“Sai Baba is dead, how do you feel?”

I have been asked this question incessantly over the last two days. Here’s my reply.

I was young when I joined the school in Puttaparthi. Too young to make sense of anything that was going on around me. My parents dropped a few hints, I loved the train journey, and before I knew it, I was in the school.

It was all a little too overwhelming at first. The mandir, the darshan, the bhajans, the lines, the lakhs of devotees. Before I could make sense, I fit in. There was a leitmotif of spirituality in everything in my life.

For ten years, my life revolved around Sai Baba and his teachings. I didn’t know if he was god or not. I didn’t have the time or courage to ask myself, and I didn’t feel the need to.

And then, I came out. It was when I realised there is a world beyond Puttaparthi. When I spoke of Sai Baba, they asked, “Which one? The bandana baba or the afro baba?” They asked me about my experience, and I could see the twinkle in their eyes.

“Does he create real gold chains?

“Did you get any?”

“Why doesn’t he create a huge oil pit so we don’t have to import it from Iraq and all?”

I began to question my own beliefs. Life took such a whirlwind spin after that, I barely had the time to think about such stuff. Somewhere along the line, I got disillusioned with religion, spirituality, and god.

It was not a conscious decision. I slowly realised that I only prayed when I was in trouble. Upon trying, I realised things turned out ok even if I did not pray.

I am not religious. Nor am I among those who say “I’m spiritual, but not religious”. I don’t know what that means. I just do what I like, and look for the maximum fun I can have while doing it. That pretty much sums up the philosophy of my life.

The years rolled on, and Puttaparthy became a fond memory. Of childhood, friends, and fear of sin.

Now, when people ask me how I feel about Sai Baba’s death, I don’t know what to say.

I don’t believe in God, but there are parts of me that have been irreparably influenced by Puttaparthi.

I never waste food. I am part of voluntary organisations that work for children. If someone needs help, I will do my best. Religion, caste and other such things don’t mean crap to me. I’m no Magsaysay nominee, but I will help a person in need, as much as I can.

Is he god? I don’t know. I don’t care. Is it even important?

It all depends on what you take away from someone’s work. While some say Sachin is the greatest batsman in the world, others say India loses when he scores a century. But haven’t we all called him god on our facebook status updates?

When I look back at Puttaparthi, it is not the huge mandirs that I remember. Not the string of dignitaries, the enviable fleet of cars, or the golden mandir in the ashram.

The image I remember is of a poor man waiting his turn in the general hospital. He is dark, his coarse hands folded in prayer, and tears flowing down his eyes.

I am educated, rational and pride myself for being responsible for my own fate. But that poor man?

His life has changed forever. His children and their children will have a livelihood. They will get access to drinking water, free medical treatment, and a good education.

If that man calls Sai Baba god, what is the harm??

49 thoughts on ““Sai Baba is dead, how do you feel?”

  1. It’s not what the perception of others and it matters what you believe.
    I’m happy to know a few good things in mail and I’m also one who never wastes food and personally,I never liked Sai baba because of incidents I heard(Ur blog makes me reflect that ‘I heard’) and this ‘unlike’ ness comes out through my vocal cords now and then but this blog questions me deeply.

    Baba has done good and the world knows that(of course,I till this second rationalized why has he done? and what good ness he wanted back?) and when I speak of another person of some stature in this world,people even sarcastically said,”You are turning…” and I simply couldn’t walk away.I thought but I learned when you are in a group, your own thoughts never matters only when what group’s image is matters.May be,same in your case as your thoughts differed from general sai devotees.
    Whatever, carry on your objectives of life and do things with enthu…!

    Like

    1. Well, Aravind. Like, I said, it depends what you want to take from someone’s life. It’s sad that we are still debating on whether he is God or not.

      To begin with, the concept of god in itself is ambigious. But you have to understand that way back in the 30s and 40s, there was no other way to mobilise large, (as you call them) crowds. They were illiterate, yes, and naive, yes. That’s why they fell for miracles, and stories. And he used their belief to transform their village beyond recognition. You can call it misguiding people, or mobilising them.

      Like

      1. good one dude….and Aravind.. I am glad you are re-thinking of the ‘I heard’ part. I have not come across anyone who has any direct experience/contact with another person who purportedly has been abused. It’s all based on someone no one knows!
        Hriday..good one dude!! When ppl ask me..I tell them I am not trying to convince them anything, but ask them to get their facts from a reliable source rather than wht they hear from somebody who heard from somebody who read somewhere written by somebody.

        Like

  2. though i live in the place till date, am least bothered in what others think of him….
    for I’ve no answer to the question of “GOD” itself…!!!
    But I found some answers, on the day when I’ve seen him suffer, and tears rolled down my cheeks, taking him as , I don’t know what……..!!
    All ur blogs that i read trough, molded ma own beliefs and experiences of him and the place, letting ma understand about the extravaganza.
    Very well crafted………and a good one…..(i know i don’t have to say that)
    thanks a lot…….. and keep striking….!!

    Like

    1. Of course you can! That’s the beauty of the concept of god. You could call a stone idol, a photo, a cricketer, or as you pointed out, even Hitler as God. A lot of people believed in Hitler’s mission, and volunteered to be a part of it. One of Hitler’s top priorities was the economy, that had been ravaged after World War I and the Treaty of Versailles. Unemployment was negligible in his reign, and his vision was to make Germany the most powerful country in the world.

      But are ends everything? Or do you think the means adopted to get there matter as well? Two of the most important reasons why Sai Baba’s mission is so successful are: 1. The importance of philanthropic activities. 2. The encompassing nature of it, i.e. you do not have to change your religion, god, or beliefs, and still be a part of the mission.

      For many people, feeding a poor man, or helping a cyclone struck village is an act that takes them closer to God, and they attribute the satisfaction that they get after such an act, as a feeling of divinity.

      Hitler, meanwhile, judged people by their race and creed, and killed millions ruthlessly in order to achieve what he wanted.

      Still feel like extrapolating my argument to call Hitler a god as well??

      Like

      1. Hitler — he was just a wild example, by the way — had is means, and they were mostly ingenuous and candid.
        He wanted people’s blind faith. He wanted subservience. He wanted control.
        Yes, Sai Baba’s means were different: his tools being the G-word, religion, and some sleigh of hand to top it up. All except the last one being in the realm of transcendence.
        The end result is blind faith, subservience and total control over your mind.
        He may not be killing physically. These are not the times of Inquisition or The Crusades. Phew, let’s not talk about genocide at these times!! You don’t want to die in a prison in Hague or be caught in a bunker and hanged in public shame.

        And I also find the paragraph snipped below to be extremely disdainful of the poor. Why don’t you want to give him the tools that make you rational and critical? Why do you want to leave him to the mercy of Gods begging for free food, water and medical care? Why can’t he be a master of his fate?

        The image I remember is of a poor man waiting his turn in the general hospital. He is dark, his coarse hands folded in prayer, and tears flowing down his eyes.

        I am educated, rational and pride myself for being responsible for my own fate. But that poor man?

        His life has changed forever. His children and their children will have a livelihood. They will get access to drinking water, free medical treatment, and a good education.

        Like

        1. Well, I’d be more careful in giving examples then, to avoid sounding like a buffoon.

          I don’t know who you are, but you have the wrong ideas dude. I have witnessed a number of spiritual leaders in my life, and trust me, Sai Baba is the most ‘chilled’ among them all, if I could put it that way.

          You clearly have never been there, but have chosen to bless us with your intellectualism, with your usage of words like subservience and mind-control. Never has Sai Baba asked his devotees to fast, do a penance, follow a ritual, or have blind faith in anything. He does not ask people to contribute to his mission, the only thing he asks them to do is go out and serve people. All the efforts and contributions go into doing something like feeding the hungry for a day, or something on those lines. I know feeding beggars for a day is not going to solve the hunger problem in India, but that is the connect which people feel with him, and attribute it to god. In all our families, people worship idols and photographs, but we never bothering telling our family members anything. But dissing someone online? Boy, that’s so much fun. I really don’t know where the ideas of subservience came to you.

          Your last paragraph about making the poor man responsible for his own fate is laughable, if not downright stupid. Its exactly the idealistic crap that is dished out to sound intellectual.

          Before the mission, Puttaparthy and the entire Anantapur district was among the most arid districts in the country. There were no hospitals in a 250 kms radius, and the district had one of the most cases of children dying due to hunger, malnutrition, lack of water, and lack of medical facilities.

          Now you are telling me, the way to improve the situation would have been by getting all the people literate (discounting the fact that there were no real schools in the region), making them aware of their rights, transforming them into rational and critical people, and thus giving them the tools to be a master of his own fate. You are a laugh riot, mate.

          How many years would that have taken? And the poor man did not ‘beg’ to be provided all that. No one did.

          Like

      2. Relax, mate. I came across your blog and thought I’d have a constructive argument. You sounded receptive in your first reply; apparently you’re not.
        I could argue with statistics if you require, but sorry, now, I don’t have the time for it. πŸ™‚
        Wishing you luck!

        Like

        1. πŸ™‚ Sorry if I sounded unreceptive.

          I would loved to have the discussion going, but its ok. You are welcome to your opinions.

          But as a final word, I would like to say that I was there, where you are. For eight years, I hated everything about the place. I was ashamed to be associated with the place, and extremely critical of many things followed there.

          But a few months back, I wanted some volunteers for some work, and I realised how difficult it is to motivate even a few people to do something. That was when I began to respect him for what he has done. There have been so many ‘god-men’ or spiritual leaders. How many of them can you say have done substantially for the people around them?

          I think you are under the assumption that Puttaparthi is a place brimming with myopic, bigoted, superstitious people who have fallen for the ‘g-word’. It is not. There are many who go to the place just for the calmness of the place. So then all the people must be fools? The media, the politicians, the thousands of middle-class people, the scientists, economists, all those people. They must be dumb, right??

          It depends on what you want to take away from the person’s life. The work that he did, or the holy-ash he claimed to create. You chose the latter, me the former.

          Like

  3. Very well written Ranjan.

    And I can not help but reply to Mr/ Ms ‘xyz’. As Ranjan pointed out its individual perception. You may call Hitler a God and nobody would stop you but the greatest gift that time gives us is the Hindsight. In Hindsight what people remember of Hitler is ‘Auschwitz’ and what people remember of Sai Baba is ‘Tolerance’.

    Like

  4. That stuck a cord !!….I am having a hard time figuring you out. I remember many rajans…Sunder rajan, P gunaranjan, Sai gunaranjan….r u on facebook ? Not sure if you remember me though…I was there from 1-9 class.

    ” Upon trying, I realised things turned out ok even if I did not pray.” …haha..

    Like

  5. This nearly made me cry. If Loka ma’m read this, you’d be a celebrity. It sums up not just mine, but everyone’s feelings!.

    Like

  6. I read this and those 7 years in Puttaparthi (1985-1992) came flooding back to me. Reading your post felt like I was hearing myself speak aloud. You’ve captured the feelings, thoughts and many unstated things so well – without really going overboard.

    Definitely sharing this on my FB profile and use words to express and share my feelings. Thanks for giving a voice and adding a perspective to my thoughts and feelings!

    Like

  7. At the right time you have struck the right cord. Nice write up. But, one thing for sure – ppl have this tendency of finding good in every dead man’s life…..should i suppose this piece of work as outcome of that attitude?
    I heard his deeds were good but ways were wrong. I want to emphasize on “I heard ” thing here.

    Like

    1. Yeah, I’d heard a lot of things too. I stayed there for ten years, but haven’t met anyone who had seen or experienced any sort of exploitation there. It doesn’t even matter to me.

      I’d rather believe the many things I saw, than a few things I heard. And is this an article that tends to find good in every dead man’s life?

      Well, I did not write a blog on Jyoti Basu, if that is any indication!!

      Like

  8. Hi Ranjan,

    This is the first time i am taking the trouble of commenting upon anything written by numerous people in different blogs…….but you simply compelled me to!!

    Reading your comments and more importantly after going through the comments of others in similar positions, atleast i am relieved to think that i am not alone who harboured such inexplicable thoughts that has bothered me through the adolescent stages and into adulthood…..

    Maybe as our primary school teachers rightly pointed out then, we din’t realise what we were receiving at that time…….and today as we look back memories come flooding back as if from a distant past never lived!!!

    Exceptionally well written……….felt almost like an echo…………..!!

    Like

  9. HeartRanjan and Xyz…dont know who you are however I have studied in Parthi for 9 years too…I call it the divine years. I think the biggest mistake Heartranjan you are doing is explaining and justifying to people like xyz and Abhishek and God knows how many hundreds or millions of them. All I can say is Silence is bliss and what one believes will remain with them and go with them.

    As Sai student we only need to believe that God is in us and He exists in our Hearts as simply put by Swami. Whether God exists or not is a personal opinion and one can go on indefinetly debating about it. What is important is that we have always been taught the right values to believe that God is one and no discrimination exists between religion, caste or creed.

    I have always been and will always be proud to have even experienced those divine years.

    Like

  10. Hriday..
    I guess after one attempt, it’s not worth your time to try and convince anonymous intellectual sounding economists who want to have constructive arguments over things they have not directly experienced/seen and want to disprove faith with statistics from God knows where!

    Like

  11. Simple, straightforward article.
    Reflects the common musings of so many of us, from varied backgrounds, confused through the growing years, first disillusioned with religion and miracles ……then again, as we grow older, striking a cord with so many peaceful, loving and meaningful teachings of those same religions……

    Truly, who cares if he was God or not? He just taught the right things (I heard :)! )

    Like

  12. Oh, by the way….LOVED your replies to ‘xyz’! πŸ™‚

    I think ‘xyz’, CAN be a decently good intellectual, if he only stops trying so hard! There’s nothing wrong with having idealistic thoughts …….but it so truly becomes ‘idealistic crap’ when not tempered with practicality. Sai baba was probably most practical – using his miracles or whatever else (that i’ve only HEARD of) to get masses to support and lend an extending hand to strangers!

    Like

  13. Again well written … you do have a lot of truth/reality in your blogs!!!
    Seeing and believing holds over hearing and believing which many people do not get about Swami.Liked how you say whether god exists or not does not matter but what good we ve learnt out of being there really matters.And that goodness has definitely rubbed off on you and m proud bout that fact.You do make HIS ideal student by doing the good which is what counts and each of us know what those early years has done to us as we live our every day lives.

    Like

  14. my batchmates were p.sai gunaranjan,manish koirala…a boy from greece named jay..my teachers were vaidehi ,anantalakshmi….i studied from 1 to 5…does any one know me?please leave a reply.i am eager to meet my friends…my email pvnreddy84@gmail.com…bye

    Like

  15. Ur blog helped me put things in prospective after so many months of the incident. Very well written. From the heart yet very practical.

    Like

  16. Heart Ranjan Bro ! I got introduced to your blog today by my Bro about Emoticons and was instantly connected with its humour! It was a pleasant reveleation to see that you have a backgound I never would ve made out from your blogs! You are blessed with such a wonderful narration. Keep it up bro πŸ™‚ Just a word of love that I always feel sharing to Bros from that Place…’ Don’t forget that Person who has created irreparable impact on you’ .. All the best !

    Like

  17. Puttaparthi was the place where my grandparents stayed till I turned 12. So every summer and Dussehra, a trip to Puttaparthi was a must. I used to tell my friends about the neatness, the niceness and the really great smell of the place. All shops had this same agarbathi + vibhoothi smell which was intoxicating. As I grew up, many friends started ridiculing me for ‘believing’ in Baba. I ignored them, of course. And then my grandpa passed away and all my uncles and aunts cajoled grandma to leave the place and stay with them. So Maamma moved out of Puttaparthi, left the small one BHK on SBI Road. Since then, I have never been there. And so, the small corner of my heart that always got excited when I caught sight of Baba in his orange robes everyday, faded little by little until nothing was left.

    Maamma bawled her eyes out when she heard Swami was no more. I didn’t have any reaction. So I did question my beliefs and asked myself the same questions that my friends used to ask me. the truth is, I always loved that place. The Sai Kulwant Hall with the mesmerizing Bhajans by Raviraj Naseri, ‘Embodiments of Love’, the translation of Baba’s speeches by Anil Kumar, the cushioned chair like things that many people used to use to sit down for the Bhajans (I always wanted one of those!), the hushed whispers of the Seva Dal, and above all, the Godman in his orange robes, who used to come wobbling down the ramp, (later in a battery driven car); everything. I used to love that place, and I think even now, if I concentrate, I can smell the unique agarbathi + vibhoothi smell on the streets. Puttaparthi. πŸ™‚

    Thank you for bringing back so many fond memories, Hriday! πŸ™‚

    Like

  18. Lovely perspective.

    I loved what you said in your reply to the Hitler thingy too, and the part about getting volunteers to serve – so damn right. That realisation gave me a new found respect for sai organisations too. To me – simply love is god and He was someone who said that.

    Like

  19. Nice job Hriday, I just got to know of your blog. I am the kind of guy who normally stops at “me like” ,but your blog compels me to be a little verbose- Good work little buddy. BTW I know you from primary school. God bless πŸ™‚

    Like

Leave a comment