulgar movies are.

      or like watching a shitty horror movie and complaining that it should not been so scary.

      or like asking the pani puri wala to put in more mirchi and then complaining “it was too hot”.

      or like checking in to a Rs.250/- hotel in the middle of a highway and complaining they do not have a 24 hours hot water service.

      Fact is that what Amir Khan commented about AIB and Delhi Belly are contradictory – and we can undersatnd the same.

      Like

  68. Enjoyed the article.

    In ancient times when a Raamlila or a Nautanki was the only entertainment for the masses, I do not think anyone took a ‘character’ as seriously as now a film star is taken. People used to have fun but they never used to bother or imitate the entertainers – what they ate and how they lived. Entertainment is just one small part of our requirements and let us neither hate not make demi Gods out of actors.

    Could not stop laughing on the sentence – ” Chetan Bhagat is the Rakhi Sawant of Indian literature .”

    Like

  69. This article is fantastic! The whole AIB thing is incidental. The truth is that this Aamir Khan fellow (I say it with a typical Bangalorean’s contempt!) is annoying. His best work was 20 years ago (as Amar in Andaz Apna Apna).

    Like

  70. “Dear Aamir Khan, This isn’t the 60s. Where you could do a few patriotic movies and become a national hero. The audience you deal with is thirty years younger to you, a completely different generation.” – Yea… This sort of summarizes your article. And the counter point is that Mr. Aamir never said he was a hero or saint in real life. He could behave in such a manner, but as long as he doesn’t claim himself to be so, you are just trying to swat an invisible mosquito.

    Like

  71. Super like…. I think exactly the same way – and have tried to tell the same but today your blogs tells it the best way… I have already shared the link so many times!!! And one more point – Amir had come down to watch some cricket match – IPL most probably. His facial expression was same as when he was painting in TZP or in Dhobi Ghat or while listening to questions on Satyamev!!! Man come on – you are watching a T20 match, everyone is cheering, there is no need to be so INTELLIGENT. No need to be so pretentious!!!! That day onwards like I do not like him – the way he looked the time he rode that bike in dhoom – in an intelligent manner!!!!.

    Like

  72. Very well said. I have been an avid fan of Aamir.. But I have started to realize (may be am bit late at this) that he is actually not what ‘we’ think he is! Today only I found his comments on AIB and that was really annoying. He himself had justified the explicit stuff in Delhi Belly (when he used to be the ‘funny’ guy appreciating non veg jokes) and all of a sudden now he becomes a Man of Conscience when it comes to AIB. Hypocrite!

    Like

  73. You have said the most obvious decisions about Amir Khan as far as his career choices work and effort goes and there is nothing wrong with it. In an industry where most of mainstream actors do bullcrap work with on crappy scripts, yes Amir Khan’s work will be much respected, and why not?
    Besides respecting and appreciating his work only you have delusions of considering the other actor and TV presenter a ‘Socrates’;trust me no one else does.

    That being said AIB’s roast in my opinion is shitty concept. Something I do not enjoy and Amir has a right to say that just like me.

    I wrote this in 2 minutes. you must have taken a week to compile such shitty work. A week wasted!

    Like

    1. No, in fact, it took me about ten minutes. And another five to add the images. So yeah, 15 minutes.

      Can you also predict how long people have had sex, based on a blog? Do you possess those special Aamir Khan sort of powers? On 19 Feb 2015 19:36, “Heartranjan's Blog” wrote:

      >

      Like

  74. Seems like much ado about nothing….the writer didn’t have anything better to do with his time, I guess. Hence, he decided to get two birds with one stone, both Aamir Khan and Chetan Bhagat. Instead of name-calling, why not try and do something that’s even worth half of what either of them has done!

    Like

  75. Tell me, So, if he has decided to make his chuthiyapa his USP and the country is lapping it up, what is wrong in that? Shouldn’t the junta be considered a prick for allowing him to be what he isn’t? I think, even you are using Aamir as a vehicle to garner some valuable hits!! its alright…relax, cool…now pick on another prick SRK, KJo or even KRK…you will get hits…Why is Madhuri such a mum chum?

    Like

  76. For me, Aamir Khan emerged as a suspect when he used the tremendous following he had gained among kids with Taare Zameen Par to promote that atrocious hairstyle and violence of Ghajini. What sensitivity was he promoting with that film? And you are right. He can still get away with being brilliant, moral, sensitive, what have you…as long as he does not sermonize about others’ efforts…without even seeing/reading/experiencing them.

    Like

  77. As is customary, I have to say, nice one ranjan, but having said that i’ll also say what amazes me is not the post but rather the number of people willing to lay down their opinions for Amir Khan. The offended souls who filled your comments section with their protest of your defamation of their supreme. What i find hilarious is not that they are in awe of a man who they probably have never met, spoken to or been in bed with but rather that they are convinced that this man strives for the collective betterment of their grand nation and their miserably boring lives. What is even more hilarious is that they actually took the effort of reading a blog post (that i doubt Amir Khan is ever going to see), get offended, then sit and write opinions on it (which Amir will definitely not read) and argue with people who are thoroughly amused with their antics. But then again these could be the voices of the Amir-Fan illuminati who as we speak is planning to remove you and your opinions off the face of the earth, in which case goodbye my opinionated friend and thanks for the blog post and its amazing haters.

    Peace

    Like

  78. Great tone, attitude and fine sarcasm.

    Yet just wondering who among modern day actors n politicians qualifies to be a loser at the art of pretension.

    Like

  79. “Carefully crafted PR” you say. I think it’s quite the opposite. I think everybody else in the industry is just too afraid of commenting on this, notwithstanding their own dislike of the Roast. I personally did not like the Roast either, despite being a big AIB fan otherwise. I’m sure there are many in the industry who didn’t like it and would want to voice their opinions on it (and almost every actor these days is being asked this question in every interview, I don’t know why), but they refrain from commenting, only because they know it’s not good PR, it’ll get them a lot of flak.

    And yes, I feel no shame in supporting an actor who helps churn out masterpieces like PK, 3 idiots, Taare Zameen Par, Dil Chahta Hai, Rang de Basanti, Lagaan, Sarfarosh, and 1947 Earth. I don’t care if these films get him the image of a saint or satiate his lockers. Just take these films out and you’ll be all the more ashamed of the quality of films that India makes. His films (most of them, at least) make us believe that there IS HOPE of having good films in Indian mainstream cinema,

    Like

    1. Totally agree.. We cannot demolish some one work just by saying its their duty to do so(Like acting for actor).. We are very good in criticizing, let not make it more evident.. If some one is bothered & doing good for even 1 person(other than himself) it needs to be applaud.. Thats the change we Indians need.

      Like

    2. Did not get your “too afraid” comment. Why would someone be afraid in reprimanding another person abusing on stage. Let’s be very simple here, imagine yourself going to give an exam, you have to answer a few questions, multiple choice, negative marking. The negative marking would lead you to read “something”, and even if you pass away the unknown questions would you try answering them incorrectly? It’s not a dare it’s a personal opinion and you should clear out the facts and not just blindly speak whatever you think is correct. “I personally haven’t seen the Roast, but I have heard people talking about it, and I felt sad” what the fuck is this ?

      Like

      1. First, the “Too afraid” comment: Yes, most of these ‘actors’ are afraid to take any stand on any issue that affects them at any level, just coz their PR agent tells them to be wary of what they say. And I don’t blame the PR agent either. He’s like the cop who tells you “You have the right to remain silent. Anything you say might be held against you”! He’s right. Coz this is exactly what has happened in this case with Aamir. Think, just think. Before this entire episode, he was acclaimed as the only actor who could make movies that make people think, introspect and give them a message, whilst also ensuring that the makers of the movie earn good moolah. With all the other ‘actors’, it’s either the former or the latter. But this guy.. this guy knew how to do both. But suddenly, he makes a comment on the AIB roast, and he’s a pretentious prick. Pseudo-intellectual social commentators these days resort to making personal attacks to try to drive home any point they want to. Take, for instance, the recent bashing of Shenaz Treasurywala’s ‘open letter’ to people she thought could influence the society and people in power, to do something to make women feel safer in our country. It was shocking to see that just coz she had done a role in ‘Delhi Belly’, people thought she had lost the right to say anything like that. Though I did not find the open letter to be as much a ‘call for action’ as it was a vent for pent-up emotions, I sincerely think that the celebrities she called out to, do possess an incredible amount of influencing power. People like Aamir Khan, Amitabh Bacchan, Shah Rukh Khan, Sachin Tendulkar, Rajnikanth can be opinion leaders in a country like ours, where these people are virtually worshiped. Yet, you never find any of these people coming out and supporting something that might create a controversy or offend a certain section of people and might tarnish their image.
        You ask “Why would someone be afraid in reprimanding another person abusing on stage”. THIS is exactly why. It’s because they don’t want to be seen as backward, regressive, pretentious pricks who are against freedom of expression.

        The author of this blog says “A few months before the release of Rang De Basanti, Aamir Khan sat with the Narmada Bachao Andolan protesters to speak up for their rights”. What the author has not told you is that the “few months before the release of Rang de Basanti” is actually a much less accurate way of putting it forth (well, you know why). I’ll put it more accurately here. He supported the Narmada Bachao Andolan even after Rang de Basanti and Fanaa, the screening of which was banned in the entire state of Gujarat because he had “offended a certain section” of the Gujarat population. Despite the ban, he still stood by the Narmada Bachao Andolan, knowing very well that this would only harm the box office collections of his movie, by no less than 10% of the total anticipated collections. It requires guts to do that, and a backbone.

        The author has also used promotional pictures of Satyamev Jayate to mock Aamir Khan. So while other “opinion leaders” are busy doing inane stuff like “India mein sabse shaana kaun” and dancing at weddings for money, this guy comes up with a show that actually brings forth problems prevalent in our country that most of us are hardly aware of, and he gets mocked, is accused of being a pretentious prick and draamebaaz and what not. Again, I will just say this: I don’t care if he’s filling up his cash-lockers or getting the image of a pious saint, as long as what he does is benefiting society in the slightest way. Personally, I think there were so many issues taken up in the show that people like my parents (who would otherwise not even acknowledge the existence of LGBTs as normal people, or not realize the importance of Sports) got sensitized to and aware about. And I can see the change in their attitude and thoughts ever since. [I am straight, btw, before you make a gay joke on me]. So yes, he has demonstrated that celebrities like him are opinion leaders and can influence society in a big way. But you will never find a Shah Rukh Khan or an Amitabh Bacchan doing something like that. Simply because of either of the 2 reasons:
        a) they don’t have the guts to do so, and will go by what the PR guy says
        b) they fuckin don’t care

        Second, his comment “I personally haven’t seen the Roast, but I have heard people talking about it, and I felt sad”. So it’s basically this: He’s heard some of the jokes that they made on the AIB Roast and he didn’t like them. It’s like you seeing a movie trailer, and finding every bit of it pathetic and in bad taste. Will you want to watch that movie? And if asked for your opinion, will you not say that you didn’t like the trailer at all and hence chose not to watch the entire movie?

        Like

        1. I have never considered Aamir Khan as a “thinking actor” and I suppose there are a bunch of people like me who don’t really care.
          I’m not bashing him over what he has to say about one individual but at least have the IQ to go forward and view the whole show/book or whatever you want to comment on. As he mentioned for Delhi Belly so did AIB “if you think it offends you don’t watch it”
          But then if you do not watch it you lose the freedom to comment on how it should be done and then people should act responsibly. Like you were very responsible while showing oral sex scenes in your movie in the name of creative freedom
          The thing about “Satyamev Jayate” and your long paragraph on how it affects society is all something that is scripted with real people involved. I can easily put a KRK on stage and make a similar show. It’s not Aamir’s Magic that creates the show. Don’t make this about PR and how people earn money and what he does not. Aamir Khan is just another actor for me and his opinions have finally struck a chord on the wrong side of argument with me because he blames artists for acting responsibly being an artist himself. And it’s just sad that whatever he thinks is right he has the audacity to suggest a million other artists to do who have creative freedom as he has himself.

          Like

        2. Yours could easily serve as an example of how civilized people ought to disagree (as also how to make perfect sense without trying to be impressive with a combination of jargon and bad grammar). I have been following the comments here and just had to come back to thank you for your response. Thank You 🙂

          Like

  80. Every one has right of expression and right of speech until it hurts others sentiment. So he was giving his opinion. Whats your problem.
    “The only way to avoid criticism is to do nothing” That’s what you expect from every one to say nothing do nothing.

    Like

    1. Yes everyone has the right to give their opinion, only when you thoroughly know what you are opining about. It doesn’t help when you are a hypocrite, who at one time supports the usage of abusive language citing as that’s what the youth now does, when your film is to release and then go about condemning other artists and preach about what such rolemodels should do, when it is somebody else’s turn to do the same.

      Like

      1. He didn’t go about condemning those who were on the AIB roast. He just gave his personal opinion which is exactly what he was asked to do by the journalists! And frankly he was bold enough to give an honest opinion much unlike what other actors do for the sake of ‘PR’. Agreed that he didn’t watch the whole thing, but do you really need to after watching it in bits and pieces (which he did btw)?

        Like

        1. He did not just give his personal opinion..he said they were irresponsible because they did not give neough warning that the show was for adults and also that he would like them to not make such shows. He did not just say that I didn’t like it. He was apparently very disappointed with some people participating in it and said that quite clearly although unnecessarily.

          Like

    2. Um… the author probably would have disabled comments if that were the expectation, don’t you think? And if I have not missed the point, the author does not have a problem with people’s opinions but how they are expressed. Personally, it hurts my sentiment when someone approves their mugshot on a cause they are championing. Other than that, all good. Excuse me, I’ve got to puke – I think I gazed at that ad of SMJ a tad too long …

      Like

  81. Such prejudice. Much pointlessness. wow.
    I think he is (supposedly) a youth icon because he actually DID something with his life, while you sound frustrated by all the attention he is getting. So he did not watch the shitty roast, heard about it from a first hand source, and commented (only when asked), saying that he did not like it. You on the other hand write about his exploits even though you have NO idea what he has gone through to make a single movie, or the stress it takes to make it ‘happen’. You are right, our generation can see through people’s bullshit. So here, watch a nice video about Bullshit man!

    Like

  82. Seems this article is written by some Rakhi sawant of bloggers world, who just want to get some fame by criticizing Aamir khan. BTW, you have achieved this perfectly. If you call a show with huge load of abusive words comedy, then every second person in India is a stand up comedian. Don’t try to be right every time using this word ‘Hypocrisy’ dude. People like you criticize Aamir for what he have done and then watch all his films to get entertained. Can you tell me what have you done in your life ? It is easy to criticize people for them who haven’t done anything themselves.

    Like

    1. Yogesh Negi – Go and search the meaning to Hypocrite and then log a comment. Yes, Aamir has done a lot but that does not justifies his statement. it’s like being a PETA follower with a passion for hunting!

      Like

  83. Now this shows how low someone can stoop down to JUST criticise someone’s pros & vaguely highlight the illogical falsely-interpreted cons!!!
    I call that man “Sir”.. & so I won’t waste my time on proving it all shit stuff just bcoz sm1 can totaly reverse the meaning to accuse a great Indian actor and a human being whom people admire so much & look upto get inspired!
    I wud just say that “If u can’t praise sm1 for right dont unnecessarily abuse misusing it all”!
    & u talk of Satyamev Jayate.. shame man!! :/
    Kudos shame (y)

    Like

  84. Well-written and clearly incisive. That Aamir Khan has been pretentious throughout all his endeavours was clear when newspapers reported the kind of bucks he charges for Satyameva Jayate. What saddens me though is his justification for coming out with Delhi Belly. “I went out of my way to get an A-rated certificate for the film”, he said. Now isn’t that expected of any actor or film-maker? As an ingenious move of diplomacy, he later on progresses to say that artists must be given their due of creative liberty. As the article clearly mentions, this generation is not going to take his words for face value. We know and we understand his hypocrisy!

    Like

  85. well, the question is, he justified in a quite detailed way that why he did not like the roast and he also justified about Delhi Belly, there is a huge difference between making a movie with foul langauge and releasing it for Adults and the quantity of foul language is DB and AIB is quite obvious….second it was released for adult audience but Roast was released on Youtube with no such restrictions where anyone can no matter what is his/her age watch…Even the most modern country people may find it offensive and wont allow their children to watch…But still Media and journalist are making fuss of it…Ask Russell Peters to shut his mouth as he himself makes fun of indian names which at least presents some purity..the divine..(sukhdeep as suck deep)…Why the media had itch to ask Amir…? he himself openly admitted of not watching it and based on people’s observations he also find it offensive..Oh No he must say “wait, let me watch and get back to you” answer, whereas he dedicates himself for the causes he endorses and the movies he works out..every movie of him is master piece…

    Like

  86. What a hating fuckster you are man! That’s all I have to say. Aamir Khan is horrible coz he doesn’t give a fuck to haters. Like wow! It’s HIS fault that people listen to his good advice. Excellent! Have you ever considered the possibility that his wits cannot compete the amount of stupid you haters accumulate to? I didn’t bother reading the second half of your shitty article. Now dunk a biscuit in this shit and eat it you moron.

    Like

  87. Well said.

    Re his holier than thou stance with respect to other artists – frankly, there are finer artists in India (and closer to home, in Hindi film) that do what they do without all the fanfare. They choose better movies, they do a better job in said movies, and they are doing it for the craft. My problem with Aamir Khan is that he says all this shit, but he mostly does what he does mostly for money – if he were truly concerned about purity of the art form, he would have left commercial cinema ages ago. Sure, there’s a Dhobi Ghat here and there (but even there, I felt Aamir Khan was the weak link). In short, he makes himself out to be the brilliant artist that he is not. And he thinks that gives him license to judge other artists.

    I’ve always been wary of Aamir Khan’s “brilliance” (as in, he alone is not enough to make me go see a film of his). I remember reading about how he kicked out Amol Gupte from the Taare Zameen Par as a director, and when I wasn’t impressed with the movie, I wondered if it would have been worse or better with Amol Gupte. But then I saw Stanley ka Dabba (splendid – if you have not seen) and it just kind of turned me off about Aamir Khan.

    Anyway, I do agree, though, that things like Satyameva Jayate are a commendable effort – as average citizens, there’s often not much we can do about social issues besides raising awareness (and obv. practicing what we preach), so I’m glad that he is using his celebrity for a good cause.

    Like

    1. Stanley K Dabba was a well made film that did not reach the masses. Tare Zameen Par would have had the same fate had Amir not stepped in. And if you end up reaching out to the masses, a fantastic BO collection will only be a byproduct. So whats wrong with that a film maker wants more n more people to watch his film. Isn’t it?

      Like

  88. The Article is hilarious.  Totally enjoyed it! I don’t know how can someone write such things (with wonderfully crafted slang) about a person who is a padma-bhushan and included in TIMES top 100 inspirational people in the world (Leaving all the acting staff   ) . However, If you believe in freedom of speech and you have watched the video of Aamir’s reaction to AIB roast.. you will see he has said properly that “I didn’t like it”. By saying it he has become the Villain of so-called “youth”. I practically liked the show and the roast concept , but if you think anyone can express his/her feelings then why can’t Aamir khan ? So do you think he is actually an Alien ? 😀 You may disagree but you cannot say he is wrong.

    And to the article writer, for the last 20 years he (with other Khans) is ruling the industry and your NEW GENERATION has just given him a 300 cr movie, namely PK The Film   ..You can still bark but the fact remains same that you have no work to do and you are frustrated like ………..leave it, I don’t use slang in my writing 😀

    Like

  89. Aamir : “Even I made Delhi Belly which had lot of profanity, but it didn’t attack anyone on an emotional level… trying to impress people by using abusive language is pointless”.
    — Name one person who was attacked by AIB who was not present there. Everyone who was “attacked emotionally” had given their consent and were very mature about it. Who is Aamir to condemn that? and what kind of language did your movie use? Hmm well, it was abusive. So whom were you trying to impress?

    Aamir : I am no longer a 14-year-old who will hear abusive language and laugh
    — Why do you assume only 14 year olds hear abusive language and laugh? I am a 30 year old and I found it funny. The “panel” on the roast were of mixed age and they found it funny. Karan Johar is pretty much the same age as you and he hosted it. So stop categorizing humour to be age specific.

    Aamir : We have certain responsibility. I felt it was a very violent event. Sirf do joote marna violence nahi hota. Violence verbal bhi hota hai. (Violence isn’t just hitting someone. Vioelnce is also verbal.) I was deeply affected by it. I was most disappointed in what I was hearing
    — If you had “certain responsibility” you should not have made something like Delhi Belly. Where a single fat guy goes to a brothel, Imran’s character cheats on his GF, etc etc. How in god’s name were you deeply affected by something you did not even WATCH. It’s like me saying I get scared at night because my friends told me about this really scary movie. oooohhhhh.

    I mean c’mon man. I thought you were more intelligent than this. I respect Aamir for making somewhat goof movies (not counting Ghajini and Dhoom3). If you watched it and said “I did not find it funny”, people would have been alright.

    Like

    1. There were people like Farida Jalal and Anil Kapoor who were attacked and were not present in the roast. Some newspapers also suggest that Salman Khan threatened Tanmay Bhat to remove the portion where his sister was called ‘bhikari’ by AIB in the live event. And Khan successfully stopped AIB from posting the entire event.

      So yes, Karan Johar jerking at Farida Jalal might sound funny to people like us (even I like the roast) but it is offensive to Jalal, ain’t it?

      Like

  90. Let’s get real… which actor doesn’t use PR … SRK, Salman, Big B… you name it … if Aamir does it more effectively than others then let’s just give credit where it belongs … As far as the language used in this blog is concerned, the lesser said the better.
    It’s written by an amateur who seems desperate to make an impression (and miserably fails at it).
    Mr. Heartrajan … grow up!!! You seem like someone yet to reach puberty (and definitely desperate to get there). It took me no more than a couple of seconds to understand that you are pissed at his stand on AIB. He is just as entitled to have an opinion as you (and frankly I agree with him and YES I have seen the AIB Roast). You seem to be from the generation that seems to think that using F words is a sign of having arrived in life… Wake up and smell the coffee …

    Like

  91. By the way, no he won’t be offended by your blog. He has better things to read. We live in a world where every loser tries to get into the limelight by pointing fingers at Aamir Khan. Like that Sucheta Haterpants Dalal and the author of this precious article. You haters make him bigger than any of us fans can.

    Like

  92. his films, tare zameen par, pk, rang de basanti, mangal padey n other movies that you have mentioned……they atleast leave a feel that there is a hope somewhere………..
    he is atleast trying……not just criticizing, …
    you just want everyone to do nothing …..n lateron write antoher artical that this country is a shit……right….

    Like

  93. If we go by your logic-> you are also no one to judge him
    this is the main problem with our think Whenever someone says something, we look at their stature and not the points made by them and try to console ourselves that what we believe and think is right . Grow up !!!

    Like

  94. if everyone’s got a right to speech (like AIB) then isn’t Mr. Amir Khan has a right to his views? I smell shit cooking in a sauce of hypocrisy garnished with frustration.

    i expected some reasoning and not a I-want-to-vent-out-my-frustration-so-lets-make-Amir-the-punch-bag-and-the-internet-as-my-potty-hole kinda article. immature article.

    Like

  95. It’s actually a very good read in fact. You have clearly put some facts in it. I don’t understand why readers are getting so offended. Most of the readers who have criticized the write up has mentioned one thing directly or indirectly “he(Aamir Khan) is a person who raises voice”, but when someone raises his voice against someone he didn’t like then you guys get offended. WTH yaar. I am no fan of either Aamir or SRK or Bhai or any other for that reason but everyone should have the right to raise their own voice and not only the stars in the country. The only difference is that when you raise a voice then the audience is less but on the other hand when a public figure raises his voice, the entire nation listens. So they have at least this moral responsibility to raise the voice with all the facts and figures in hand. Just by raising voice to something which is a hot topic in the market and getting paid for that is not a duty towards nation. Raise your voice which you believe in and have the facts ready to justify yourself.

    We as Indian are serving the nation through Social Media. We think that by posting something on twitter of FB we are serving the nation. I agree that Social Media plays a role in the system but if Social Media is a mean to serve the nation then i don’t think our armed forces were required at the border, rather some posts related to our enemies will be enough to defeat them.

    Come on guys he just voiced his concern and you are not OK with that but you are OK if Aamir (or any other public figure for that reason) raises his voice. Then he is a national hero. Our country is one of the country where a billionaire gets millions as reward for getting gold medal in Olympics, but the families of the heroes who give their lives protecting the nation gets 25K. But we are all in praise always for them on SOCIAL MEDIA like the comments and posts will give those families their lived ones back.

    Many of us like the AIB Roast and many didn’t like it. Its a personal choice. If you didn’t like it then you had a option to close the youtube window before continuing to watch it till end. It’s not like you paid hundreds to watch the roast in a multiplex. We all are hypocrites but its funny that we overreact when someone points that out about us.

    I remember a saying that was very common “100 mein se 99 beimaan phir bhi mera bharat mahaan”. No country is perfect and that’s obvious but at least some of the country’s people try to do their best make it perfect and that too not on SOCIAL MEDIA.

    Like

  96. Like the tag line of the blogger goes “the thin line between bullshit and cowdung”, the write up is completely a – what I would like to call – a “cock-a-bulla” story. The writer is clearly and madly in need of fame and would do just about anything to get his 3 seconds of fame. I’m not too happy about AK’s comments either but that’s his opinion, if this blogger did not care two hoots about Satyamev Jayate and did not bother to commend him on his work, why is he in a hurry to criticize? I guess the easiest thing under the sun is to give advise and this advise is something he can shove it up his – bull shit loathed, cowdung smeared – arse. It’s fucking annoying!!!! _l_ 🙂

    Like

  97. ” Now, I personally have no problems with the show. A star like Aamir Khan talking about …….I also have no problem with him projecting himself as this new-age Carl Shehnanigan who tells the nation how to live – ……. I have no problems with that.””

    -well you do..

    Like

  98. This nigga spent hours writing a hate blog on a single person and in the end he says “I hope no one gets offended” hahahahaha.And dumbass dont say “yo” if you dont have the accent for it your indian be indian stop being white you sound stupid as shit.

    Like

  99. You questioned how can Aamir comment about something which he hasn’t even watched yet.
    Well my question to you is, ‘Did you hear the full response given by Aamir?’ If ‘Yes’ you wouldn’t have needed to write such a long essay brother.

    Like

  100. HR, you have truly let loose the spirt of the offended indian. The pic of ‘Indian man taking offense’ on your blog thus stands totally vindicated by the number of people offended by your post. Take a bow. And Chetan Bhagat is still wondering whether he should claim the title you gave him or not. He should because its true and it rocks. As for Aamir, he sucks for being a hypocrite. Can I still enjoy his movies? If they are well made why not? As Kanan and Biswa would say, “Toh problem kya hai?”

    Like

  101. Still laughing over CHETAN BHAGAT is RAKHI SAWANT

    Too good

    Doom3 is of Amir’s calibre
    Laagan was luck n he got even more lucky by taare zameen par. Media n we made him that man of wisdom. All he was thinking while staring at the sky was ‘fuck wat do I say?’. Whatever he uttered were utter disaster. But the stare to sky helped him talk much less :-). Lucky again !

    Like

  102. I don’t buy a bit of this blog. I think the author has pointed out some obvious picks where Aamir appears to have double standards but he has terribly failed to do a complete research. Its just like what they show on the news channel and force their opinions on the viewers with half story. For e.g. I have watched his reactions (full version) with respect to AIB and I agree with what he said. But most videos show only a clip of it so that people are mislead. Same goes with Chetan Bhagat controversy. Secondly, the author unnecessarily displays his poor sarcasm on what Aamir does or is doing. He is an actor and not social activist. If you are judging him by his involvement in any other thing but being an actor, I don’t think its the right way to look at things. Lastly, no one claims to be Socrates or Bhagat Singh. I didn’t really get the point to put the big names and compare an individual with them.

    Like

  103. Reblogged this on The Only Blog and commented:
    HeartRanjan is one of the bloggers I have read and liked for a long time now. But this one just nails it. “भाई भी अपनी वाली ओपिनियन रखता है”

    Like

  104. Okay.. Dude.. this is too much!! Its all crap!! You cant simply blame anyone like this! What do you know about his work? And who else in this industry helps peope? Who else is doin satyamev jayate? Can you do something like that? No right? Then stop this shit! Dont comment abt anyone widout knowing properly.. maybe hez doin all this for publicity.. but atleast hez doin something!

    Like

  105. I agree with your perception abt aamir but i won’t be agree with everyone who is taking their stand to defend AIB . I think that AIB was just trying to show that how we Indian are desperate about words that our teacher didn’t teach us in our school days . I think that telling human organ name in different language or in different context don’t lead to any kind of creativity or anyone should broadcast publically .. Bcs we Indian know that how much we aware about all sexology even more than 50% of us , don’t know 10% of it. Now AIB is trying to tell people “ab to….khda khda sofa hai..kuch nhi hota hai..” So this context can make negative impact on people who is not a part other 50%..

    Like

  106. True.. he acts tats he is so different than other bollywood actors & he is so diff… end of the day he is just a commercial bollywood actor who acts good n good in marketing. I would have understood tat he is another Irfan Khan or kk menon.. but if I talk of acting he is no match..

    Like

  107. Seriously.Big deal. A journalist asks some questions, and he gives his opinion. Now you have to groan and moan at him saying “oh, who does he think he is. a hypocrite,blah blah wah wah”. What’s wrong in voicing his opinion? He does come across as pretentious and what not, but its his opinion at the end of the day that he voiced.
    Honestly, AIB need to get their act together. You see, there is a fine line between freedom of speech, and exploitation of freedom of speech. You cannot just go shout whatever comes to your head on a stage and hide behind the “freedom of speech” card. If that was the case, we would see millions of cases of racism, hate speech , anti social propaganda and what not.
    More importantly, AIB has been booked with criminal conduct. NOT a civil case, but a criminal case. Serious stuff. There are some laws in India, and as long as you stay in India, you’ve got to respect them.

    Like

    1. Question is has AIB broken any laws ? Politically correct answer is “let the law take its course”. This is not a question of “thin lines between freedom of speech”, its just another case of double standards of moral policing.

      Like

  108. 0Aamir has just shared his personal opinion. If the writer (of this nonsensical blog) watches Aamir’s response , he also specifically mentions , that it is his personal opinion and he has no problem with those who like this form of comedy. Ok , what if he defended Delhi Belly , any individual wants his efforts to be praised and will try to display and depict his work as positively he can. And as this writer has written , Aamir is not the Bramha..(something) .., he’s just a human.
    And me being a psychologist, specifically understand this form of behaviour is common in human beings. So just shut the fu*k up. And the writer claims the media has no other work. I agree to it partially, but do you have any other work ?

    Like

  109. Well, this did give a whole new perspective of Aamir khan not only as an actor but also as a human being. I am glad someone did see through all the layers of carefully crafted public image to the, as you rightly said, pretentious prick. Since the incident with Chetan Bhagat during 3 idiots, it is clear that the man holds no respect for another artists’ work. Constructive Criticism of an artists work is good, even AIB accepted that. However, this guy deserves a special mention for creating an “opinion” and blatantly announcing it to the world without even watching the video. his reaction left me speechless(not in a good way) and the first thing that came into my mind was: “isn’t he the same guy who justified Delhi Belly, which had every single one of the elements that offended him so much about the roast?” , but then I realized, dude’s got a show to run. Think about the TRP’s of Satyameva Jayate. But one thing was right, the youth today can tell honest opinion from PR. I hope, Mr. Khan knows that.

    Like

  110. This reminds me a story about a fool. So here it is. “Once upon a time there was a fool and he was very upset about it that everybody thinks he’s a fool and nobody gives importance to him. One day a Sufi saint visited his village, he told his problem to him and prayed to give him some solution. Sufi said “it’s very simple, whenever anybody say anything or doing anything just ask “what’s in it special, any fool can do it. Fool scratched his head and said ” No I didn’t understand, tell me with example. Sufi said “Ok for example if someone says Aha what a beautiful moon. Immediately ask “what? What’s beautiful in it. Prove it. Even that fool got the point and started doing it. It worked and now he is being considered a very wise man in the village because he always asks “what’s in it special, prove it. Nobody can 😉. I mean no offence, I got the point, do you got mine?

    Like

  111. Laughed this hard after a long time! Kudos to you for pointing out all the things that came to our mind at some point or another! Superb writing as always!

    Like

  112. So happy to read this. I thought it was just me!
    “Aamir Khan first looked at the sky, blinked seven times, sipped some water, and then gave out his thoughts.”
    Yes! And he tries to convince us that all that posturing = SERIOUS good acting
    Also, movies that take a message and beat you over the head with it are better
    than those less self-conscious, lighter in touch ways of engaging with or entertaining
    your audience. I believe that he a decent actor (at times) who has done a slew of
    mostly mediocre movies (most, I said most!), but that is okay. But get off the high
    horse already, there are many other like you, and also some that are better than you!

    Like

  113. Hahhah this shitty piece is hilarious in the use lop-sided, narrow and parochial perspective and twisted logic. Let me just bring some of your “core” arguments to the fore:

    1. Promotion vs Indian Awards ceremony are anti-polar. Mutually exclusive. Couldn’t understand how did you or rather how could you pitch two disparate things in a meaningless context and “try” to put your point across.

    2. If some one truthfully or not truthfully, howsoever, admits that the other person did a better job and hence deserves the appreciation, how can that be “fucking annoying”. He marketed himself as “voice of the solar system”, exaggeration much?

    3. In this world full of illogical and irrational morons who use unfounded, groundless and unreasoned arguments to garner support for their arguments, like yourself, if some one were to step up and do things that make people/ fellow actors wiggle out of their dormant state, then that would set a bench mark, no matter how evident obvious that move is, as there are too few a people who have the balls to that. Who the hell gave him the tag “Socrates”, anyway. Exaggeration much?

    4. No word on Narmada Bachao Andolan? Get your facts right! Also, please refer to the first line of the 3rd point.

    5. In all the movies that you point out, he does highlight some of the gloomy state of affairs. But isn’t that right? He isn’t misleading us in anyway. Again, cannot comprehend what was the basis for this point? How does that make him pretentious? Seriously, I feel sorry for you. Please refer to the first line of the 3rd point.

    6. Aamir tells the nation not to litter, not to turn off foreigners by being rude to them. This makes him pretentious? ( Aamir Khan tells the nation to be nice to foreigners – written twice in your article. Kindly at least proof read your article before posting. On second thoughts, please don’t post.)
    I almost forgot, please refer to the first line of the 3rd point.

    7. He gets paid crores for every film. Almost all actors of his stature and repute get that. He is socially aware actor, not just because he blogs, he further substantiates that characteristic while choosing the subject of the film. You cannot expect that with likes of Happy New Year, i guess?

    8. He doesn’t give a fuck about other artists? Right in the very first few lines you mentioned that he applauded the other person for doing a better job. Hypocritical much? Everyone is entitled for an opinion, douche. And he was pretty clear and firm about the fact ( in that AIB related interview) that it was his personal opinion. For once, you have a national, rather international celebrity candidly speaking his mind, without paying heed to mindless fucks like you. I am glad someone is doing a logical thing. Something that is expected out of any human, really. And mind you, I am not calling him a “goddamn Socrates”.

    9. Let me keep this as my last point. Your major argument- how can he comment without even reading or watching the respective stuff. Let me ask you a very simple question- Is your article an adaptation of the book 1984 by George Orwell. Your response, i know, would be NO, regardless whether you have read the book or not. Adaptation, in the most simple literary sense, means pick up something from somewhere and tweak it to fit your style. If you have not even read or watched something like that, and I were to ask you did you adapt this article from 1984, you would categorically shout out- a loud, ear numbing, thumping NO. Co-incidence is very different word with a wholly different meaning. I am glad that at least he understands the difference, and those of who don’t, like you, make …..? refer to the 1st line of the 3rd point.
    The points that he made about AIB, Aamir explicitly mentioned that he conversed with Karan (someone who was a the host). He didn’t jump to conclusions by merely conversing with any random guy.

    So, in the end, i’ll pick my closing from just one point that i agree to from your article – Our generation understand subtleties, read between the lines, and can tell an actor from a chutiya. Well not just an actor, just about anybody from a chutiya.

    And you my friend, are one hell of a “chutiya”.
    P.S. I hope i offended you.

    Like

    1. I liked your comment better than the original article. It makes sense. The other one, the article I mean, it sounds like it is written by someone who got rejected by the person he is writing about.

      Like

    2. Excellent response to a very fucked up blog…whats sad in India is that there is hypocrisy in younger generation and in older generation. If you are cheap and vulgar you are defended on the name of freedom of speech and then we say this is what happens in a Roast..what bull shit..but if you disagree to it and post your opinion against this ideology of irresponsible freedom of speech you become a double standard preacher.

      It’s very sad to see the same level of hypocrisy and intolerance in the youth of India against their ideology as elders to there…

      Basically India is a bunch of hypocrites and we have no respect for anyone opinions. All those bunch of loosers who keep cribbing that we have bigger issues than AIB to handle..what the fuck are you doing by making such a fuss of an Actor’s opinion. You are even a bigger chut and a cunt.

      Freedom of speech comes with responsibility and just mimicking a show of the west doesn’t show how creative you are…

      I hope too I have offended this ass writer…

      Like

    3. Yeah some things are true, like marketing and stuff. But everyone knowingly or unknowing is marketing himself, just as you are my friend marketing your blog. But the fact is no one is perfect, not you, not me nor AK. And everyone is entitled to his/her opinion as this is a free country. Its upon us to take other’s opinion seriously or not. So if you don’t like amir’s opinion, stop following him!
      For eg – I as a youth believe that AIB was a good, and AK does not, but by no means AK is “chutiya” for that. As the fact stands, AK has done many gr8 things which I haven’t.

      The problem with you as an author is this – You yourself are a chutiya – Why? Because instead of focusing in your life you are busy being a pessimist and finding faults of Aamir. But of-course this is all for your blog publicity I am sure.

      Also there are many other debatable questions in your blog, but I have other positive things to do in my life than to argue with you.

      And you my friend, are one hell of a “chutiya”.
      P.S. I hope i offended you.

      I have a name, but for a pessimist like you, I will always be a chutiya!

      Like

  114. Dosto,

    Sab se pehle big mighty fucking round of applause for Heart Rajan, for bringing this shit in public.

    I personally didn’t like what happened during 3 Idiots but I was chutiya enough not to do anything about the Chetan Bhagat book adaptation controversy. Anyway! Her’s my point; it is good to educate the world about various issues using your public image; however, targeting controversial yet an iconic artists like AIB is severe. Yes, freedom of fucking expression? Dude, remember this KRK chap? he is just speaking his mind and why he there’s no action against him?

    Because he didn’t call any celebs name in a mighty sold out open roast gig but on youtube. If you want to play fair about freedom of expression; why biases?

    Be it AIB, Kapil Sharma or fucking Chris Rock; rule should be clear and there’s something for adults, should be taken as adults not dolts or just don’t be bunch of wimpy assholes.

    Like

  115. Also, Taare zameen par was amol gupte’s brain child not Aamir’s. and OMG released 3 years back with exact similar points like pk.
    but dude, you literally snatched words out of my mouth. Bravo!

    Like

  116. I would prefer supporting a person who is doing something (even if it’s to generate awareness or bring it to media forefront) than a person who is sitting generating fucking opinions about “random stuff”. I don’t understand what’s riling you up so bad that instead of your bread and butter (movie reviews), you start judging people…

    Live(make a difference) and let live!

    Like

  117. Just because the guy said something about AIB roast which has clearly “offended” you… you now write this piece of shit to bash him… way to go !!!!! * claps* …..
    Even i dont hold the same views as his of AIB roast as him but it is not write undermine the good things he is doing as an actor

    Like

  118. Quite true… I’ve held this rather dismissive opinion about Mr. AK since post Lagaan… I looked at it as his getting way too preachy… but Heartranjan, whoever you are… you have said it well…

    Like

  119. Why, just why do you hate Amir Khan so? Did he refuse to sign your autograph book when you were a kid? Respect the fact that he is at least attempting to spread awareness even if he is charging money for it. Guess what? A lot of people are influenced by what he says or does. THAT, my friend, is working towards a better society. Posting hate blogs, like you, is not doing anyone any good, even if you don’t take money for it.

    Like

  120. “The audience you deal with is thirty years younger to you, a completely different generation.”

    And yet pk made 650 crores worldwide. So even though there is a generation gap, he has his finger on the pulse of this generation as the film has been loved and watched to an extent where it made history with it’s grossing!

    But being a massive Aamir fan, I do stand by AIB in their fight for freedom of speech. It was not on primetime TV, it was on youtube. It may or may not hurt people, but nobody has a right to ban it. Sounds familiar right? Just like our Supreme Court told about pk.

    But I am still going to watch his movies, because his personal opinions are his, just like mine. That should not come in between me and his movies.

    Like

  121. Hi,
    I think after reading this blog…. i feel like saying “F* Off Ass*e” to the writer because he seems to be obsessed with Aamir Khan the superstar only… and not Aamir Khan the guy-next-door who went through 1 wrecked marriage (with 2 kids) and 1 alleged affair with some non-Indian and then a second marriage with someone much younger to him… and managed to do his roles to the best of his human capabilities…. So don’t mind…but please stay off the turf… like I will after writing this blog.. 🙂

    Like

  122. Now, I disagree with Aamir’s stand on the AIB Knockout. I thoroughly enjoyed the Knockout as a guilty pleasure, and I don’t think he has the authority to talk about it after Delhi Belly. I think your point there is fully justified. However, I don’t think you need to bash on his ENTIRE career graph and past work simply because of that ONE comment. Isn’t this whole argument about everyone having the right to freedom of speech? Yes, Aamir’s argument may be flawed, yes, you may not disagree with it, but you have no right to bash the ENTIRE career of one of India’s most talented and respected thespians.

    You also mention issues with his social work and “Satyamev Jayate” being too soppy and melodramatic. Yes, the show may be a bit overdone, but are these not issues facing India today? At least Aamir has done something (actually, a LOT of good things) for society. Name one actor from the current generation of actors who has publicly stood up for social causes plaguing India such as poverty and illiteracy? The only examples I can think of are Priyanka Chopra who has made great efforts for education of the girl child and Shraddha Kapoor who has done a lot for the Kashmir flood victims in recent times. We oftentimes complain that the film industry is shallow-minded and aloof from society’s issues – so why are we chastising Mr. Khan for actually giving a damn about the world around him? It’s a classic case of damned if you do and damned if you don’t.

    Like

  123. Dear Heartranjan I understand you have also joined the line of ‘becoming famous by speaking against Aamir’.
    Well,
    Aamir repeatedly said it was his opinion about AIB and who is he to comment. He saw 2clips of it from KJo and Arjun Kapoor and found it verbally violent,that’s why he didn’t see the entire video.
    Aamir don’t attend Indian awards coz they are so original. Now many celebs have started quitting award shows coz of their originality.LOL.
    3 idiots story only had an outline of Chetan bhagat’s Five point someone. when VVC and Raju hirani told him that his name will appear in the end credits he was ok at that. only after 3Idiots became bumper hit this writer came up with excuses that he was not given credits.

    Cross check your facts before writing a blog. And yes freedom of speech doesn’t let you speak anything you wish to. so, kindly SHUT UP.

    Like

  124. Can I be on your blog header? On a side note, that was hilarious and on point! Well needed response to an insecure, attention-seeking douche. I hope this gets some viral coverage and buries all the damage caused by the unnecessary complaining against what was actually a brilliant show. One can dream…

    Like

  125. Your blog is about what many think of Mr. Peferctionist but have not been able to put it in words not because of lack of courage but because they prefer ignoring him. But with his stupid comments on AIB, even though he does not know what the show was about, he has gone a little over his pseudo intellectual image. I have always considered Aamir Khan to be a little overrated. Like you said, it is his job to read the script and adapt the character that he going to play. I am sure many actors do that but do not go conducting press conferences about it. Aamir Khan should really learn how actors like KK Menon, Irfan Khan and others do much better than him but don’t go all blabbering about it all the time. As far as AIB is concerned, it was a show made in good humour for people who understand it. I am sure Khan does not fit in that category.

    Like

  126. Reblogged this on the eyes of my mind and commented:
    He is doing something with Satyameva Jayate.. I do not completely agree with this blog, but it definitely is an interesting viewpoint. And that is what I want to put forward by a Reblog

    Like

  127. I sense some tall poppy syndrome here. Leave the guy alone. He is who he is, that is, an amazing actor. Why should he attend the awards shows? Kangana doesn’t either. Leonardo DiCaprio didn’t attend the Oscars when Titanic was nominated for a dozen awards or so. FYI, a number of Bollywood actors and people from the industry criticized the AIB show, not just Aamir. Perhaps they didn’t speak up, but he felt the need to express his view on it. Who cares? Never mind what he says. Never mind what generation we are from, we are all open to expressing our own opinions. That’s essentially all Aamir was doing here. The journalist asking the question, probably thought hey, why not ask the question. This guy has balls and isn’t scared about what the world says about him. Aamir is an amazing talent and will continue to be successful no matter what gets in his way. Oh and by the way, breaking news, SRK also releases one film a year now. In fact, most Hollywood actors follow the same route too. I suggest you stop posting such offensive material and just be happy with the way the world is. 🙂

    Like

  128. A sign of success is the criticism u get frm cheap loosers… If u r offended by my callin u a looser…rest assure its xactly wht I wanted. And according to Mr writer we shud now promote a new from of art. Art of slang. How thotful of u. Whn u bcom a parent do get ur child admission into slang school as a cocarricular activity.. But hv to say ur bolg ws funny.

    Like

  129. worst verdict n thinking on wordpress.
    try to post something with logic next time
    1st of all he said- ‘main hota kaun hu bolnewala? lekin aur logo ke tarah mera bhi opinion hai. I did not see it but heard the script from karan and arjun. There are many people who liked it but i did not. This is just my personal opinion.I think liberty and responsibility should be maintained together.’
    I think that one of the main purposes of AIB roast was -‘tolerance and freedom of speech’.. then why can’t u tolerate someone who has not liked ur event personally?Isn’t it hypocrisy? or beacuse someone with 10 times more popularity than AIB n his supporters combined , has gone against it? what’s the reason?
    Let’s come to Delhi Belly. The film had A certificate and was not telecasted on tv, social networking site or you tube . It was only shown in theatres and you must know that auidence is filtered for A grade flm. The film did not deal with insulting or abusing real living persons.
    On the contrary, AIb did not use any filter.
    Now,let’s come to a point. Deepika Padukone got offended by TOI reporting and she is a face of women empowerment and she is enjoying this show publicly .Whoa!! great.
    Recently, she found that her dance number ‘Lovely’ in Happy New Year film was ‘Cheap’.She just did it some months back. Is she a 5 yrs old child or dumb?
    When KRK said ‘sonakshi has the sexiest butt in bollywood’
    sonakshi got offended.Now, she is enjoying. Hypocrite or matter of money?\
    Last but not the least , AIB has not done anything great .Don’t highlight this issue this much.
    P.S.: Aamir also said that he is against ‘freedom of speech’ or ‘any kind of forceful removal of video or banning’. I hope ,you get it. Don’t behave like a 15 years old kid .
    Worst blog.

    Like

    1. mate, did you even read what you typed down?
      sir, please de-stress your breasts.
      calm the calamities that are in your mammaries.
      soothe your boobs.
      don’t have a rack attack.

      also, you’re trying to correlate the objectification of a woman in a prestigious newspaper read by millions of people across the country (for which she hadn’t given her consent) to the rather crude humour present in a public show in where all of the participants of the said act had given their consent, including the famous personalities. *sigh*
      sir, Deepika got offended because they published a WHOLE news paper article about her bloody breasts.
      Now take a step back, you said “I think that one of the main purposes of AIB roast was -‘tolerance and freedom of speech’.. then why can’t u tolerate someone who has not liked ur event personally?” an opinion expressed is not what bothers people, however a rather blissfully ignorant opinion expressed on national television is what get’s on the nerves of many people. including mine. i’m on the verge of being 18 (getting that driver’s licence, fuck yeah!) and i find your *cough* shit *cough* rather unbearable. heck this is what is known as a serious case of verbal diarrhoea. i could go on and on, but i think everyone here get’s the point.

      so, errrr… ummm.. other than blithering stupidity, what did you say your major was?

      signing off,
      another random person on the internet who’s had enough of your shit (literal and metaphorical) cheerio 🙂

      Like

    2. This is one of the dumbest blog posts i ever read, and it is a waste of wordpress and the internet. But on other note, do i care about a few KB of space huh? Guess i don’t. Oh but wait, my time. That split second when i clicked on this link from a random Facebook share. Argh, its not coming back so why not tell this heartranjan guy that my friend, your post sucks.

      I hope you don’t want to become a writer because then the only job you can ever find is with Times of India writing their “TOI point of view” columns. You kinda implied somewhere that you are a part of “generation that sees through bullshit”. I think you forgot that the same “generation” or whatever you mean by that, that they will read your article too but well, understandingly fail to “see through it” because there is so much bullshit in it, its a pile And then again, no one cares enough about a random internet post and bad one at that.

      This generation can tell actors from a chutiya (as you mention rightly in your post), but can also can tell a chutiya from a writer. Once in a while, a dangerous combination of chutiya+writer like yourself come out and so its hard to tell the difference. A rare mix you see.

      Freedom of expression…wow, we all love it. As you rightly noted, we are not a nation of chimpanzees, so do express but make sure you don’t come out sounding like a chimpanzee.

      Like

      1. And then you wasted another 5 minutes, or whatever time it took you, to type this useless comment instead of ignoring the post which you think is “one of the dumbest blog posts i ever read, and it is a waste of wordpress and the internet”.

        Not commenting on the post but the hypocrisy of your own comment.

        Like

    3. I think the main point of this blog was that these days, the current generation is a lot smarter and can see though a lot of BS. Instead of blind and unconditional hero-worshiping and idolizing, we have more ability to take things with a pinch of salt!
      The points you make to counter this blog may be valid but sadly I feel that it still purely in support of one individual and that sounds like hero-worshiping to me.

      Like

  130. What ever you have written here is so generalist and contradictory that it cancels out itself . Its good that you recognize the fact that youth today reads between the lines , But when you know that they do and still his movies are multi – crore hits, are you youthful enough to read between the lines . He doesn’t give a shit about other artist is there problem and not his my friend(Its a civilized jungle). Nobody thinks of him anything more than what he is ” An Actor” and if they do, trust me they will take some time to understand what a blog is?(i:e not your audience) . I think you are talking about your perception of him and not of him for real . Anyways kudos to you for expressing yourself.

    Like

  131. Dude, firstly, I loved AIB, and as non Aamir Khan Fan, I totally agree with his opinion, it really is very important for actors to take responsibility before they say something in public and he mentioned time and again “that it is his personal opinion” and other actors might like or not, but he didn’t personally liked it. The fact about he doesn’t believe in awards is because these so called Indian awards are biased and he hates it for that reason, and he attended Oscars because we all know why it is called Oscars.
    This guy is at such level of acting, I can guarantee he would make 100 crores more if he want to by making bullshit and meaningless movies and dancing in wedding etc., but instead, he opts out to make Satyameva Jayate and brings out some of the things which are unnoticed which (stars of Mr. Bachan, SRK, Salman who all are game show hosts wouldn’t) So, please least thing you can do is give him some respect, Else go GET A LIFE.

    Like

    1. Dude, Firstly, do point out your secondlies.

      Criticism is one of the things that can possibly construct you. Too much praise makes you slack. So keeping Aamirs good qualities aside is how you should view this article. That is how he should view this article. Criticism. Period.

      I stand by the author on his views. And I dont agree with Aamirs in the least. A celebrity who makes shows like Satyamev.. should speak responsibly himself. What is freedom of speech or expression? Is it freedom to talk about celeb gossip? Is it freedom to rant about current affairs? You dont need freedom for that. You need freedom for going against the tide. If AIB is made to shut up then its that freedom that has been curbed. Curtailing ones liberties are the seeds of fundamentalism. There is no end to it. As a society you will never be in a 100pc agreement on all issues.

      No one should decide for another what he or she should choose to do. There are no exceptions to this rule. If there are then you are not free.

      Like

    2. If AIB should take responsbility for what they say shouldnt Aamir ask Bollywood to stp showcasing sexual harassment as the only way to get a girl in the movies? Boy meets girl, chases girl, irritates her, stops her from going where she wants, a song later and they are in Loouuu. Why cant Aamir ask his Bollywood pals to be responsible there? Why does disagreeing with someone mean one doesnt respect them. Oh right. You have watched too many Bollywood movies

      Like

  132. Dear Mr X,
    (Please allow me to address you as ‘X’ as you surely represent those who spend better part of their lives and their writing skills (kudos! You write well) in fault-finding among others, well, poor Bollywood actors are just a soft target)
    So you seem to be analyzing each and every thing that Aamir Khan did and follow every word that he said and surprisingly you didn’t even find a single positive thing there. Isn’t that a case of a serious ‘pessimist’ disorder? Or is that what you do as a hobby – following actors’ every act and move, on screen and off screen, just to write a “fucking” long article on your blog just whenever you feel like doing something more creative than criticizing? And congratulations, this time your efforts have paid off, you are “fucking” all over Facebook and now you can enjoy your moments of fame till the next time you come up with another 500 words lambasting another actor or a politician or anyone else who may be trying to do something good, but you, you, you, are an expert in fault-finding and in critically analyzing. Who knows the “PR” fraternity that you mention, may take a note of you and seek your help in promoting some actors through bad publicity, you will surely excel in the field!
    You begin with Lagaan and mention everything that Aamir did. Can we just leave what the actor did or say and just feel proud that it was an Indian film at the Oscars? You say that there is nothing great in him doing one film a year or in preparing extensively for the character, I agree that is expected of any actor, but how many of actors are able to do the justice to the role despite tall talks and massive promotions. Aamir at least knows his job! You go on to talk about his involvement with social and political issues, give examples of his films (and you have done an extensive research in compiling the list of controversies around Aamir and his film) without realizing that at least, for whatever motive, he has been making some efforts and to you it may just be a “method” to fool people, but at the ground level did you check how much right or wrong he is or if he has actually made difference to some people’s lives? Surely you would not know about those as you have conveniently followed armchair reporting to gather your facts. I wish you would have done some groundwork and with the brilliant writing skills that you have, you could have come up with the balanced piece of writing. Why a one-sided perspective? Just because you are not convinced enough or you don’t find anything “fucking” good in whatever he does? Being a pseudo-intellect can help in you being a hero for a day but such gimmicks do not last.
    And this…Mr X is not from a die-hard Aamir Khan fan but a common person who expected to read a balanced view in an article that has gone viral today!
    Regards

    Like

    1. Ma’am,
      This article isn’t about how “awesome” Aamir Khan is. You seem to have taken the phrase ” Don’t judge a book by its cover” too literally. You wrote a “fucking” (Pardon my French) long comment for an article which was all about him being pretentious. Every piece of writing need not be balanced.
      Regards.

      Like

    2. Butthurt much?
      This article was about criticizing the actor for his hypocritical “shit”, not praise him. Period.

      Like

  133. Aamir Khan is a perfectionist means he is meticulous about his work but he need not be a perfectionist in life. Patriotic roles are limited to movies, an actor does not have to be a patriot to take up such roles. Everyone has their own opinion about everything.

    Like

    1. considering the fact that the writer above wrote a blog post which went viral, highlighting the key issues in our society for the youth to read, i’d say he’s given at least 1% of the effort Aamir khan has given to his movies. then again, what is it you said that you did to make this “place” a wee bit “better” than it is right now?

      Like

  134. The author has a point. but,the fact is that Aamir has seen 2 out of the 3 videos (in bits) of AIB Knockout; which is enough to judge if it’s offensive or not. You just need one scene carrying sexually explicit content to declare the movie a porn. Similarly, he’s come across several instances of offences and swear words in probably the 5 minutes or so that he could watch. I am a big AIB and TVF fan; like a really big one. I’ve followed them since their inception, I’ve interacted with them and I even feed them back personally. And to me, AIB Knockout is a brilliant work. But, at the same time, Aamir isn’t entirely wrong. He has made a very important statement that has missed out in this blog. He said,’Gaaliyaan sunke hassi aane ki aur umar rahi nahi meri. Agar main 16-17 saal ka hota to shayad hassi aati mujhe’. So, my point is that if it isn’t funny for him, then he has to take the swear words without the pinch of humour; and therefore he doesn’t have to take it in the first place. END OF IT[.] I am not saying Aamir is a completely right. I am merely clarifying a point that he has in fact watched the video, enough to decide if it’s offensive or not.

    Like

  135. Couldn’t focus much because all that came across from this article was the writers anger and frustration! If you really think Aamir Khan is such a fuck why bother writing to him & explaining it all. And if this in the end is all about freedom of speech then maybe Aamir has the right to his too I have always liked Aamir Khan’s work because he has touched on topics no one dares to look at or talk about. Obviously he is not perfect but i do believe he challenges the norms. What the fuck was the whole point of this article other than you trying to garner attention?

    Like

  136. Your writing has humour and your point that Aamir Khan should be more cautious before speaking out his mind is public is justified. One must not boss over things knowing the partial truth. But again , being a public figure, whom people look up to , his job and effort must be applauded.
    On the issue of AIB , I have no grudge against the content of the show( and I have seen it). The only issue that becomes contentious is the impact of the language on the growing Indian kids. Me and you as grown ups can take the thing in lighter way(I found it amusing , not the entire show though) but the children and adolescents may create a different story altogether. I have been following the proceedings on the same carefully and can confidently say that censirship may seem to be unjust on the grounds of the freedom of expression. Though the mode of dissemination remains an issue with such a diverse crowd on the internet.

    Like

  137. Did u read what Aamir Khan said :”He saw some clips” and he also mentioned about “Delhi Belly” . Plz see the video before writing anything from next time 🙂

    Like

  138. well, blogger have a choice here

    1. Moron – you butthurt halfbaked ‘young’ prick, go fuck with your sloppy onesided asshole logic.
    2. Well, though I strongly disagree, it’s free country, its perfectly alright to have different opinion.

    chose whatever suits you!

    Like

  139. Ok I undersrand that you dont like Amir for some reason … that doesn’t mean you can prove whatever he did is wrong. Your article looks like a attempt to show your hate towarda him .. nothing else …
    Yes actually every actor has to go deep in his movie script and shoukd change his appearance … but how many actors do that? Many good things which he do is may be quite obvious for a actor or person to do. But can you say that every man in this world or in yiur city or in your locality or may be yourself is doing what you should do? I know that its not true and people who do what they shoukd do always stand out.
    Whatever 3 idiot was trying to tell .. many movie did … and true in my view… but you dont have a word to say to anyone else but Amir because u dont like him.
    Whatever he said in PK also done by many movies but you have point only for PK .. PK didnt said a word fir releagion but only questioned the way we fillow it. And question on those who are making it a business. So stop writing stupid articles and first focus on what you are supposed to do . If u are a writer then write something meaning full ..

    Like

  140. It is commendable that the internet today has provided a platform to address the public, to anyone with a passing knowledge of technology and/or creative writing. The author of this blog, however, may be well advised to keep his daily job.
    There are two ways to write a blog: either adopt a journalistic style, conduct thorough research and present the facts objectively; or write fiction. The author of this blog straddles both styles and comes up with his own unique creation.
    Firstly, you will find ‘evidence’ being presented in this video about the reality of the 3 idiots/Chetan Bhagat debacle.

    Bhagat sold his rights, signed a contract accepting rolling credits at the end and spoke up only when the movie became a big hit. He himself told Aamir Khan that reading the book wasn’t necessary (which he admits on camera) so you could hardly blame Khan for not reading it.
    Secondly, he admits using foul language in Delhi Belly which was only accessible to an adult audience. His concern regarding the roast was that AIB should have regulated the dissemination of such adult-specific material so it doesn’t reach minors (note, with “virality” comes “responsibility”). For example, AIB could have prevented the free dissemination of their clips (using copyright laws). Of course, they didn’t, because AIB wanted publicity. Now, should we censor adult material- that is a matter of debate. Personally, I think not- kids nowadays can find access to all the crass language if they want to. But it is Aamir’s personal opinion, and by the same token of free speech, he is entitled to it.
    Finally, Aamir’s opinion was that he didn’t find the roast funny. Neither did I. And I don’t find Russell Peter’s jokes funny- because he laughs at people, not with them. Same as AIB. If this is the new trend the comedians, including yourself, wish to adopt then I am disappointed.
    It is not surprising that people like Russell Peters and yourself have taken the opportunity to gain some free publicity by commenting on this topic, because it takes a bit more depth to comment on socially relevant topics that matter rather than a stupid roast and what some actor said about it. I like Aamir’s acting and think he was right in the situations above, but in general how do I care what he thinks of another show?
    Maybe instead of writing such pointless posts, use your time to watch George Carlin instead and learn how to be really funny, or read some books (ideally, NOT Chetan Bhagat) and improve your writing skills?

    Like

    1. omg… thanks devdeep to post this video here…..Mr ranjan..now what will u say on your fake and baseless blog :p… ppl are really blind to follow him without even confirming…. thats called ‘Bhed-Chaal’… :p

      Like

  141. First, I like the view of writer about Aamir Khna’s approach. It is the critique . Every actor and artist have to face. But it seems only Aamir Khan never been challenged for his views and opinions. I think Aamir Khan has no any proper idealogy but he is well focused on marketing. He become brand and ambassador of a new fashion of social negative thinking . He plays his role Anna Hajare for upper middle class. He is also playing role as a group leader for them who worried about every thing going wrong but don’t come forward to take initiative for solutions . This situation of entire nation has been captured by Anna , Modi < Kejariwal and Ammir Khan . Market gets high for all of them.

    Like

  142. 1. You have to admit, the Oscars are a class apart from most of the FMCG sponsored “award shows” that transpire here. A great many of our Bollywood movies deserve little more than a Razzie, if that. Of course there is still a lot of politics and you have to promote the movie for it to stand a chance. And what’s wrong with admitting that the competition was better than you?

    2. You admit that Aamir chooses his movies carefully, reads the scripts etc. but then dismisses these efforts as what an actor is supposed to do. Even by your own admission Aamir would get top score when graded on the curve of Indian actors, so what’s really wrong? Sure, he might not do so well if you compare to the body of the world’s artists but who in India would, really?

    3. I tend to stay away from Bollywood movies because, you know, I like to keep my skin and sanity. But I actually enjoyed Taree Zameen Par, 3 Idiots and Pk. Why? What’s different about these movies? Well, for one they surprised me; I couldn’t predict the ending after the first 15 minutes of the movie. Maybe our generation has higher standards from all those pirated Hollywood movies that we’re awash in but those movies worked for me despite our re-calibrated palette.

    4. 3 Idiots: My first impression after I saw the movie was ‘This is so different from the book’ and in this case I’d say it was a drastic improvement. I had expected that they movie would be a line by line redux of the book very much like, say, the ‘Girl with the Dragon Tattoo’. But ‘3 Idiots’ takes the characters and synopsis from the book and then deviates heavily in tone and almost all the details. Some of it is Bollywood masala but even that is used judiciously. IMO, this works way better as a movie than a faithful adaptation would have.

    5. If you’re good at something why do it for free? People here have a general tendency to demonize people who get paid ‘crores’. Sure, there are a lot of corrupt people who got rich that way but that doesn’t mean someone who works for it should be diminished because of his paycheck. I have to make the cliched argument here: If Aamir gets paid crores that’s because that’s exactly the figure the market would support.

    Like

  143. This is one of the dumbest blog posts i ever read, and it is a waste of wordpress and the internet. But on other note, do i care about a few KB of space huh? Guess i don’t. Oh but wait, my time. That split second when i clicked on this link from a random Facebook share. Argh, its not coming back so why not tell this heartranjan guy that my friend, your post sucks.

    I hope you don’t want to become a writer because then the only job you can ever find is with Times of India writing their “TOI point of view” columns. You kinda implied somewhere that you are a part of “generation that sees through bullshit”. I think you forgot that the same “generation” or whatever you mean by that, that they will read your article too but well, understandingly fail to “see through it” because there is so much bullshit in it, its a pile And then again, no one cares enough about a random internet post and bad one at that.

    This generation can tell actors from a chutiya (as you mention rightly in your post), but can also can tell a chutiya from a writer. Once in a while, a dangerous combination of chutiya+writer like yourself come out and so its hard to tell the difference. A rare mix you see.

    Freedom of expression…wow, we all love it. As you rightly noted, we are not a nation of chimpanzees, so do express but make sure you don’t come out sounding like a chimpanzee.

    Like

  144. Heartranjan.. Let me tell you what is your problem:

    1. Start having a wonderful family life . Be good to wife / girlfriends if not married. Got kids – look at them as angels in disguise. Start living truly loving by heart.. it will reduce the number of times you use the word ” fuck” . Nature switches on floodlights on our unexpressed deprivations at wrong times, at times.

    2. Read the book “Tell tale brain” by the MarcoPolo of neurology , Dr.V S Ramachandran. At this confused stage, this book in its simplicity, will help you understand your brain related problems so that you take some serious efforts before you become a full fledged psycho

    3. The only change that as of now you are capable of making is shoot a few porns and corrupt the young. Upgrade yourself. Start believing that the youth of our country now has learnt to DECIDE on its own based on its intellect and NOT borrowed intellect. Today, even if Buddha comes and talks to them, they would respectfully say ” Thanks , I will look into it ” . I’m talking about the “aam youth” , who as per you are prone to being influenced by an Aamir Khan and not the youth that is a clone of arrogant individuals like your goodself , who have no value for either money or values ( kuonki baap ka paisa haina ) and completely deprived of social skills – the real psychopaths camouflaged in vanity .

    4. I’m neither a fan of Aamir Khan nor a critic. I just like his approach . His roadmap. Even Buddha had a roadmap – he quit after marital bliss 🙂 . I love Buddha , and have his picture in my living room. So Buddhist readers, please dont get me wrong.

    5. Last question – Who the **** do you think you are ? You as******, make a million dollar by being productive and move your *****. This is how I want to ask . But right now, I’m writing this in my Buddhamood. So my last words would be – ” Look for what you think you dont have from the inside. You will start BEing Happy “

    Like

  145. I think in trying to read between the lines, you forgot to read the lines. This reads more like a hate mail. Why are you soooo offended at his opinion? He could not digest the roast but u seem to be having a verbal diarrhea. Ultimately you are riding piggyback on Amir to get your 5 seconds of fame. The roast is over, stop your grilling and go home. *yawn*

    Like

  146. Hey Blogger were U beaten by Aamir Khan or did he hurt u personally!! Because this shit looks more like vengeance than revealing the bullshit truth!! And AIB accepted was well made charity show but messing around with religion is not some civilization. Its messing around with our beliefs and once belief is gone then will u give the people new freaking bullshit to believe in. Speaking about Christianity was off the limits. U would have reacted too if some1 spoke nonsense shit about ur religion and still Aamir spoke though he is not a christian!!U speak as if u were born with Aamir in the same hospital and were lying in adjacent freaking cradles. U assume u know much but first go and research and then put up ur bulls!! So before blogging anymore bulsl about others first blog all the collections of shit about ur ownself!!

    Like

  147. Ok so you are angry with his response. But how can you write words like chutya, fuck on print which many youngsters (who are thirty years younger than Aamir Khan) can read. You could have made all the points without writing the expletives. Which is why I think anyone with a position of responsibility should hold themselves accountable for.
    Coming to AK, he is pretentious and a marketeer. If you think he is doing the social stuff because he means to, then you are a dumbwit. He has a PR team and they advise him on what’s good or bad for him. Dont hold him (or for that matter anyone) to a special status. Its not his fault, but ours
    Next about AIB roast. It was funny whatever I saw on youtube. The problem I have with naysayers is that it was a pvt show for a pvt audience who paid money for it. If they arent complaining, then no issues. But have to say, that the promotion was on youtube which is a free-for-all view and the marketing should have been appropriate with “above 18/21” whatever that doesn’t allow access to youngsters.
    Finally, this is a controversy that doesn’t deserve a controversy. So let’s get on with our lives and do something useful with the limited time we have
    Cheers

    Like

  148. His opinion may not be right according to the most of us but he has the right to one. You don’t have to see things happen to have an opinion, you may have one on a topic regardless. And pls whoever wrote this does not realise that this nation has made him who he is. There is a damn good reason for why he is what he is and why his films make it to the oscars. Sure when SRK wins all the awards for Happy New Year, one wonders if they are worth it, when he is competing with the likes of Haider and PK. PK today is the biggest money maker ever after Dhoom 3, both starring Aamir. This country loves him for whatever he is. In a 100 lifetimes you won’t achieve what Aamir has. 😃

    Like

  149. Noone is perfect human being, I didn’t supported his crew n Hiranis- “Pk” imposing liberalism over general way of life, but then again I do support his assertion on the roast culture and his criticism of the whole thing. If standing for something righteous is hypocrisy these days then we do need large number of hypocrites in this society.

    Like

  150. Now, even though Chetan Bhagat is the Rakhi Sawant of Indian literature, he wrote the book and sold millions, and no one can take that away from him. If you’ve read 5 Point Someone, and watched 3 Idiots, and you possess the IQ of a garden lizard, you’ll know that the film is more or less an adaptation of the book. – Had me in splits! You were bang on! Loved the post!

    Like

  151. Kudos for writing the truth. In media, particularly English media in India there are snobbish people, devoid of commonsense who call anything that does not match their little world pure bullshit. Do not mind the language of these self proclaimed intellectuals. Truth must be spoken. And you have done great job at that.

    Like

  152. Lol. It was a funny read. A bit too angry though. Not taking it seriously though, just as I’d done for the AIB roast video or Aamir’s response to it. Afterall it started with a joke, everyone has made their money and gone home, so why so serious? 😉 Keep writing though

    Like

  153. I looked at this comment section and I am disappointed at the level of intelligence of most people.
    Is it so difficult to see how hypocritical aamir khan is?
    Do people really have such a low intelect that they attach their intelligence to an irrelevant actor?
    No, hosting an awareness show does not mean that he stands for any damn thing (especially when he gets paid crores per episode).

    P.S. : will the aamir-fags stop being so butthurt about criticizm of him? (most of it is true if you look at it without bias)

    Like

  154. Hi Heartranjan (First I would like to mention that I am not Amir Khan fan I am like u 🙂 ) … so if I collected correctly few points from your blog you are saying
    (i) Is he national hero? Is it all Amir Khan’s responsibility for India’s reform?
    My Opinion: Do you have any idea about his fan following? He is asking all indians to keep their city/street clean, Respect foreigners also He is raising social issues (and not just raising but giving solution also sometimes ). Can you expect other actors to do the same. His movies are doing fine like Srk, Salman, Hrtik etc. But he doesn’t sell hair oil, biscuits , Home loans, under-wears etc. (and even if he does, its his very right). I think even every Indian should participate in country reforms but people like you would question other if he/she is coming forward to do so. As far as his earnings are concerns he got talent/brain, which he is using for himself (or for his family) and also for country by giving some message to the society.
    (ii) Amir Khan doesn’t read and doesn’t see what other people has written and shown, before commenting on others.
    My Opinion: First tell me, did you see his complete interview and comments on AIB? I dont think so. otherwise you wouldn’t mention this thing. Go and watch it you will get your answer.And also watch other interview about plagiarism (BTW as per my knowledge he is not a script writer and did not write for 3 idiots at least)
    (iii) He is not perfectionist whatever he is doing , he is supposed to do that.
    My Opinion: Who are you ? A student ? A professional? An activist? whoever you are ! Ask this question to yourself do you do what you are supposed to do? (By seeing your writing skills and topic chosen I hope Not !). If everybody does what he/she is supposed to do then so many problems will be eradicated automatically dude(Don’t you think so?).

    **Remarks** I wish I could know the F*** language like you but I have been never trained and not allowed to use that.

    Like

  155. The fastest way to fame is to be willing to be controversial . Attacking Aamir Khan, the most popular guy among the youth is a great strategy. Seems like you have been taking marketing classes Mr. Heartranjan!

    Like

  156. What I find is the blog is super hit.. as many have come across the blog and commented on it whether positive or negative with the content. Congratulation Dear author, you are successful in doing so. In my personal opinion, this generation seeks the freedom of speech and so the AIB show, so why the question is arising when Amir put his personal opinion. If someone is airing a show to promote the freedom of speech, then he/she should be ready to accept some positive and negative feedback. If you don’t praise them so have left positive remarks for you, how you are blaming those feedback negatively? This is hypocrisy. Amir has his personal choice to attend any award so or not. Unlike other “big stars” of bollywood, I find the Amir’s movie are way more sensible, so I like him. Someone may like Sharukh’s or Salman’s. That is their choice.
    I read the whole blog, but sorry could not read all comments. I found the some comments are way more sensible than the blog itself, but dear author, congratulation for the success after writing article.

    Like

      1. What I understand, the problem isn’t about the opinion that Amir Khan or any other person has. It is more about how aware you are about the issue before expressing your opinion about it, that being the difference between a informative debate and the mockery we call ‘parliament’. There’s no problem with someone really knowing everything, the problem lies when we pretends to do so and cares to judge other about it.

        Like

  157. Let me say like this in the tone of ” Arjun and Ranveer” – ” Acha Ranjan, tu blog mein itna gali kyu deta yar? .. Ok sache dil sey batha…. Tu apne lund sey wordpress ko hilatha hey ya us par chilata hey?” Leek Bodsk.. ##$^&*)))(((*&&&^%%$$$## ” To Blogger banega?”

    Dude, what are you trying to prove here? Same what Amir Khan said in his opinion. This is just Your Opinion Bro… Like wise everyone has opinion. I am not a big fan of his monkey ears any how.. but dont you find a logic that your just trying to target just one person with your so called statistical and over-logical hypothesis. . All you are trying to do is conversion here, with imposing your facts and figures on someone.. see if you liked ALL INDIA BOSDKS so much, Then Chill dude… even I kinda liked few but it doesnt mean that everyone should… When you are saying in your opinion ” If you dont like it , then dont watch ” – Is it not also Fair ” when you don’t like his opinion, Why Care” ? Why should you really have to waste space in wordpress … Tu bhi Amir sey bhi Bada Intelligent BOSDK nikla yar…

    Few Funny things i tried making artistics now…

    Ranjan- Your Blog looks like a Penis but its actually used Condom…. 😛

    When Ranjan Writes Blog , its not called Blogging , its called Adultery …

    Why is the Blog called HeartRanjan , because it cant be called PenisRanjan because he has Pussy ….

    When Ranjan Wrote about Amir, He was actually thinking about Salman. Because he cant find the difference between their dick.

    Ranjan __________________________/\___________________________________

    Like

        1. I think you mean ‘you are anything BUT funny’.

          I like your Username, but I’m sorry, I don’t Dhoom With dudes who miss words! 😀

          Stop being so serious, man. You take the blog more seriously than I do.

          Like

          1. Haha. But sir, not everyone has “Heart” like yours. This Solar System has even lesser mortal like us who take offense on even silliest things. I hope you are not “Fuckingly” annoyed with it :))

            Like

        1. Fact of the matter is that in-spite of AK having espoused and pontificated on social issues with the gravitas unexpected of a movie star, his AIB response comes across as a self-righteous and sanctimonious expression. I am a big fan of AK and irrespective of the intellectual horsepower of the AIB show, I didn’t expect AK’s response which was the absolute complete anti-thesis to his stand on Delhi Belly, freedom of creativity etc.

          Like

  158. The worst last 10 minutes i ever spent!

    Dear Garden Lizard with a chic pea sized brain,
    the man has made sense when he said – Its about freedom of speech. We are all on the same page with that, but for freedom of speech, thought and action you need a certain sensibility and maturity of thought. N please stop digging dead skeletons. Its highly unproductive.

    Lets talk about the issue at hand…The AIB roast being freely available online for any and every one to watch.
    If there are no filters and this is exposed to the impressionable kids how do you think things will be? do you not expect more abuse, more bullying and more of all that high school shit?
    A 2012 global youth online behavior survey showed There are as many as 53% kids in India are bullied… some in school, some online..some ridiculed of their appearance and some for multitude of other reasons and some sadly enough resort to killing themselves… as it seems less painful.

    So yes enjoy such humour but be responsible enough as a mature adult to ensure that its filtered. And that’s what Aamir is said.
    And if in spite of all of it you can not understand why filtering is important then well i should really expect much out of a garden lizard…

    Like

    1. nice reply mansi…. but these ppl are misguided …abuse is abuse and its always wrong.. and theseppl are trying to make a wrong thing right by saying that sabhi to bolte hai…. inhe ye samjhna cahhaiye ki kuch logo ke bolne se galat sahi nahi ho jaayega….a buse will always remain abuse… mo matter in fun or in anger 😀

      Like

    2. Where are the filters when songs like “Munni Badnaam Hui” etc are played at kids birthday parties. Where are the filters when young kids are taught that dancing implies rubbing ones crotch against someone else and making supposedly orgasmic faces? Where are the filters when Bollywood has taught the roadside romeos that when a girl says no she means no. That yoou shouldnt chase a girl around and impede her path for loouuu. Please keep this in mind the next time you get harassed by a roadside lout, which I hope for your own sake doesnt happen

      Like

  159. You should have mentioned you have inappropriate language in your blog. Which is the entire point of the AIB roast matter. They should be allowed to do what they want, but also they hold massive responsibility over this. What they say/do affects millions of people. Just because you have freedom does not mean you abuse it.

    Have some sense of maturity before blogging about things you have no experience in. You have done exactly what you have written about. Talking about things with no credibility. Atleast Aamir Khan has credibility to back himself.

    Hope you have a sensible and mature response rather than a “Oh I AM THE SHIT, COZ THIS IS MY BLOG” one.

    Like

  160. Kudos Man !! It was about time somebody spoke abt Aamir baba! …All this guy has been doing for years is perfecting the art of deception ……His personal life may as well be shitty as hell ..Aamir is a messiah of India … !

    Like

  161. Fucking Nail in the coffin!
    Nobody has their nose up in other’s business, but what Mr. Perfectionist does is beyond any sane man’s intellect.
    Well maybe its because he has created a world of chutiyapa and somehow has managed to fill it with idiots from all around to believe him as well

    Like

  162. Bull Shit….Stop commenting and exponding on thing which profit to none…talking about one’s wrong side or bad side is a person’s weakness and reflects Jealous Nature..
    Today if ur writing about AK that means he is successful…and truly he is Mr.Prefect…U might know the saying…”As the king walks dog will brake” (in Hindi Perhaps) so in short stop behaving like a dog…
    Its always better to talk about good side of a person…their are many criminals…and cruel people…if u really r troubled and what to help India …and its people…
    Catch and stop those criminals…and stop poverty…
    Spend time in positives and not on Negatives …
    thanks ….Common Person…

    Like

  163. What annoys me more is people had to wait until Aamir Khan commented on AIB’s roast to realize this. We need to stop stereotyping actors based on the movies they do. Just because that Sanaskari guy (idek his name) does charitra-sheel roles doesn’t mean he as an individual isn’t into bdsm. So honestly don’t even insinuate that, like think! read a book or something.

    Also ily man!! thanks

    Like

  164. Double standards of Mr Perfectionist, Delhi Belly was a script from a holy book, but AIB Is not good to watch. At least Salaman has an image of a big hearted man as well as bad boy of bollywood, he stick to it, u ask him a non sense question and he’ll bang you…so, be real in whatever you say/do/feel.
    Rest kuddos to all his social work, full credit to him..might be getting paid for it, but not everyone has guts and willingness to do it…

    Like

  165. ok !! first thing m gonna do is ‘Share it’… wait…ya done! so you have said things so crystal clear m sure even if ‘Azad’ reads it in a few years he will convey it to him… awesome… keep it up !!

    Like

  166. I just want to say 3 things
    a) I have seen no fucking theater artist to undergo such a major physical transformation as he had done. So please give a minute fucking thought before pooping shit in the article.
    b) Chetan Bhagat has signed a damn contract in which he was okay with not mentioning his fucking name in the opening credits. Here is the proof http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/3-Idiots-may-sue-Chetan-Bhagat/articleshow/5407592.cms
    c) You are a stinking asshole dude

    Like

    1. A) Nice to see you went so close to his arsehole to smell it.
      B) You mean no Bollywood artist has gone under such drastic changes. Its a part of what is called……….wait for it………..acting. Stop pushing forward the view that sardars have no brains.

      Like

  167. Well, I don’t understand one thing. If you as an individual have right n can express your views, y can’t aamir? Luk at the things, he spoke only when it came to films to defend coz he was a part of those flicks. When he speaks something not related to his own movies, it’s his freedom of expression as an individual. Why do v always want to relate his professional n personal thinking?

    I don’t have anything against anyone unless someone is causing gud to another, or even thinking gud for someone for tht matter. V can criticise or can start to act.

    Again, I’m not here to offend or support any one individual. Just a heads up.

    Like

    1. If the question is for me, I don’t have any problem if anyone makes fun of me. There’s a thin line between being funny n insulting. One has to know other individual to have tht FUN factor. I am fine unless someone cross the line.

      Like

  168. “…doesn’t mean the rest of the nation is a bunch of chimpanzees” – but we are, aren’t we? Despite knowing all of the above, we shower adulation on cricketers, actors and turn a blind eye to politicians who are bleeding us dry. Maybe yea you are right, we aren’t a nation of chimpanzees (they are smarter than us) we are perhaps a herd of cows 😀

    Like

  169. Well said. 🙂
    I admire Aamir for having taken on Satyameva Jayate and doing a good job. But I do have this one issue – he somehow creates this larger than life image of himself in every movie – whether it was Lagaan, Taare Zameen Par or his latest PK. Somehow, he is the only guy with any sense.

    There is no harm in taking credit where it is due but to take more than you deserve makes you a narcissist. Taare Zameen Par in particular should have belonged to Amole Gupte, but it became all about the star rather than the guy who conceived and wrote on the subject in such a beautiful and sensitive manner. Please don’t hijack somebody’s hard work in this manner.

    Hey Aamir, if you’re listening – you still are my favorite among the Khans, but it would help if you could give others the credit they deserve. It would make you a better person.

    Like

    1. why you are offended by aamir’s comments….. its right of freedom to speak…. As all AIB supporters are saying that its their right to speak… then why not aamir…. why should he change his thinking or point of view for some misguided ppl like u … :p

      Like

          1. As I said, it would have made sense for you to read MY comment. Since I am quite agnostic to the AIB theme, I don’t wish to take this conversation any further. I can see two camps here and it just doesn’t make sense to get caught in the cross hairs of two sniping parties, especially when I am concerned about something altogether different. So, adieu!

            Like

  170. Dear Mr HeartRanjan,

    I do not agree with you…
    as youth of nation …..I can say what AIB did is all Bullshit… and Mr ranjan … you are not the leader of youth…..dont just pull all youth and saying that today’s generation is like this… the its totally wrong!…. only few misguided people like you ,who are use to of this kind of abusive language in their lifestyle are supporting this nonsense… who do not use this foul language will never support u or this AIB .I am completely stand by what Mr amir said…
    why r u questioning over aamir only to give accept all this… why not questioned to those who are supporting this…. there is not right or wrong only a point of view …. atleast someone has guts to speak honestly infront of media … if u say AIB has right of freedom to speak… them everyone has the same… then why AIB supporters are feeling so ill …. and one more thing AIB supporters says that ppl who do not like AIB are hypocrite … that means if one can not be shameless like you guyz then then he or she is hyporate.. where the word shamefull !!!…. i think its not existed in ur dictionary…. lolz.. that means being hypocrate is much much better that being shameless :p

    Like

    1. I have been following this blog for the whole day, as i see, all that you are able to see in the blog is Aamir Khan (AK) vs. AIB.
      Lagaan, PK, Taare Zameen Par, Oscars, Satyamev Jayate are all invisble to you.

      The blog and a lot of comments have a lot of other points too, like the post from Vibha.

      Like AIB, AK also has an interview on prime time national television where he gives a similar statutory warning. I’m no fanboy of AK, nor the author, but it is the senseless dragging in of the AK vs. AIB issue which is troubling me.
      An abuse is an abuse is an abuse. Who ever delivers it. AK or AIB. Agree?

      For a movie which was released in 2011, the language was “violent”, in my opinion, as AK would have put it. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O5Uvprq85Lo
      When his movie with vulgar language cannot be wrong, how can another video be?
      This is the major point i have to point AK towards being a “hypocrite”.
      Tell me if I am wrong in saying that.

      Commenting on a post is really easy, but doing it right also matters.

      P.S.:
      1. There are numerous grammatical and spelling mistakes in your post/replies. It would be a lot better if you would try and work on that.
      2. Meaning of hypocrisy can be found here: http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/hypocrisy (in case you do not know)

      Like

  171. I would totally agree with the blog. I wouldn’t compare Aamir with the theatre actors. They are far beyond perfect than Aamir. They don’t get paid crores to have so much transformation.

    We are living in a world of controversies which is a core thing for a person to become famous in no time. Having said that “Freedom of speech”, doesn’t mean that you speak shitty things.

    Like

    1. ha ha…. sir aamir na kahta to koi aur kah deta….salman ne phone pe bol diya…. sharukh ne personally bol diya…. aamir ne media ke saamne … aur main yaha ….apne kaam se kaam rakho na…. why u AIB supporters are getting offended by aamir point of view … galat ko galat kaho to yahi haal hota hai …. hillarious :p

      Like

  172. Great stuff Mr. Ranjan. To answer some of the criticism coming your way: 1. Aamir Khan is a celebrity, so his opinion matters. He will find resonance with lot of followers, so taking a position (however pretentious it is) will have a bearing on the minds of people who follow him. So it is just not an opinion (free speech shit!), it is a celebrity opinion which can lead people astray and shape the opinions of those who like him. 2. Be it the AIB roast or any other “so called offensive” content on the web, those over protective kparents who are wary of their kids reading adult/offensive content on the web, please understand that there are more offensive stuff (porn for example) available freely on the net. So there is no way you can stop your kids from accessing shit on the net. Then why only cite AIB roast or this blog (cuss words) as examples of bad content on the net? Inculcating good values in your kids and the hoping against hope, that these will work while they make a choice is a far better option! Isn’t it 3. Be it Aamir Khan or Deepika Padukone, these filthy faggots do all these only to attract more eyeballs. They are dog in the monger policies! Take for exapmple, the Deepika – TOI feud. A girl who gyrates to lyrics like “uche se uche baanda, poty pe bethe nanga” (Dum Maro Dum), is she not perpetuating violence, adultery or call whatever it is? Yes, the on screen and off screen life are different. But for someone like Deepika who is being complicit in this act promote skin show to titillate men who salivate and buy tickets for her movies, has no right to protest against a cleavage show. The moot point is stop hero worshipping the bollywood celebrities. There are other noble examples to idolise : Saina Nehwal or Mary Kom will always be a better option.

    Like

    1. Hi Rohan. To be frank, I found your opinion quite fair. I’m against hero worshipping as well and believe that there are individuals who deserve more attention and adulation than screen actors who earn crores for just portraying a role and reading lines given to them.

      That being said, I don’t see why Aamir is a celebrity and his opinions matter and Karan Johar’s dont. If you say that Aamir’s opinion will transcend to loads of youngsters watching his interview, then don’t you think the same audience might find cussing cool because Karan Johar did so? And to be fair on Aamir, he says that Karan showed him some pictures of the show which went viral and that wasn’t to “his” taste. Therefore he didn’t watch it. Also, he adds that crucifying AIB is incorrect as there is freedom of speech in our country. If there’s a FIR launched against them, then the law will take its course. If they are found guilty, they are guilty. If not, they walk free. I don’t see how does Aamir turn out to be the hypocrite.

      There are loads of ppl here who feel Aamir is a hypocrite because his movie Delhi Belly had profanity and he’s speaking against it here. The point to understand here is that, Delhi Belly had cuss words therefore they went ahead and got an ‘A’ certificate for the movie. When the DVD gets released, it can reach kids as well. But an ‘A’ certificate is the best the producers can do. Likewise, Aamir found insulting other renowned public figures not to his taste and that the stars (Karan, Ranveer, Arjun) could have been more responsible. A simple way to do this could have been to have an age bar on YouTube. This is the best the show could’ve done. Beyond this, it’s left to the parents to take of wat their kids watch and wat not.

      We live in a free country and everyone has there own opinion towards issues. Just let everyone be. We will be happier if we don’t keep waiting to pounce on someone just because they spoke their mind. End of the day, it’s their opinion.

      Like

    2. ha ha…. so do u think only aamir is a celebrity!….what abt arjun, aalia,karan,,,, etc…. are them not celebrity?…. why should only aamir have sence of speaking … why not all these AIB celebrity….. who deleiver rubbish in social media…why u AIB supporters are getting offended by a person’s point of view……matlab jab AIB walo pe baat aayi to unke liye freedom of speaking abusive and flithy language ….aur aamir ko sence of responsibility samjha rahe ho…..aamir is not 100 % but 1000000000 % correct…..aur youth ko badnaam mat karo plz……sare youth ki mentality aapke jaisi nahi hai…….x-(

      Like

      1. Yes Anjali, because Aarjun, Ranveer & Karan Johar or Alia are unapologetic about their views on issues. They are not preaching contradictory views in some other platforms. you can’t run with the hare and hunt with the hounds, you know. BTW, I didn’t like AIB shit either! I am all for free speech. And Yes I agree, Mr. Ranjan should not have used derogatory language (cuss words) in this blog. But the fact remains that Aamir is a pretentious prick!

        Like

    3. I think you’re full of shit.

      To say Deepika Padukone promotes adultery and violence by dancing to a song is idiotic. So if she wore a saree and did pooja, she would promote religious beliefs? Like, little girls would begin waking up in the morning and doing pooja? Come on, man.

      I think we as a nation vastly overestimate the impact of cinema on our psyche.

      Like

      1. Whoa! Mr. Ranjan. I thot I was on your side. Anyways, Deepika example was in no way insinuating anything against women or what they are supposed to wear or how they are supposed to behave. Women can be more seductive in Sarees than hot pants. You probably didn’t get my point or I failed to articulate it to your liking. I do not have any complaints when nandita das lip locks shabana azmi in fire. I loved the aesthetics of two women making passionate love to each other in ‘Blue is the warmest colour’. But I have serious issues with item numbers which are forcefully incorporated (sometimes shot later after the film is complete) in films only to attract men (dignified and lower stall perverts alike). Look at the intent behind these. Unfortunately, film as a representational medium creates its own language through visual metaphors. So yes, women wearing a saree and doing pooja projects a certain image. And we Indians are mad over movies. Deepika – TOI feud was entirely based on ‘Objectification of women’. But the same is perpetuated when she participates in an abominable item number like the one in Dum Maaro Dum. Is this not promoting ‘objectification of women’ which she was fighting against. You know sometimes perpretrators become victims. As a country, we need to develop more tolerance for everything which is ‘the other’. Till then, let us hail the fine follies and critique the inferior virtues of the human condition!

        Like

        1. BTW, why do you have to start your reply with ‘you are full of shit! Is it more like a reflex instinct with you? You are a great writer. I liked what I read. You don’t have to be so rude. Are you an unpaid genius at work? Has someone achieved fame stealing your work / idea? Are you lovelorned? What is it? Don’t make yourself obnoxious that though people like your writing, they would think twice before coming to your blog. Just my thoughts. You can fuck that. I can already see your middle finger raised towards me. Or is it just in my mind?

          Like

    1. he said he didnt watch comepletely…. why all AIB supporters got offended b y aamir’s point of view only…. he also has right to speak like so called AIB celebrity …aamir doesn’t need ur certificate of correction ..he is far beyond u guys :p

      Like

  173. I disagree with what you say. Why are you throwing so much anger on Aamir? He has the right to voice his opinion as much as you do. I am not against AIB, I however feel that you are targeting him because you wanted to tarnish his image and rip him off his status as an intelligent man. He is 100 times better than the guys who decide on your roti to petrol prices!

    Like

  174. Haha! Well said. I used to like Aamir Khan for his acting, never mind the mindless Love Love Love and Andaz Apna Apna type BS. But “an aging douchebag” is what he’s become now and a very sanctimonious, annoying kind.

    Like

  175. Hello Ranjan,
    I am a die heart fan of Amir Khan while i liked your touch points at 1> Just because ours is a hare-brained industry, doesn’t make someone a goddamn Socrates.
    2> The brahmaguru of wisdom.
    3> Who held the elephant’s ass and thought that’s what an elephant looks like. (Remind my Grandfather Story when i was child.)
    4> Russel Peters said, you are an actor…
    & Finally i remembered a show by Rajat Sharma “Janta Ki Adalat” where Amir Said That he want’s to play a Role of Sri Krishna in Mahabharat once in life but he have n’t enough time for the same. God Are You Exist !!!

    Like

  176. Such a shame Heartranjan! Such a shame! Never expected you to stoop down to this level.

    Was Aamir Khan hypocritical? Yes. But only to a certain extent. He says, “Cuss words don’t make me laugh” Agreed. This is really hypocritical of him thanks to Delhi Belly. His focus was on “Insult Comedy” and like he said, he isn’t familiar to the roast format so the insult humor didn’t go down well with him. Openly making racist and sexist comments are really offensive and intolerable for people who don’t know what a roast is. So if anybody asks him, HE HAS EVERY GODDAMN RIGHT TO SPEAK HIS MIND.

    There is a thing called “Freedom of Opinion” which people like you and Russell Peters have totally forgotten. Not only did Aamir say, ban the show. He said, “Be responsible.” You may or may not agree with him but you have no right to use cuss words against him.

    This post is complete drivel! I know you’re supporting Bhagat’s ludicrous claims only because you are a writer. Open your mind! Bhagat had signed a contract with Vinod Chopra and Google the video where Rajkumar Hirani speaks about the controversy. There was no clause in the contact which supported Bhagat, but the IIM-A genius was a sharp man. He created that controversy and rose to fame. Why in the world should a person like Hirani (2 time national award winner) plagiarise a cheap book? He officially bought it. Where I find them wrong is, they said only 5% of the book was used while I feel it was at leat 50 to 60% of the book. But that doesn’t give Bhagat any legal authority to sue them!

    About Aamir’s claim, you have manipulated facts, Mr.Heartranjan! Aamir said, “Bhagat himself told me, there was no need to read the book as the screenplay is quite different from my novel.”

    This is becoming a very long post so I will post it in 2 parts.

    Like

  177. Oh man you sound so annoyed by Amir. Think carefully you are doing the same thing….criticizing an honest attempt made by Amir. Atleast there is one actor who is doing films on national issues rather than shit like Masti

    Like

  178. & I thought I will get to read something sensible and something that will make sense. But what I get is another monkey trying to prove that how much he is in the favor of Freedom of Speech and ranting about things without proper insights

    Like

  179. @Heartranjan: I admire you for not denying that you are an Aamir Hater. But pardon me I wont give you an Oscar for calling Milk is white,when you say in ur defense that you Praised Satyamev Jaite and praising him as an actor , coz thats a fact. Now coming to your post, I dont have a wrath against you being so judgmental and that too wrong. I think its a basic Indian problem that we cant be happy and make everyone happy. We see Happy new Year , Humshakals and Chennai Express in the name of entertainment and everyone is like” Why the fuck they cant be realistic?” And when someone takes ur nerve on social issues, he is the “I know all”. Dafuq you want man??

    A person doing social movies and program mes doesnt mean “HE IS PREACHING”. He said he found it offensive and blah blah (which I dont agree with), but its his OPINION. He didnt say ban them , he said he opposes the ban. Why cant he voice his opinion on an issue even if his wrong?? I mean you are voicing yours here , and that too in an Extraordinarily fucking stupid way.

    Even if you want him Hollow and not incorporating his principles, it is not a law that he comment on the AIB roast.

    Now why I called you Immature?? Well, I blog myself , and I think you pretty well know that when a blog has a central Idea and a topic, there are arguments assertions and reasoning. There is very less room for redundant data. When I saw ur post, I thought it was about his Hypocritic opinion about the AIB thing. But when you are questioning his career that he has done REGRESSIVE SHIT for 20 years and He has no right to teach that all parents are idiots in TZP and alll, man you sound like a Fucktard, to be honest.
    The character he plays in TZP Preaches the right and wrong, not HIM. Like Heath Ledger as Joker was awesome, not the Heath Ledger the person. He was a Druggie.

    And you have a fucking problem with him doing the Tourism Industry ad for only you know reasons and then you claim he earns crores. So basically you dont want him to the Tourism ad and do some Shitty game show , so that later you can crucify himself , as a money whore. Wow man, your conscience is up your ass, I must say.

    Thats why your article is crap and I am disappointed. As I said and proved how alll this data and you Nullifying his carrer is irrelevant to the AIB post and even Aamir vocing his opinion is mutually exclusive of all his good work.

    So again man grow up or write in proper context. And in addition to ths small movies like Peepli and all I am Proud of the movies like RDB, TZP, Dil chahta hai and Lagaan (another insignificant input in this shitty post).

    Well haters hate and Potatoes Potate mate, but atleast bash him on something Bashable rather than writing a post out of compulsion or making a fool out of urself. Like the SRK fans do to console themselves as they know who is better.

    Like

    1. Absolutely correct! Well said Rohan Raman!! Respect! As for the writer, I think he is a sick misguided man! As per him,it’s only the AIB supporters who have the freedom of speech & no-one else. They call the ones hypocrites who don’t support AIB,but are the hypocrites themselves! It was Aamir’s personal opinion for heaven’s sake! If you didn’t like it then you didn’t! Don’t malign him just because you didn’t like his comment! Sick Fucktard! Go fuck yourself & btw yes,he is the perfectionist & at least 10000000000 times better than you.

      Like

  180. Very well said, this is what we called some sensible talk. Kudos !!! I used be an Aamir Khan’s fan but figured all this out some time back. He is in a fucking character every given moment when facing any camera, does not look real at all. Dude movies are enough for your acting, give us a break and try to showcase your personality some times at least. I am still his fan when it comes to his movies, but not in real life….

    Like

  181. Your article is bang on target except for a few things….

    1) The reason for ‘Lagaan’ not winning an Oscar is best known by the ‘juries’. Let’s not get into that! I do not think that the run time of the film marred its chances!

    2) I strongly disagree with your comment on ‘Taare Zameen Par’. The film perfectly portrays the society’s inability to understand a disorder and thinking of it as an excuse to get away from the things the affected person hates to do and also the aversion induced in the affected person towards those things and the society as a result. The ‘cruelty’ that you are talking about (it is definitely not ‘cruelty’ if not anything else) is an extremely natural response arising out of this misunderstanding!

    3) He is the brand ambassador of ‘Incredible India’ campaign and he is paid by the Government of India to say what he says on national television. I don’t see a problem in that!

    Other than these things I agree with everything that you have written! Cheers!

    Like

  182. this guy is Seriously a jhatu. Am not Sure about Aamir but Its very clear about your thoughts for sure. For ex. If someone is donating Blood, You instead of supporting or doing the same will find a way to criticize like this – “Ary who chutiya to din bhar muth marta rah ta hai. Aur blood Donate kerne chala”. Khud to kuch acha nahi ker sakta to dusron ke to rok mut. Wo apne personal life mai kya kerta hai wo mut dekh, What he does for others should be your only concern if any. If he is doing something good to improve this Nation then support him or keep quit. Blogging such thing may create nagetive feelings about him or people doing good for nation and people may stop following him and oppose him no matter what we all may benefit from his works towards our Nation.

    So Jhatu, Shut your bloody Ass off

    Like

  183. There’s a saying “people who don’t like you or criticize you is usually cause they can’t have you or be with you”
    AK is at least doing something and trying to make a difference and the few peoples lives that he has touched will be ever so grateful to God to have sent them a man in their need of hour.
    What do you do? Sit here and write a blog, gossip blog. Why don’t you pull up your pants and do something good instead? Make a difference, reach out to people and for God’s sake stop criticizing the people who do.
    Its okay that you don’t like AK or whoever else you do not like. But do you really have to write a whole blog about how much you hate them and what they do? Come on man, get a life.. .grow up! Sure you have better talents than that… if you are a writer, write about something positive, may be a cause, something that will make a difference in the world!

    Everyone is entitled to their opinions!!! If AK doesn’t like the roast, that’s his opinion…

    Like

  184. arrey you fucking bhenchod, what have you done for social causes around the world, just because you want take out your frustration for Amir Khan’s recent comment on AIB doesn’t mean that you have to question every life decision he has made to date, stick to the topic you are critiquing, don’t go around shitting your fucking biased opinions all over the internet and sensationalizing it with daring headings. Fucking attention whore.

    Like

  185. Now the second part of my comment:

    1. “If you really are an artist, at least have the fucking decency to look up their work before commenting”

    Decency? Oh, then what is this:

    “Chetan Bhagat is the Rakhi Sawant of Indian literature”
    “you come across as an aging douchebag.”

    Wow! Such ‘decent’ language! If a person says, he finds something offensive, intellectuals like you call him an agent douchebag! Hate Bhagat? Even I do. But I don’t go around repeatedly calling him Rakhi Sawant.

    2. You’re quickly turning into the next GreatBong. That genius who can’t help but publish his garbage rants on his popular blog. I loved his blog some years back, but these days his rants are simply unreadable. And you’re following his footsteps. Your rants are also becoming unreadable because you’re not even open to the other side of the argument.

    3. “Like I said, you’re not fooling anybody. This is a generation that sees through bullshit. And right now, for all your decades of carefully constructed PR,”

    Says who? Any proof? If this is the case, why Bhagat books top the chart ahead of Ghosh? why is Honey Singh the most popular musician at the moment? Who are you make such a lame, baseless statement as if you represent the entire youth!

    4. It’s such a shame that you hate Bhagat for gimmicky writing but you are doing the same thing. There are way too many important issues going on currently, but you want to focus of Aamir Khan. Irony isn’t it? And it has worked! More than 500 comments here, which don’t cross 60 in normal case. Most of your popular posts are gimmicky, be it SRK- Ra one, Uday Chopra and now this. It’s not that you don’t have anything else to write but you very well know that gimmick sells and you’re selling it.

    Such a long comment because I wont follow your blog from now on. You were one of the very few talented and honest writers here. Sadly you have also turned into a gimmick. God bless you!

    Like

    1. Beautifully said. And you are so right about Great Bong… He used to be good long back.

      I’ve never read this blogger before, never will again. This post is full of misinformation and plain malice. Sadly, it has become an Internet sensation. Shows the level of intellect and cussedness among our networked public. Aamir may be just a 12th pass but he is also an extremely well-read Indian who does work beyond the filmi sphere. And calling Aamir ( who will turn 50 on March 14) an ageing douchebag — that’s such a terribly mean thing to say against anybody. Aamir is in fact preparing to play a 55 year old character, a real person, a wrestler father to two daughters, the wrestling sisters, the Phogat siblings. Right move Aamir.

      His film and TV work has been getting simply better and better. Even his ads are memorable. Be it his endorsements or films or TV, he takes so much care over everything. But he has not endorsed anything for a couple of years, since SMJ started in 2012.

      And what’s the big deal with Aamir’s response to AIB’s pathetic show? Why is the filmi and social media in such a tizzy since past ten days over one reaction from a known name? Why doesn’t our media criticise others who expressed anger over the AIB Roast? Salman is said to have threatened Tanmay, SRK expressed unhappiness…but they did it away from media glare. Only Aamir gets this huge overreaction- backlash. Poor guy.

      And this networked generation is the sort that doesn’t look beyond headlines or watch a video beyond the first frame. Aamir made it clear that he he had watched just a couple of clips and been informed by Karan J and Arjun K about the show’s dodgy content. And that was enough for him; he did not feel like watching more.He spoke about his distress over the involvement of his film world friends in a show that had so much of negativity. He did not say a word against anybody, film person or AIB guys.

      What right does a Russel Peters have to trash Aamir the way he did…the way this blogger has done. And Pooja Brat, the girl who lip locked with her father, posed painted and nude– calling out Aamir, somebody far beyond her.

      Well, obviously this Heartranjan’s hatered and contempt towards Aamir runs deep. Hence, this poisonous piece that’s actually being shared and applauded on the net among like-minded Shallow Hals. Can be debated word for word, every bit of mindless criticism dismissed. But I am too weary to argue with arrogant opinionated uptown pseudo- liberals.

      Have a good life with your cynicism and sniggers.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I am sorry Madam but Heartranjan is not an Aamir hater. I have followed his blog for quite a long time. He is one of the most brave writers in India. Far far better than GB, GB was once a gem but these days he is extremely hateful and cynical. He has these bunch of die hard fans who start abusing commenters who write anything against him. That’s the reason why I never visit his blog.

        I have read all his posts on Aamir. Be it PK, dhoom 3 or Dhobi ghat review, Satyamev Jayate review. Almost everything. He was sincere enough to praise SMJ, Dhobi ghat and PK and he did thrash a bad film like Dhoom 3. He is way way more skeptical about the other Khans than Aamir.

        But, my point is, his criticism used to be extremely valid and to the point in all his posts. In this post, he is all over the place. Making comments without verifying facts. I’m not obsessed with deceny (I did like the roast in fact) but common man how can someone talk about decency in a post full of f-words? This post looked extremely gimmicky with an aim to provoke people. And I don’t expect terrifically talented people like Heartranjan to do such gimmicks. That thing really pissed me off.

        About your point, the fact is people have already given up on other khans. One is a criminal other is a money making machine. Both have no dignity for themselves. Dancing in weddings, drunk driving, cat-fights are the things these guys resort to, to keep themselves in news. This may be a blatant generalisation but most of us have huge respect for Aamir Khan. He has been a part of movies we are proud of. When he makes unpopular remarks people can’t digest it. And this man is known to make such remarks, like he was one of the very few guys to openly slammed SLB’s “Black” and he received a lot of flak for that.

        About Russell and Bhatts, I don’t care what they think. They were cashing on Aamir’s popularity. I would like to end the comment by saying, Heartranjan isn’t as hateful as you think. What i feel is, he tries to beat his point on your face with all the f-words and personal attacks. When you’re on his side, he is the most enjoyable person to read. When you aren’t you feel he is the most annoying blogger ever. I found this post quite one sided and may be the reason why it didn’t go down well with me. But yes, I’d repeat, he ain’t that cynical. He has terrific sense of humor. Sadly I didn’t find any this time round.

        Like

  186. Hey…

    This thread is going everywhere. I am no blogger nor a fan of AK. I am a typical Delhiwala not unfamiliar with whatever and whatever ways things were said in AIB. To be frank, most of the adjectives are used in it are part of my regular vocabulary…but hey hold on – I still have reservations to use them in front of people/women, get it shot & uploaded on the public forum…..Phewwww….this is inspite of being a supporter of Free Speech!!!

    I like moving around naked – but would not have balls to ‘perform’ publicly, shoot & upload it for the sake of FOS (Freedom of Speech)

    Like

  187. hahaha… Dude you sounded like a paid BJP Ass (like Rajat Sharma) to me when you said this:
    “Aap Ki Adalat (that classy, artful show with a completely non-creepy looking host)”… Get a better life Asshole…

    Like

  188. I pity the writer… scared and embarrassed to have such future journalist who goes with face value…u prove the famous indian saying ‘ jo dikhta hain, woh bikta hain;…. you WRONG NUMBER!

    Like

  189. Hahaha….

    What a piece of crap,This is violence,that too in black & white.(NO,Joking read rather read twice and liked as well.)
    Run to your guts out Amir fans looking for you everywhere you are in deep shit.
    I am sure there shall be some hue and cry around for few days,which tags along publicity and money complimentary.
    Did Rajat sharma molested you intellectually?why that poor chap is under your knife.After hair weaving and 24 facials a days he looks better than Justin Bieber anyway.
    The best part is about chetan bhagat-he got the undue publicity ab BHUGAT,IRONY,I guess that is.Just to mention here FunnyGyan-Abovefelt offended you called Chetan Rakhi sawant.Don’t worry he is Rakhi fan that made him angry.

    Congrats for the name,fame and moolah in advance.
    Cheers!!!!!!!

    Like

    1. What rubbish! I’m no way offended by him calling Bhagat as Rakhi. I have been reading him for over 3 years and he has said much worse things about Bhagat. I had said that in a totally different context.

      And I am no Aamir fan. But how dare you call me Rakhi fan? I won’t stoop down to your level or else I could have compared you with Shiney Ahula or Jackky Bhagnani!

      Like

  190. Some people write well. You like flow with it without getting wet. You like reading it without the need to understand it. You are one such wannabe writer.

    Like

  191. Oh by the way, ignore the wannabe intellectuals who are so “concerned” about the future of the nation, the quality of writing, blah blah blah . They just got butthurt is all 😀 😛 You were brilliant!

    Like

  192. While I did post 2 not-so-good comments about your post, I just want to clarify that my flak was against your uresearched claims not your criticism. It is sad that butt hurt fan boys are writing nasty things about you, you have every god damn right to criticize anybody. Sorry for you receiving all such idiotic personal attacks. You’re really a brave writer and I have no doubts about that!

    Like

    1. It’s cool, man. You don’t have to be so apologetic about the comment 😀

      I am not a very sensitive guy. *stares at spider on the wall for six seconds, then lunges at it and chews it up*

      Like

      1. The apology was written because I read your FB post. Seriously, fucktards threatening to burn you alive for one post? It’s sad that we are not allowed to speak anything against popular guys. I hate Aamir khan fans now! Thought they were at least better than the other 2 jokers, but no, they are all the same kind of jerks!

        I may hate this post but come on man, I can’t force you to remove it because it’s against my beliefs. That is exactly the freedom of speech. To say, “I hate this, but you have the right to express your views.”

        Rape and murder threats for one post is a sad sad thing. That’s the reason why I wrote this. To clarify that I don’t like your post, but keep writing brave posts like these and don’t get bogged down by fucktards hell bent on curbing our right to express ourselves?

        Like

  193. AIB didn’t make me laugh. Maybe I’m an insufferable bore but the fact that most people around me think otherwise, I’m inclined to agree with them. I also agree with all that freedom of speech rhetoric but please tell me one thing honestly…did you really laugh at those Jokes…Tanmay Bhat was probably funny at times, but that’s about it for me. I didn’t laugh from my gut even once!! That’s my whole problem with this brand of humor. Its not about freedom to do what you want to, or being socially irresponsible. Its not fucking funny! And don’t compare this to Russel Peters, because even when he picks on you, he’s never offensive and a ‘Taps n Bong’ is way funnier than any of those AIB dudes could manage…and yeah who’s that woman..mittal…really??

    Like

    1. It seems to me that in a list of complex concepts like the cure for cancer,The beginning of time,Black holes…etc. that all of us yet don’t get, sense of humor is the first in your list.

      Like

    1. Actually, no. I didn’t expect so many comments. See, I would never write something like this about Salman Khan or Shah Rukh Khan, because I know what their fans are like – maniacal, humourless.

      I thought with all the years of ‘sensitive’ cinema that Aamir Khan has done, his audience would be slightly less uptight about stuff.

      Boy, was I wrong!

      And yes, I AM preparing another rubbish blog. 😀

      Like

  194. I am sure there are several people who like this article…. all SRK fans for one, all doctors who were offended by his SMJ episode, all those who thought that the AIB roast was a piece of art. But I am not sure I understand the author’s problem. I don’t deny that Aamir has made mistakes. I don’t think Aamir denies it either. But if Aamir seems like the voice of the nation it is only because he is one of the few stars who understands the responsibility of being a star. The others seem to think that wearing shiny clothes, attending some events and dancing at weddings is their only job in life. If he seems like an intelligent actor, it is because he is, at least comparitively. If he seems like he cares about other human beings it is because he does. I can understand why all this may seem pretentious. After all who is the person who decides he has a social responsibility to perform when nobody else is worried about theirs. Oh and why does he have to read scripts and get into character when nobody else does. So annoying it must be!

    Like

    1. Wow. Really? Shah Rukh Khan fan, now?

      The entire universe doesn’t exist in binaries of Aamir Khan – Shah Rukh Khan, you know. Also, the world isn’t black and white. One could write something about one person, and dislike another aspect of the same person.

      I have enjoyed his films, even reviewed them positively (would have put a link here, but I’m a lazy sort of person). I don’t know why I have to keep justifying that I like his films, and Satyamev Jayate as well.

      My point is, no matter how great a person is, it is OK to laugh once in a while. You know another person who had achieved a lot, but didn’t like people questioning him? Adolf Goddamn Hitler!

      Point is, he’s done great films, has probably the most solid body of work among the actors of his generation, and has the balls to talk about issues in a country where nobody gives a fuck.

      Now, wouldn’t it be wonderful if the man (and his fans) eased a little, laughed at a blog post, and moved on in life? It’s a blog, for heaven’s sake. Nobody will give a shit about it tomorrow.

      What’s the fuss?

      Like

      1. Heartranjan you have to decide if the blog is funny or if you have criticized AK. I don’t see it to be a funny blog, I see you as a critic in here. So please don’t hide under the pretence of being funny. Admit it that you wanted to point out the negatives in AK, I hate people who when cornered go “I was just joking”

        Like

      2. You seem to think that if we criticize something, we must not want to be questioned. Actually this whole article seems to be based on this kind of warped logic. By your logic, you replying to my post means you don’t have a sense of humour either. Nobody is arguing that you have an absolute right to say what you are saying. But if we think your blog isn’t funny or if we think that there are only a certain group of people who will find it funny, doesn’t mean we are intolerant, don’t have a sense of humour or are a blind followers of Aamir Khan. In fact I have criticized Aamir before and you have probably praised him before (although to be perceived as an impartial film critic you would have to give good reviews to at least some of his films, considering the competition). In any case, I think that we both find things to admire and criticize in him. It’s just that this article of yours seems to be annoyed about the fact that he acts like he is better than others while simultaneously acknowledging that he is!?!?!?!

        Like

  195. you know you are reading an article of a newbie, insensitive , and under potent writer who jumps around his freedom of expression… Try to put some logic into what you say, make up your mind kid… every body know you are a shittty writer when you use slangs like Blah.. blah blah in your article.and the people liking this article are i guess got a pea sized brain, or just simple grudges against the actor.. seriously guys grow up..

    Like

    1. And everyone knows you’re a shitty writer when you don’t use punctuations and use too many full stops to end your sentences. Since I like the article, I guess I have a pea sized brain, but I believe your parents were slapped when you were born. Ill stick with the pea sized brain.

      Like

    1. Ok. 1. You shouldn’t be looking into your maid’s clothes. When she has one or not, should be none of your concern. And pursuing the topic is tantamount to sexual offence. Just saying. That Shiney Ahuja fellow went to jail.

      2. When you say ‘wannabe faggot insensitive blogger’, do you mean I am a wannabe AND a faggot, or a guy who wants to be a faggot?

      3. How does one decide if someone is worth sucking someone’s dick? Do the people involved decide, or does another person have to do it?

      You are like Swami Vivekananda. You make one small statement, but it raises so many burning questions.

      Like

  196. This blog seems to b targetting the AIB issue. I think we need to get into much broader perspective about this whole issue.  And that perspective is our culture..  To be more specific.. Human culture (not Indian or any other).. Long back it used to be right and wrong..  In Indian culture point of view.. Dharma (righteousness)   and adharma (wrong doing or unrighteousness)  but now it seems the definitions hav changed.  Ther is nothing called as right. Ther is only wrong and a greater wrong.  Eg.  If i steal 1000 rs and get caught i can openly say k der are 1000 crore scams going in country.. Why shud i get punishment.. So we need to see wher is human culture going.  It seems its degrading. Human instincts are on d verge of extinction.  And animal instincts r emerging.  To give one more exmpl..  If u get caught kissing ur gf in a public place u wil straight away argue saying tht india mai road pe thunkna aur mutna allowed hai but pyaar karna gunaah hai..  Someone like AIB developer might come up and say k bhai tu kissing kya.. Sab kar.. Bed laga de road pe.  Mai tiket rakhta hu tera live show dekhne k liye aur jo paisa aayega uska charity karenge….
    So this is what current scenario has bcm.  Pepl can do wrong things for good cause and walk away easily saying that ther is greater wrong happening in this country, So dont put focus on me.. Blah blah blah.
    So d question is do we need some introspection???
    And talkin sprcifically abt AK. Well evry 1 aims for perfection.. Yet nobody is perfect. He uses his stardom effectively to create social awareness on certain issues. But humans are prone to make mistakes and hence they are called humans and not Gods.

    Like

  197. @heartranjan

    Can you read Aamir’s exact response about this AIB (All India Bunchofretards) and tell me where exactly he went wrong.

    Now just imagine….you have gone to your daily park on a Sunday evening along with your family (comprising respectable ladies and kids) to de-stress…….I come there along with my friend and occupy a bench next to you…..We don’t even realize your presence and begin conversing among ourselves.

    Me: abey behenchod…….kal kahan tha…lauda chuswa raha tha kya teri behen se
    friend: nahi bhosdike chodne me lagaa hua tha….chut phaad raha tha chinaal gf ka

    And we continue with even more colorful language describing female body parts.
    And I can imagine you smiling in the evening at the freedom of speech displayed by us and actually would have forced your family (who would be disgusted at us by now) to see how we are progressing as a nation by exercising such wonderful freedom of speech.

    Like

    1. Well, on a serious note I think you’re absolutely right about this. Frankly, AIB’s event should have been a private one. The sensibilities of the already troubled people of our country are not fit to be tested by such colourful freedom of speech. I personally laughed along too when watching the event but I’m pretty sure the number of sensible yet chilled out people are far less than those for whom things can go wayside easily.

      Like

      1. The fact that they put this private affair on a public domain is proof of the fact that these All India Bunchofretards were hungry for publicity…and they surely got more than their 2 paise worth.
        And when retards like this moronic writer support AIB by attacking a celebrity (who incidentally has a huge online following resulting in more page hits/visits) like this it’s not difficult to guess that he’s looking for his 2 paise worth of limelight

        Like

      1. @rashid Bro, with all due respect to your intellectuality, woh jo park mein log aaye the who started using foul language, unko chup nahi kara sakte. the only option left is to take my family and sit somewhere else. Agreed. Lekin bhai youtube pe control h na? just imagine ki woh jo log aaye the woh youtube h. I shut this you tube down and keep sitting with my family happily ever after.

        AIB ne ek sirf show banaya, jo unhone public platform pe dala so that people who are like minded as them can watch it, have fun and keep it at rest. They didnt telecast it on tv.

        I dont know you and I am sure you are a good intellectual man. Isisliye bol raha hoon, baat freedom of speech ki nahi h. It is to be secure about ourselves. We get offended because we are scared. We need not be. They are just jokes, no body gets mislead by that.
        Aur khud hi soch, aisa toh hai nahi ki yeh show banne se pehle india mein log maa bhen nahi karte the.
        Toh ismein Show ki kya galti.

        Like

        1. Going by that logic, even AK was voicing his opinion underbhis freedom of speech. I wonder what the writer, Peter Brussels etc got so worked about that they had to dish out foul mouthed obscenities

          Like

  198. AIB was hilarious.Some jokes people found scandalous (hypocrites), wonder if they would have laughed their asses out had they got as a message in private. The event is getting more reel time than actual issues plaguing this country. What SHAME!
    Dude! Thanks for writing such an hilarious post.Makes sense. It’s good to see a pig headed person brought down to ground.They are actors, just that. Sharing this too!

    Like

  199. so Mr. writer i guess you have the exclusive right of expressing your opinion in this country.
    aamir has been faking the social awareness he has…then lets start by looking at yours first ..shall we?

    Like

  200. Awesome post man, I just loved it. Mind you, I have nothing against Amir Khan and I am sure neither do you its just the way you have written stuff is amazing. I haven’t enjoyed anything like this blog in a long time.
    After I read it I made a lot of my friends read it aloud and enjoyed it, just the same every time. Some of the lines you used such as ‘the jury grew old and died during the interval’ will stay with me forever.
    Keep Posting…

    Like

  201. It’s funny how you pick him right after he bashes the indecent public perpetrators, and you find nothing good in that. I actually watched that show unlike Amir who saved himself the agony of going through it, I love cursing once in a while to vent my frustration like others, but even for me that show was stupid. I chuckled only when somebody used the word “chutiya”, don’t really no why..maybe because you have to be a “chutiya” to attend such shows being a person of high profile. And please don’t talk about “pretension”, look around you if there’s even a single person who doesn’t pretend to be likable! Even these idiots who’re posting here, of course unlike me :), are pretending to agree with you when they all follow the same idea and strive to be different but can’t break out of the realm so feel terrible of their live and criticize others like you my friend.

    But any way…Nice blog behenchod!! 🙂

    didn’t want to offend you but I feel that’s appropriate in your eyes 🙂
    (see it makes sense if you do certain things behind the doors, like shitting, licking a plate or cursing someone, when it’s out in public you don’t walk around with your pants down and mouth full of shit) Hopefully ya’ll got the point. now find someone new to sit and criticize lol

    Like

  202. social media is new form of public lynching… i’m no big fan of aamir, but admire him for expressing his opinion in open even though that might be against social media pundits… (this article targets him for to his comments on AIB’s show, and author, like many other may be aib sympathizer). But Aamir didn’t resort to name calling, derogatory language… as these author(s) do – esp emboldened by relative anonymity and no-real time counter-arguments that come with writing well planned slander campaigns in name of articles (can say that, as i myself am guilty of being a armchair activist … though never needed name calling)

    Like

    1. Wow. You said exactly what needs to be said.Social media IS a form of public lynching, deserved or not. And this time, with Aamir it’s highly undeserved. The man was asked about this AIB issue during the course of an evening spent discussing more important things– and six irrelevant minutes of the video went viral , got highlighted. Aamir has ultimately been slammed unfairly, malicious liars are writing open letters and blogs like this one… What an over reaction, but obviously motivated by sections out to bring down Aamir if they can. This particular blog — every line can be contested, and in fact has been, by a balanced WordPress piece that plainly calls itself a response to this spiteful totally untruthful piece of BS.

      Like

      1. So you’re insinuating that I have a personal grudge against Aamir Khan and want to bring him down, and hence wrote this.

        Hmmm…seems plausible. See, this is how it works. The blog gets shared a lot, and Aamir Khan’s bankers see it. They take away all his property, and producers stop signing films with him. Slowly, his glamour fades away, and he ends up becoming a poor, sad man. That was the plan with the blog.

        Grow the fuck up! This is a satire blog, and things are sometimes written for humour reasons. I understand you didn’t find it funny, but trying to look into the crystal ball and finding conspiracy theories, is taking it a bit too far.

        Like

    1. Hey, actually I got myself a pack of Extra Large Wings, and I feel fine now.

      You must be quite the man, making cunt references and all. Is that how you feel? That someone who is annoying/bitchy/disagreeing with you is a bleeding vagina?

      You know you came out of one too, right?

      Like

  203. Before I get berated by the blogger for commenting on something I’m ignorant of, let me admit outright that my knowledge of indian theatre or rather Bollywood to be exact is limited. So I have no basis for either confirming nor disproving the blogger’s opinion of Amir Khan. However, the blogger’s witty annihilation of Amir Khan’s grandiosity, needed to be acknowledged, so I thought that I’d just stop by to comment him/her on a very well written piece of critic. My only criticism would be the the “great divide” the blogger seems to be creating between the different generations. Great art; outstanding acting performances surpasses age and remains timeless…

    Like

    1. Thanks.

      While talking of generation gap, I didn’t mean in terms of appreciation of art or aesthetics. I meant a generation more steeped in information, exposure, one that is media savvy.

      Like

  204. A good one once again! 🙂 . Also, I am seeing it shared on Facebook a lot. Good for you! I have enjoyed reading your blog the past one year, and I am glad more people are discovering it.

    Like

  205. The only sensible response I found was by “indiandlite”. I completely agree with him. Also to make your point strong one does not need to use foul and harsh expressions on any one no matter how low that person is. By doing so, you fall behind them.

    Like

  206. The writer should first start with good language .. the f*** word used so frequently really throws the writer in poor light … as for the article .. well, look at it this way.. if AK is asked an opinion by public then clearly he is regarded worth his thoughts. As for the movie’s , I think he is brilliant when he brings out issues . Its not just for those ,so called “educated” but for the masses .. or have we forgotten that we are part of a huge nation ?
    Where is the UNLIKE button when we need one ??? This blog is pathetic !!!

    Like

  207. I read through the article and well certainly pity your nonsensical thoughts. It is evident from your choice of words that you have not done your basic study right and have simply written something that is more based on what you would have heard. The flow as well as choice of words clearly showcase that these are not original 🙂

    If you wanna write, do some research and then base your opinion. It is like collating the numbers and then doing the number crunching to analyze the facts…All missing in your work…

    Like

  208. The article is perfect. This has been my thoughts since 3 idiots and have been piled up more since then but then again may be i thought i was lazy to write this, he is such a pseudo intellect. He lives his life proving holier than thou…and to me he is not the best actor even, u see a guy like Pankaj Kapoor who transforms his looks mannerism and dialect in a much better was, and not even want any publicity for that. He thinks he is DDL or De niro, and truth be told aint a patch on either. To me he is not just the most overrated actor but also the most overrated human being, if Satyamev Jayate was for such a good cause why charge so much money per episode….

    Like

  209. This is BRILLIANT!! I have always found Aamir Khan revolting (though not when he was a little dancing juhi chawla-romancing shrimp with a mullet) and this piece articulates why perfectly. Stupid Aamir Khan.

    Like

  210. Pingback: Quora
  211. who the fuck r u raising questions whether aamir fakes or he is actually serious about issues. Atleast he is not shitting around on blogs lyk u. He saw some clips(checkout what he said) and then commented that he didnt lyk it so didnt watch the complete show. And u think u vil get publicity by writing this crap then u shud b happy. bt one thing u shudnt forget is that u r not even close to his jhaants. Jus stop writting ur crappy blogs and get a lyf

    Like

    1. Please don’t insult our great country by being abusive and using “textspeak”. Let us now go on a journey to discover if you have a brain, and if yes, then what is it actually used for.

      Like

      1. someone gets offended very badly..who?? AIB Roast Blind Followers 😦
        Tell me one thing Heartranjans Do u really think it was funny?? I m not fan of any khan or others.
        You cannot show your private parts in public thats why its called private and rules apllies on abusive language regarding “private parts” too.

        Like

    1. Can’t you see “For more hearty laughs and information about the writer, check out Heartranjan’s Blog.” at the end of ScoopWhoop’s post ??

      Like

  212. so many hate messages this writer.. he has created this whole commotion among readers and ofcourse AK woud nt mind this one.. after all we are all reading this one coz we all like his movies, including this writer.. hahaha

    Like

  213. Dear heartranjan,
    If it was all about freedom of expression, where is the notion of responsibility? I am not an Aamir-fan, COZ I am a Bachchanian!, but I admire the guy for his talent and efforts. But the issue is NOT whether he’s right or wrong, but it is about someTHING like you trying to get into the limelight by writing dozens of F-words in a two-page blog. If that is your idea of right to expression, mind that there are people who are far more talented than you in that, and can make you wish that you never had a mother. From experience, its not the F-words, but that how you can combine them, has the deadliest affect. I can give you an example right now, but that is precisely against the point here. Have you ever had any responsibility in your life? Oh, sorry, you are an anonymous blogger!. At least have the guts to come-out and speak. Just demanding the freedom of expression, guys like you, and those in AIB, aspire to pull-out an M F Hussain. And no responsibility? Something blindly copied from some age-old American TV show is CREATIVE? These AIB and all can’t make anyone laugh without cursing. Then where is the creativity? From Jonny Walker to Kapil Sharma, we always had talented comedians who ruled the podium without having to abuse. And even if someone wants to bring abusive ‘comedy’ into Indian households, doesn’t it matter to gauge about whether the mass is ready for this or not? Are they really doing it to revolutionalize their audience or because they can’t do anything else. The freedom of doing anything is NOT what a free country means! If you still are un-initiated, go and read Dr. Ambedkar’s writings, if you are educated, and more crucially, mentally capable enough. If cursing is okay, slapping will be soon, followed by punching ones teeth out. One just needs to take it sportingly, in the name of freedom! Just because of primates like you, democracy seems a failed concept. & YES, SOCRATES did say that.
    I can go on and on, I don’t need to use any curs-word to rip your ego off. That doesn’t matter as you will always hide behind some illogical argument or plain silence, the later making you feel strong as some kid with his magic blanky. But the real point here, if you are having problem in following, is: WHAT ABOUT RESPONSIBILITY???????? It seems no one cares, as if defamation is superficial altogether! May be for those like you without self-respect! & humor is NOT an absolute pious object. Its a casual thing, no one should TRY to make it serious, by putting in verbal abuses & stuff. Some places in the world, intellectually deprived like US and all, without no sense of honor, may resort to it. That doesn’t mean we have to. We still have enough brains to create brainy jokes and to understand them. If still guys are hell-bent on cursing and expect others to take that lightly, some strictness is needed. Moral of the story: COMEDY and CURSING are two different things!!! Its a pity that some people are still having to teach that to the masses. If you can write this blog, please try to get through a Merriam-Webster; you may get to LEARN something.

    Like

    1. Boy you are a complete jackass, Kumar Abhinav. Did you even read the post ? The issue is hypocrisy – don’t complain about bad abusive language that others use if you yourself use the same language ! I think you should re-read the blog and then maybe consult Merriam-Webster – very carefully this time

      Like

  214. dude atleast someone is out there trying! in whatever ways but for good! with all the opinion you have why dont you correct the faulty and do something better than just posting a blog.
    STOP JUDGING! START DOING!

    Like

  215. someone gets offended very badly..who?? AIB Roast Blind Followers 😦
    Tell me one thing Heartranjans Do u really think it was funny?? I m not fan of any khan or others.
    You cannot show your private parts in public thats why its called private and rules apllies on abusive language regarding “private parts” too.

    Like

  216. First, let me ask you something…. What the hell is actually wrong with you? You look like a fucking obsessed hater right now you know? Always looking at the negative sides of what Aamir do. Like, what the hell man? You shout your shit all bout freedom of speech and all your shit but you go here, blog, and criticize someone you do not know personally? You go and blog here about his movies, how he show people the mistake in your education,religion and such. Don’t you see? He’s raising India. But of course, you don’t. Cause just like a blogger here said “You live in your own fucking annoying universe.” So, Im gonna ask you one thing– Buzz off Aamir Khan, shut up, and you go and play with your toys there in your universe. Stop criticizing/judging people whom you don’t know. Not knowing his reasons why he do this or that. Just fucking stop, cause it’s fucking annoying.

    Like

  217. @ AIB – since everyone talks like it this – so if you do not like it do not watch –

    which is like saying

    Everyone shits so we are going to shit in public en-masse – if you do not like do not watch it!!!

    or

    Everyones parents have sex – so let us have someones parents have sex in public – if you do not like do not watch it!!

    or

    Women pee while sitting Men pee while standing …. you get the idea
    Oonche se Ooncha Banda Poti pe baithe nanga!

    It is good that there are some decent people left in the world otherwise there is only YoYo Honey Singh all around us.

    It is funny that we are all self-contradicting hypocrites of varying degrees, we just somehow manage to live with our hypocrisy – it stands for actors, AIB and this blogger ‘heart rajan’. So why is Amir not entitled to his hypocrisy – just accept what people say – why be judgemental? Maybe Heart Rajan loves Amir Khan and wants him to conform to what he is saying so that the love remains whole! Who knows?

    Hammam mein sab nange hain!

    Like

  218. Have u been reading my mind? This is exactly what i think. Delhi Belly and Ghajini are fine but screw AIB guys…..yeah screw them. Like you said, he is a complete douchebag.

    Like

  219. Mr Ranjan..
    You also looks like an IDIOT
    1. Aamir spoke on Narmada almost 6 months after the release of Rang De Basanti
    2. Nothing work is mentioned in 3 idiots, PK , TZP, etc..
    3. Regarding Chetan Bhagat.. He is an IIT IIM student. He himself states that he should have read the contract. If he is so educated, it is expected out of him not to be a part of such idiotic episode.
    4. AIB indeed is good for adult audience only. Please clarify that if you are a father and you have a 5 years old son/daughter, would you prefer him/her to watch AIB
    5. Aamir stated on the show that Dehli Belly is not meant for all age-group audience.

    He is so far the best bollywood actor who can represent himself as a nation ambassador.

    And please keep your mouth shut if you dont believe in his working style.

    Like

  220. It’s weird how u have just plucked the thoughts right out of my mind n put them across in so much more articulate manner. It was a lot of fun.
    And about AIB… enough already… Man, people need to grow up and grow a sense of humor!! **elaborate eye roll**

    Like

  221. Ha ha. nice dude! but chod do bechaare ko.
    Is dish ne sab dekha hai.
    Our uniqueness lies in not being pissed at anything at all.
    Come colonize us, come worship us. Desis be like….

    kabira khada bazar me,
    maange saki khair…
    na kahu se dosti,
    na kahu se bair!

    😉

    Like

  222. I guess you are confused dude !!! …. I prsonally enjoyed the AIB roast. He didnt. He saw a few clips and he didnt like it so he didnt watch it. Itni badi article likhney ki kya zaroorath thi, when all you wanted to tell was in the last few paragraphs.

    Anyway .. fuckl post but good writing though. You should write something that is non-fiction !

    Like

  223. Going by what Aamir actually said in the video which is that if you don’t like something, you tell that person firmly that you don’t like it rather than ban it, you have every right to criticise him for his remarks since that is the healthy sign of a democracy. However, I wonder if the issue here is getting a bit diluted in the strict polarisation that is happening here – between people who find that the show has hurt supposed moral sentiments vs people who are all for freedom of expression.

    While Aamir may be a pretentious prick or whatever you call him, I think the issues he raised in his talk were interesting. After watching AIB Roast and finding some of it funny and some of it offensive, I was thinking about the power of satire to either preserve the status quo or challenge it. The jokes made at someone being dark or being gay are definitely preserving the status quo in my opinion. Karan Johar, whose sexuality is not the norm, may have enjoyed the roast. But does that hold for all the people with alternative sexualities in this country? So, for me, Aamir did have a valid point in his criticism. Now whether he practises all that he preaches is an entirely different issue. But that could have been addressed after taking up the validity of the arguments he raised. You may agree with them, you may not, but I definitely think they are worth addressing before roasting Aamir Khan for voicing them.

    I take it that you find nothing offensive in AIB Roast since you seem to be saying nothing about the content. But as you may have guessed, there is a minority who found some of the jokes disturbing for other reasons than that they hurt our so called cultural values or is against Indian culture. Aamir’s arguments for me seem to reflect those of this minority whose views seem to be getting wiped out in this strictly polarised argument.

    Also how fair is to equate Aamir’s critiicism of the show with his looking down upon the artists involved in it? That leaves no room for any criticism other than a personal attack.

    At the end of it though, I think you could have made your point without attacking every single choice Aamir has made as an artist. And because of that, I get the nagging feeling that much of the ire directed at Aamir is not because he is looking down upon other artists (which is exactly what Russel Peters is doing calling acting something that does not involve any cerebral exercise beyond mugging up a few lines penned by others, something you don’t seem to have a problem with) just beacuse he criticised a show you liked.

    Like

  224. atleast amir khan does not have cases pending against him for killing blackbuck or constructed a ramp outside his house which he is not willing to take it down even though the BMC has asked him to do so. using fuck language is quite is ok, but its used in a stupid way. perhaps you should know when to use it. or are there no other issues for you? corruption, bad roads,encroachment etc ? probably you said FUCK all that. I need to chase amir khan for all the bitterness i have in my life.

    Like

  225. No matter how much you bat for AIB and for however long, Satymave Jayate is a far more important show than a 1000 AIBs put together. Period.
    Here’s my two cents-
    Aamir maybe a sucker for footage. He wants to come across as thinking, intellectual or whatnot.
    He might be pretentious, attention hungry, narcissistic, pseudo, self-righteous or whatever…But so is our current Prime Minister.
    The point is, let them hog all the attention in the world, but in the end some good should result out of it.
    He might be outright pretentious, that’s why he does sensationalist stuff to grind his own axe Or think a little deeper, in Aamir case this might even stem from the fact that he’s just a school educated chap, who wants to prove a point to the world or to himself, fight his own demons.

    Whatever it is, he is actually imparting a lot of information to (the masses, the havenots) that they do not know about and can be beneficial through Satyamev Jayate.

    However, your reading into the Satyamave Jayate banner was commendable. Looks like you’ve taken your Film appreciation course too seriously buddy!!

    Your whole argument hangs on a flimsy logic, laden with tons of ranting. In fact you don’t even have an argument here. You, my friend are either a mouthpiece for AIB, a hired gun or are just looking for a bit of fame. But the truth is you are the one who sound wayyy more pretentious than Aamir Khan here.

    Name one actor who takes his Social responsibility seriously. Satyamev Jayate is definitely touching lives.
    If Aamir is taking a profit home, then so be.
    On the other hand AIB is not even doing a goog job of creating humor. They have to rely on their crew’s obesity, looks, being catholic, some star presence and of course expletives. It is seriously unfunny.

    Like

  226. Have not verified the authenticity of some stuff written on here (Specially he not watching/reading stuff before commenting), but totally agree with a few things written on there. I agree our generation has made him a larger than life figure (as you can say from some of the replies posted on your write-up!

    I agree cent percent when you say (sarcastically) that Aamir Khan is a thinking man, a perfectionist etc. I swear his thoughtfulness only reflects from staring into the blank in most of his thoughts. And as for doing one movie at a time, reading his scripts, doing extensive preparation for it (which means working on his physical appearance) – AGREE- DUDE THAT IS EXACTLY WHAT YOU ARE BEING PAID IN CRORES FOR. I would do all of this too if I were being paid that amount. Nonetheless, I want to point out bro, that I liked Lagaan, 3 idiots & PK (albeit that he overdoes it towards the end in all these 3 movies)

    Coming back to Delhi Belly – yup that is how the youth talks (and thanks for promoting it all the more), but isn’t that what AIB was all about? Gross language and ‘grossdom’ on the whole. So why is it that AIB become bad for Aamir and Delhi Belly is fine! One the one hand Aamir stand for social issues, on the other he erodes India’s culture of suaveness in conversations by promoting movies like Delhi Belly. Such hypocrisy!

    And dude, you totally missed his other movie Dhobi Ghat. I swear I watched it 2 times to understand where people could relate to art there and I still could not get it, but I could not gather the courage to watch it the 3rd time to even understand the core of the movie.

    I could go on and on and on…but all I want to say is – Mr. Amir Khan, I liked a few of your movies, but trust me there are other good movies out there as well. The problem I have is with your PR stunts of self promotion. Trust me, lesser known actors do the exact same things – read their scripts, work on the appearance etc etc. The problem is that Indian crowd lacks the wisdom to give them as much hullabaloo and fan following.

    Like

  227. Awesome post….where is the Like button? I absolutely loved watching AIB Roast and wanna watch more and more of such shows. It was just entertainment, entertainment and entertainment !!

    All those doing moral policing must look at themselves first.

    PS….I loved watching Taare Zameen Par, Dhoom3 and many other movies of Amir (PK was a piece of shit though) But that does not mean he is a God-man or some kind of saint and will start moral policing.

    Like

  228. This is brilliantly written. Everything about Aamir Khan is spot on, and yet my favorite part was the perfect description of Chetan Bhagat, “the Rakhi Sawant of writing.”

    Love it!

    Like

    1. You are a lazy retard. You don’t have the brains to read between the lines. I said the show is commendable. Also, if you stopped being such a dumb ass, this article has got nothing to do with doing for the country. It’s to do with coming across as preachy and annoying.

      Do you always require someone to break things down to you? Are you in class 3, you judgemental asshole? On 27 Feb 2015 00:11, “Heartranjan's Blog” wrote:

      >

      Like

  229. May be what you wrote is your personal views on Amir Khan, But you sounded too harsh on him and is work. He is not pretentious at all, he is an artist and a social worker and deserves respect by all means. He is a creative person, reached heights of success due to his hard work and intelligence. none of his work should be speculated in a negative light.
    Rest we all are humans so we have some desires and wishes to excel, earn good wealth, nothing wrong with that, its natural. We all have flaws as well as some perfections.
    Do you have any personal animosity with everybody’s favorite ‘Amir Khan’

    Like

  230. Hey, want to say that this was probably your best work till date. Kudos to that! 🙂
    Seriously though, after going through some of the comments who totally misread the article to suit their particular beliefs, i really feel the need to applaud in public. I really hope that the world is better than what the comments all over the web tell me 😛

    Like

  231. people could forgive him his past (read: mela, bazee) … considering the gud acting he did in other films ..
    ignore his marketing gimmicks – cuz he experimented a bit with themes (not sticking to the strictly-commercial kinds)
    forgive him for being 2 preachy- cuz he hosted community-conscious shows, produced some offbeat flicks, etc
    all in all, he did a decent job with what he is in the industry …

    n wen he responded abt the AIB roast thing … he wore the ‘responsible me’ cap … n not the ‘creative me’ one..

    n the world is now divided over it ..

    people who felt the prick cuz dey believe in creative liberty of arts
    n people who think art comes with responsibility (n are in sync wid his response)..

    so it’s de battle between – being creative n being responsible .. and it’s a thin line 😉

    but after a while who cares what anybody else said .. what matters is what I /u think .. so take ur pick guys …
    ………..
    The way u wrote it is hilarious (lets keep the sentiments apart 🙂 ) and I like some phrases.. IQ of a garden lizard, staring into cosmos, African child etc..

    Like

  232. Pingback: Quora
  233. No Mans Land deserved to win. Lagaan had many flaws in it. If u have not seen the movie then dont write about it. No mans land is one of the finest movie created and Lagaan is the finest movie created in India, there lies the difference.

    People dont blindly listen to this writer as he has no studied his case properly and is writing on some assumptions.

    Thank u

    Like

  234. Oh my God….
    @Writer…..you seem to be under serious depression…..
    Your irritability quotient has gone too high…..consult a psychiatrist instead of cursing someone who is doing something good.
    Everyone has flaws..everyone makes mistakes…and that does not mean they can not express their opinion…if you are blaming him like this….apply the same barometer on you and judge yourself…..don’t be so pessimistic and instead of getting so much irked up by someone’s shortcomings, try and appreciate the goodness..

    Like

  235. What a stupid article and a sheer waste of time. Mr. Wise Guy Heartranjan should know that film industry is a commercial entity just like any other business. It’s not a non-profit charity where people are trying to be heroes by helping mankind. One must do what he has to do to earn money and market himself as a brand “that sells”.

    Like

  236. So all those who defend his “hypocrisy” (I will still call it that) to actually being “activism”, please go to Youtube and watch the “Fertilizer/Organic” episode of Satyamev Jayate. He had invited the Managing Director of the country’s largest producer of fertilizer and all he did was lynch him publicly without even Listening to the other guy’s side! He just wants people to Stick To The Script (like a true Actor that he is) and all that plastic “sincerity” he showed in screen…was all that he does best…Acting!

    Like

  237. Fortunate me I discovered your website unintentionally, and I’m stunned why this twist of fate did not take place earlier!
    I bookmarked it.
    Loved♥ by Hindinews24x.in

    Like

Leave a comment